This week’s full episode is for QAV Club members only. You can listen to one of our free episodes by clicking the below podcast archives link and opening up our pages on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or watch clips on TikTok. Or visit our homepage to learn more about QAV and how it works as a value investing system that you can learn and apply to beat the market.
As a sneak peak, here’s Tony’s pulled pork on a fairly new entrant on our buy list — Symal Group Limited (SYL). They are an Australian construction and infrastructure services company founded in 2015 and listed on the ASX in 2023. The business provides civil, building, and utilities construction services across public and private sectors, with operations spanning roads, bridges, renewable energy projects, and industrial facilities.
**Overview**
This episode we dig through a packed week in markets, portfolios, commodities, gold trends, sovereign risk, Michael Burry’s fund closure, Warren Buffett’s farewell letter, QAV Light’s monster performance, the ASX correction, and a full pulled-pork deep dive on SYL (Symal Group). We also cover ANZ’s result, gold’s de-dollarisation tailwinds, Karoon’s changing leadership, MTO’s registration-duty misstep, and three recent rocket-ships on the buy list. The episode ends with film and TV talk: Tarkovsky, Guinness, and Slow Horses.
—
**Timestamps & Topics (with tickers)**
**00:00** – Intros, Kung Fu exhaustion, black belt confusion
**00:02** – QAV Light performance update: +19.99% p.a.; SPDR: +10.10%
**00:04** – Portfolio-by-portfolio rundown:
**00:08** – Market correction & AFR “dash-for-trash” article
**00:10** – Macquarie strategist claims loss-makers outperforming
**00:11** – QAV six-month numbers vs benchmark
**00:12** – Trump tariffs, beef, coffee, agricultural impacts
**00:14** – US shutdown backlog, delayed statistics, Fed uncertainty
**00:17** – ANZ full-year results
**00:19** – Gold: de-dollarisation, BRICS buying, ETF flows
**00:23** – Perseus Mining CEO retirement & sovereign risk discussion
**00:27** – Michael Burry shuts Scion; Nvidia puts disaster
**00:28** – Buffett’s final letter: selling $1.4B in stock, legacy, life advice
**00:33** – Karoon Energy CEO change
**00:36** – Motorcycle Holdings (MTO) trading halt for underpaid vehicle reg duty
**00:39** – Three standouts on the buy list
**00:41** – Commodity update
**00:43** – Pulled Pork: SYMAL (SYL)
**00:57** – Film chat: Tarkovsky’s *Stalker* and the cursed production
**01:00** – Guinness drama series, Slow Horses, Down Cemetery Road
**01:02** – TK’s racehorse “Charlie 99”
**01:04** – Wrap-up & disclosures
Transcription
Cameron: [00:00:00] Welcome back to QAV Australia. Tony Eson, episode 8 46. It’s the 18th of November, 2025. How you doing
tk,
Tony Kynaston: well, thank you. How are you?
Cameron: dude, I am, I’m good. But, uh, last week, man, I don’t know something’s going on. I’ll see how I go at kung fu tonight, but last week I’d get on the mat and five minutes into the cardio and I’d be, I’d be like wrecked, uh, dragging my ass around for the next hour or two or three.
Dunno what was going on. Anyway, hopefully it was just a bug of some sort.
Tony Kynaston: Hmm?
Cameron: Um, but yeah, you know, you just have those days or it was a few days when I was just like, oh my God, what’s wrong with me? You know, like normally I’m, you know, king of the hill last week I was just, had to walk off and sit on the side and yeah.
Thought I was gonna pass out. Dunno what was wrong with me. Uh, for the record, got a nice email from one of [00:01:00] our longtime subscribers, Andy this morning said, congratulations on your black belt. Not a black belt. Just wanna put that, I dunno how that got out there yet. My next grading is the black, our next grading, Chrissy.
Mine is the black belt. We’re not black belts yet. We’re just, I had a black eye that’s not a black belt. You shouldn’t confuse the two few black eyes on the way to the black belt. But, uh, yeah.
Tony Kynaston: what happens when you both get black belts around your place? Is it just like, what’s that? What was that? Brad Pitt and Angela in Rolley movie, Mr. And
Cameron: Mr. And Mrs. Smith. Yeah,
Tony Kynaston: Is it like that? Here I’ll cut
Cameron: well, yeah, yeah, yeah,
Tony Kynaston: I got it
Cameron: yeah. No, we’re both just sort of trying to keep ahead of Fox.
