
In this episode of the QAV Value Investing podcast, we discuss RSG’s recent settlement with the Malian government, the acquisition of MWY, the volatile nature of the lithium market, adding accrual accounting to our checklist, and zombie companies on the ASX 300.
Transcription
QAV Club 747
[00:00:00] TK: one, two, three.
[00:00:13] TK: Is that what you meant? Is that how you said
[00:00:15] TK: it?
[00:00:17] CR: Never boring. Never boring with you, Kynaston.
[00:00:20] TK: I know, life’s gotta be like
[00:00:23] TK: that, right? I
[00:00:25] CR: episode 747 brought to you by Qantas. I actually bought some Qantas today. Um, Mark, it’s had a good week. Tony, you’re back in, uh, Sydney. You’ve gone up to support Alan Jones, I believe, in his, uh, difficult times. You wanted to be close, because you’re good personal friends with Alan Jones. You were telling me off air you met him at a racing to do once upon a time, and, um,
[00:00:53] TK: did, yeah, many years
[00:00:55] CR: He kept his
[00:00:55] TK: was wearing a, he was one of the few people back then who was wearing a pink. What do you call it when they have a handkerchief poking out
[00:01:05] TK: of the top left hand pocket of their suit jacket?
[00:01:07] CR: Is that when the investigators pulled him aside and said, uh, Alan Come in for questioning?
[00:01:16] TK: No, no, no, no. It was a social function. No, no. I, I, every time I see Ellen Jones, I just think back to those Raw and HG shows when they talked about the
[00:01:25] TK: parrot. That was their nickname for
[00:01:27] CR: Oh, really? I don’t remember
[00:01:28] CR: that.
[00:01:29] TK: Yeah. Yeah. It’s a running gag about coaching the Australian rugby union side with a parrot on his shoulder.
[00:01:36] TK: He used to call him the
[00:01:37] CR: Because he’s a pirate?
[00:01:39] TK: I don’t know. It was just like a running joke, but like it was so lost in time. He never knew why,
[00:01:45] TK: what it
[00:01:46] CR: Right, yeah, right. Well, unlike Alan Jones, the market’s had a good week. It dipped a little bit after the Trump bump, but then it’s come back. Who hasn’t had a good week, though? Really, the CEO and other guys at RSG. Or me, along with them. So, RSG, we mentioned, I think. Yeah. Last week, or maybe it happened after last week, did we?
[00:02:10] CR: They went into a trading
[00:02:11] TK: No, we mentioned that, we talked about it last week,
[00:02:13] CR: Oh, and I held it. Then They went into a trading halt. They came out of the trading halt yesterday morning when the company announced that they had agreed to pay 160 US million dollars to the Malian government, about 250 million Australian. CEO still hadn’t been released.
[00:02:36] CR: They were paying it in two tranches, 80 million US dollars. from existing cash reserves with future payments of approximately 80 million to be made in the coming months from existing liquidity sources. I had a look at how much cash they had on hand, which was about 250 million. And, uh, I went, ah, this doesn’t look good.
[00:02:57] CR: So I finally sold my holding in my super yesterday. And of course, what did it do today? Up 10%. First thing this morning. Yeah. So thanks a lot, Marley.
[00:03:08] TK: You reckon there’s a, you reckon there’s like this little, it’s like almost like a German CFO sitting in the Malian government, little spectacles and a green eye shade going, they have 450 million cash.
[00:03:25] CR: Why German?
[00:03:27] TK: I don’t know. I don’t know why I thought
[00:03:28] CR: aspersions on all Germans? Character out of a Spielberg, Indiana
[00:03:34] TK: yeah, you’re right. And I’m casting aspersions on the Malinese government too, because I’m kind of equating them with the other Germans in World War II.
[00:03:42] CR: Can you move your microphone a little bit closer to your mouth? You’re
[00:03:45] CR: echoey there. Sounds like you’re still in Cape Shake.