Tony Kynaston: right.
Cameron: his goal is to have a black belt. By the time he’s 16, there’s another four to five years. So,
Tony Kynaston: It’s every boy’s dream to take on their father, isn’t it?
Cameron: yeah,
Tony Kynaston: the
Cameron: he’s already, he’s already trying to do it, so, yeah. Hey, um, speaking of, uh, long term discipline, man, QAV light, [00:02:00] absolutely killing it. Um, I did a light update yesterday and I said, fortune favors the patient and the disciplines not fortune favors the bold as I used to quote Napoleon, but I think it was a, uh, it was a Roman poet Terrence, who first said that
Tony Kynaston: Ah,
Cameron: in his play, Foria, because the QAV Lights portfolios are killing it at the moment. Tony, um, let me just bring up,
Tony Kynaston: I thought there was fortune Favors The Brave, which is the SA British SAS model.
Cameron: yeah, well they just borrowed that off. Napoleon,
Tony Kynaston: Uh.
Cameron: uh, I dunno, the, uh, QAV Light Group. All times. That’s the four portfolios all bundled together. Uh, as of right now, today, up 19.999% per annum [00:03:00] versus the SPDR 200, up 10 point 10%. So double market for the light group portfolios all time. Uh, this calendar year up 32.83% versus the SPDR up eight and a half percent.
Tony Kynaston: That’ll help.
Cameron: It will help. Um, and as well, you know, I’m sure all of our listeners know the light portfolios were just in the dogs up until the middle of this year, honestly. Well, no, they’re in the dogs. A couple of years ago, by the middle of this year, they’d caught up. And then, and I’ve heard you say this so many times over the years, you’ll, you know,
Tony Kynaston: And yet you
Cameron: it just,
Tony Kynaston: when it
Cameron: no, it just takes six months.
And, and you know, I, as I said in, I said to our subscribers, look, you know, [00:04:00] I know we’ll have tough times. The market’s gonna have a correction. It’s already have in a correction we’ll talk to about in a minute, according to some people. But you know, if I look at the dummy portfolio, once we got that lead, uh, after COVID, even though it’s come down, it sort of maintained a healthy margin between the index.
Like it lost a little bit coming out of, you know, that, that into that 22 period, 2022 period. But it’s still maintained a good lead. Um, if I look at the individual portfolios, which I haven’t done yet, so this could be a big shock, the 2, 2, 1 portfolio, that was the first one that I started at, beginning of 2022, that at one point.
In 20, middle of 2023 was down 10% versus the SPDR, which was up five. So it was underperforming by 15%. It’s ahead now, but just it’s 9.17 versus 8.94. So it’s just caught up after whatever that is. [00:05:00] Years. Um, two point, the second portfolio that I started a few months later, it is now 18% versus eight, or since it started eight, uh, per annum.
This is, um, the third portfolio is 21% per annum versus 10.8 for the SPDR. And the last one is 22.4% per annum versus 10.41. So the first one is caught up, the other three are killing it.
Tony Kynaston: hmm.
Cameron: Uh, double market for the other three, and somehow it’s pulls the whole lot up. So, um. I’m so happy about that because not that I was really concerned that I was doing something wrong, but you know, it was concerning that it was just looked so bad for the first couple of years.
But, um, there you go. It’s now demonstrating that, you know, the system just works if you just [00:06:00] stay disciplined, stay focused. Even a dummy like me can do it and it, and even with four and that’s, you know, four portfolios. Like we not one of 10 to 20 stocks, but there’s, I dunno, 60 to 80 stocks in that, you know, then I dunno they’re all got 20, but there’s 60 to 80 stocks in there probably.
Uh, while I’m at it, let’s look at the dummy portfolio. Um
Tony Kynaston: t‑shirts made up with Fortuna, Pati, ette on them.
Cameron: Oh, okay.
Tony Kynaston: Fortune favors the patient.
Cameron: Do you remember the, the one with Latin on it that I had, that I wore on our last Europe trip?
Tony Kynaston: Is that the, um. yes, I do. The one, um, Vince Vindo. Vince, uh, something like that? No, depar. Sio.
Cameron: No, I’m not gonna say what it was because it was disgusting. But it was in Latin.
Tony Kynaston: Oh, I thought you
Cameron: Yeah.
Tony Kynaston: know the one you mean. Yeah,
Cameron: Yeah,
Tony Kynaston: was disgusting, [00:07:00] but it was in
Cameron: it was just, it was in Latin and I was waiting for someone in Italy to sort of recognize it and call me out on it. No one did.
Tony Kynaston: But you had
Cameron: Um,
Tony Kynaston: being blown up, didn’t you? From the, I think it was the Caesar podcast, the
Cameron: something being
Tony Kynaston: or, anyway,
Cameron: oh, oh,
Tony Kynaston: digress.
Cameron: oh oh. Are you talking about when they burn thing Go forio?
Tony Kynaston: Rio.
Cameron: No. Forio? No, I don’t think I had a forio one. The, uh, dummy portfolio, uh, has been running, oh, hold on. That’s not the right end date. Oh, god dammit. Let me get to the right end date. So 2nd of September, 2019 to, what is the date today? The 18th?
I’ll do it to the 17th. Uh, 17.24% per annum versus 8.2% per annum. So better than double market, um, over that period. Just [00:08:00] so, uh, yeah, like, uh, very happy about that current calendar year for the dummy portfolio, by the way, up 27%. Versus eight and a half for the index. So best stock in the dummy portfolio this last, this current current calendar year, PRN up 97%, SRG, up 95% PPM up 60 PLT up, 55 SRV up, 53.
Just a bonkers, absolutely bonkers year.
Tony Kynaston: It has been, hasn’t it? Maybe we’re getting ahead of ourselves and going the early crow here. ’cause the market is turning down a bit, but we’ll see.
Cameron: Well,
Tony Kynaston: allowed
Cameron: this is the time,
Tony Kynaston: Yeah.
Cameron: this is the time to,
Tony Kynaston: a crow.
Cameron: to grow. We may not be able to do it in a month. Yeah. So the financial review I was reading this morning, uh, says that there’s a correction. This is sh clear. Uh, the ASX 200 has fallen for six days straight and is off [00:09:00] more than 5% in less than a month. Indeed, the case that a pullback may actually be healthy is further strengthened when we look at what’s Dr.
Driven the market over the past six months. To put it bluntly, it’s been a dash for trash.
Tony Kynaston: Hmm. And that’s not how we’ve overachieved. That’s, that’s what the market’s doing.
Cameron: Yes, this is, um, he’s quoting some Macquarie Bank guy here, but, uh, Macquarie’s local strategist, Matthew Brooks argues we are in a style bizaro world where the stocks that usually do well are struggling and the losers are winning. I’m like, really? Because our stocks are doing great.
Tony Kynaston: Yeah.
Cameron: I don’t, and they’re not losers.
Tony Kynaston: the only bizarre thing about them is that people haven’t heard of them. People don’t
Cameron: And that you, the only bi bizarre thing is that you think it’s bizaro because they’re good stocks. The best performed style of the past six months is actually loss making companies according to this guy, loser loss makers, defined by [00:10:00] Macquarie’s Quant team, as companies with higher risk and weaker initial momentum delivered a staggering return of 41.7% over the period while companies posting negative numbers at the net profit and cash flow line up 21, 26 0.1% on average.
So, uh, let me see. Last six months, uh,
Tony Kynaston: too, haven’t we? Must have been four years ago. Three, four years ago. I think I even did a couple of shows about inverting QAV and seeing if that would work better than QAV.
Cameron: yeah,
Tony Kynaston: And
Cameron: you did.
Tony Kynaston: it, did for a while and then it came crashing down. ’cause when the market turns, those stocks
Cameron: Yeah,
Tony Kynaston: and down the mine shaft. Down the elevator shaft.
Cameron: hi. Comparison. Our last six months in the dummy portfolio is up 26% versus 6.4 for the benchmark. So he’s saying those [00:11:00] posting negative numbers at the net profit and cash flow line line up 26%. Well guaranteed that none of the, uh, QAV stocks fit that description and they’ve done 26% too.
Tony Kynaston: don’t even
Cameron: I should,
Tony Kynaston: filter, do they? We don’t even
Cameron: should reach out to CLE and say, hey.
Tony Kynaston: Yeah. If anyone has a contact into the AFR, let us know. We’re happy to talk
Cameron: Yeah.
the other article that I saw, I’m not sure if I sent you this one. Um, investors can forget Trump’s tariff war, but, but where is next move?
Tony Kynaston: What? The release
Cameron: Have.
Tony Kynaston: files or as they’re also known the The Epstein redactions.
Cameron: Yeah.
Tony Kynaston: Yeah.
Cameron: Well they, there are no Epstein foes. They told us a few months ago, don’t exist. It’s all a big Democrat hoax. Now they’re gonna release them and he’s told Pam Bondi to particularly look into the Democrats. ’cause when the Democrats created the hoax, they made it all [00:12:00] about the Democrats who were.
Involved with Epstein? I don’t know. Sure. Trump sees a logical throughput there through line there somewhere. Uh, having insisted for months that tariffs would not increase prices, the Trump administration has begun slashing agricultural tariffs to try to reduce what Americans are paying for groceries on Thursday night.
Trump said many food products from Argentina, Ecuador, Guatemala, and El Salvador would be exempted from levies. After they agreed to trade frameworks with the US a day later, he moved to lower tariffs on beef, coffee, and dozens of agricultural and food goods, including from countries that haven’t done a trade deal that includes tariffs on good old Australian beef.
The two real hotspots have become the prices for beef, which sits at record highs in America, and coffee, which has surged more than 41% in the past 12 months, mainly due to the 50% tariff Trump imposed on Brazil
Tony Kynaston: But
Cameron: every time
Tony Kynaston: the
Cameron: I go out.
Tony Kynaston: down.
Cameron: Oh, he [00:13:00] has.
Tony Kynaston: I heard
Cameron: Right,
Tony Kynaston: about this. think it was
Cameron: right. Didn’t we talk about that on a US podcast a few weeks ago?
Tony Kynaston: No, this was only in the last week.
Cameron: Oh right. But we did talk about eggs. We talked about a big egg company over there. Remember?
Tony Kynaston: Oh,
Cameron: Can’t remember who it was now
Tony Kynaston: yeah, yeah,
Cameron: and how the egg prices had gone up when there was bird flu and all of that kind of stuff. And then they came back down. But I think they’re still his higher than they have been historically.
It’s like four bucks a carton or something over there.
Tony Kynaston: yeah. Well, Trump’s claiming he solved the egg problem, but of course, that’s not where the problem is now. It’s in, it’s in beef. And the American, the American farmers are up in arms because, uh, they’re being flooded with, with beef now. ’cause the tariffs are being lowered. They thought they were getting a good deal and being protected. Now they’re not. So they’re upset.
Cameron: Uh, well, the reason I mentioned the trough thing is because, um. The guy from Macquarie, Matthew Brooks also said that he thought that, um, [00:14:00] some of the slowdown in our market was because of the shutdown in the US and the tariffs and all of that kinda stuff. And now that the shutdown is over and the tariffs are being pulled back, that, uh, it, it might help our market recover, but
Tony Kynaston: I
Cameron: eh,
Tony Kynaston: because it’s
Cameron: yeah.
Tony Kynaston: I think it’s also part of, um, what’s holding us back is, is partly the shutdown, but not the way first think of it as being the shutdown. It’s because no one did any work on statistics over there. ’cause they weren’t getting paid. so all the key stats in the in the US are about a month behind.
So people are just not prepared to invest until they see what payrolls are Like what CPIs like whether the fed’s gonna cut, the fed’s gonna raise. We’ve seen this before. I mean, probably one of the hardest times to be an investor since we’ve been doing QAV was when the RBA started raising interest rates. And you know, a lot of the noise in Australia is, we’ve seen the last cut. And so [00:15:00] people are gun shy and if the US is in the same situation, which some analysts are doing their own numbers and saying that the, the, the Fed may be on hold for longer than people think, then we’re gonna see the end of easy money.
And then all those companies which don’t make a profit, gets sold off. And the loans get repaid before the interest rates go up.
Cameron: Well, the good thing from our perspective is it doesn’t matter, right?
Tony Kynaston: doesn’t matter. No, that’s right.
Cameron: Well, it it does in a way like when. I mean, we lost half of our listeners when the, when the interest rates went up. You know, it was interesting watching people who were not able to, well, I assume, I dunno why they disappeared, but at least half of our, nearly half of our membership, I think, disappeared in 22, 23 when the market was struggling.
Um, dunno why. Maybe there was a variety of reasons, but, um, I think a lot of people pulled their money outta the share market and, you know, I got emails from people saying they were buying a [00:16:00] house or they were doing this or doing that. But, uh, yeah, people do get affected when the market has a correction
Tony Kynaston: Oh, absolutely. Or when interest rates go up and they both are inter interlinked, I guess,
Cameron: connected. Yeah.
Tony Kynaston: But as
Cameron: What else?
Tony Kynaston: I wish, you know, wish I could read all the economic data and predict the future, but it’s not possible.
Cameron: And Well, I was talking to somebody. Oh yeah, I had a guy over here, a friend from country the other day. We were talking about investing and he was, you know, asking, you know, what you thought about, you know, what was happening in the US and what was gonna happen. And I said, you know, Tony’s thing is we don’t, we don’t try and forecast the future, right?
We just play it day by day. Let the system tell us what to do.
Tony Kynaston: Yep.
Cameron: Hmm.
Tony Kynaston: the dealt.
Cameron: Yeah. What you got on your list of things to talk about? Tk? I got more, but I thought I’d throw to you for a bit.
Tony Kynaston: I have. quite a few because we did an interview last week and [00:17:00] I’ve got a few stories backed up. I’ll try and get through them quickly.
Cameron: Tony’s a little bit backed up. People you need to have more fiber. Tony Chia seeds
Tony Kynaston: try.
Cameron: here, like green smoothies with chia seeds is what I recommend. And Soum husk soluble and insoluble fiber.
Tony Kynaston: Is that what you are drinking?
Cameron: Yep. Yeah, yeah.
Tony Kynaston: you are backed up as well.
Cameron: No, no. I’ve got lots of fiber. I know they get backed up running like smooth. I am.
Tony Kynaston: Uh, okay.
Cameron: Anyway, moving. Load along.
Tony Kynaston: right along. I’m not backed up. uh, had their full year results. I own shares in a NZ that’s been on the buy list for a long time. Uh, the market actually responded okay to it. Um, they’ve, the, the shares have gone next dividends, so they’ve come off a little bit price wise, but they, they’ll pay a reasonable dividend yield. Um, takes a, a month or so to do that for some reason. I can [00:18:00] never understand why banks take a long time to pay dividends. I guess that’s why they’re profitable anyway. Um. The company reported MPA of 5.79 billion, which was down 14% year on year. But that was largely due to redundancy and legal costs. The new CEO Mr. Mattos is shaking things up, but it’s costing some money to do that. Underlying cash profit though was 6.9 billion, which was the head of consensus. So it wasn’t a bad result. I think people are giving Mr. Mattos, Nunno, mattos the benefit of the doubt, and they like what he’s doing and they’ll see what happens.
So, um, I mean, it’s, it was pretty widely covered that result, but it, uh, wasn’t too bad. And a NZ has been the best performing of the bank stocks this year. Um, the only one on the QAV list this year. And at the same time, CBA is off 20%. As people start to realize that CBA was the most overvalued banking bank in the world in history. It’s, [00:19:00] it’s the analysis
This section is for QAV Club Members only.
Register for your 14-day free QAV Club trial here.
If you’re already a QAV Club member and seeing this message, please login via the top menu.
If you’re a QAV Light member who wants to upgrade to QAV Club, go to your Account page (see Footer) and upgrade from there.
Bernard: Q A V is a [01:04:00] checklist-based system of value investing developed by Tony Khyneston. over 25 years. To learn more about how it works and how you can learn the system, visit our website, Q A V Podcast dot com dot A U.
This podcast is an information provider and in giving you product information we are not making any suggestion or recommendation about a particular product. The information has been prepared without taking into account your individual investment objectives, financial circumstances or needs. Before you decide whether or not to acquire a particular financial product you should assess whether it is appropriate for you in the light of your own personal circumstances, having regard to your own objectives, financial situation and needs. You may wish to obtain financial advice from a suitably qualified adviser before making any decision to acquire a financial product. Please note that all information about performance returns is historical. [01:05:00] Past performance should not be relied upon as an indicator of future performance; unit prices and the value of your investment may fall as well as rise. The results are general advice only and not personal product advice.
Transparency is important to us. We will always be very open and honest about the stocks we own. We will also always give our audience advance notice when we intend to buy or sell a stock that we are going to talk about on the podcast. This is so we can never be accused of pumping a stock to our own advantage. If we talk about a stock we currently own, we will make it known that we own it.
This email is authorised by Anthony Khyneston. Authorised Representative Number zero zero 1 2 9 2 7 1 8 of M F & Co. Asset Management Proprietary Limited (A F S L five 2 zero 4 4 2). No part of this content may be reproduced in any form without the prior consent of Spacecraft [01:06:00] Publishing.
Quote of the day: “truth is an accurate representation of reality”, Nexus, Yuval Noah Harari

0 Comments