[00:03:51] TK: Yeah. There you go. Yeah. Yeah. So, um, I don’t even know if the CEO has been released. There was an article in today’s AFR suggesting he wasn’t,
[00:04:01] CR: Well yesterday,
[00:04:01] TK: I imagine that’s not
[00:04:02] CR: company’s press release said they remain safe and well and continue to receive support on the ground from the UK and international embassies and consulates, um, yeah, I guess they’re being held until the money is paid, I don’t know,
[00:04:20] TK: Yeah, there’s a couple of interesting things there. I think it was the chair of the company who wasn’t in Marley, because it’s also listed on the London Stock Exchange. That’s the other, that’s another interesting thing too, we, it went into a trading halt in Australia, but it didn’t go into a trading halt in the UK, and the UK share price kept going down.
[00:04:38] TK: So when it came out of a trading halt in Australia, there was a bit of arbitrage going on to try and equalize the prices. But once that went through, I think that’s one of the reasons why it’s gone up today, perhaps.
[00:04:50] CR: anyway.
[00:04:52] TK: Um, but, uh, I did read in the Fin, I think it was today, that, uh, a whole bunch of Canadian gold mining stocks, uh, caved in straight away and, and paid.
[00:05:05] TK: So Barrick Gold paid 85 million US to secure the release of four of its executives.
[00:05:11] CR: back in September, I think. We talked about that one last week.
[00:05:15] TK: okay. Uh, yeah. So. Thanks a lot.
[00:05:17] CR: Same thing happened to
[00:05:18] TK: Mali was after 350 million dollars in back taxes from Barrick and they got 85. But yeah, it’s not a bad, bad day’s work. And um, Allied Gold, B2 Gold and Robex Resources have all recently renegotiated their agreements with the Malinese government.
[00:05:36] TK: So the Canadians Cave straight away, jumped in, yeah, like the French in World War 2, just surrendered straight away. And, uh, just continuing my World War 2 theme
[00:05:48] CR: Yeah.
[00:05:49] TK: and, ah, ha, ha,
[00:05:50] CR: In retrospect,
[00:05:51] CR: what the
[00:05:53] CR: Ukrainians maybe should have done two and a half years ago, because it looks like it’s going to happen in a couple of months anyway, if not sooner.
[00:06:02] TK: Yeah, well, that’s another issue, isn’t it? Like, uh, what did Biden say today? He’s, he was elected president for four years, not three, three and a half, and was fine for the, for the Ukrainian government to use long range missiles against Russia. Russia, of course, came out and said, yeah, if you want to start World War III, go ahead.
[00:06:19] CR: Yeah. But like, imagine you’re Zelensky, you got a pretty good sense that as soon as Trump takes office, if not before. Uh, all of the funding from the US anyway is going to dry up, maybe some funding will still come from the EU for a while, but it’s going to dry up, which means you’re going to have to negotiate a settlement with Russia anyway.
[00:06:41] CR: You really want to be shooting missiles into Moscow, uh, when you’re about to have to sit down at a negotiating table with them? Um, I think that would be
[00:06:50] TK: them up your sleeve.
[00:06:51] CR: I just think now is the time to cut your losses and do what they were ready to do by all reports out of Ukraine in April of 2022 until Bojo flew over there and told them not to do it.
[00:07:09] CR: And somehow convinced them that not doing it was a good idea. Anyway.
[00:07:12] TK: Yeah. Bojo’s Winston Churchill
[00:07:14] CR: Will be interesting to
[00:07:16] CR: see how the markets react to that when it happens. Uh, we know how the markets
[00:07:24] TK: love it.
[00:07:25] CR: Yeah, well when the war started, the markets crashed. That was just after we started the light portfolios, and my first light portfolio is still trying to recover from that, because it It tanked within like the first 60 days and still trying to get back to where, uh, back to, I think it’s back in the black, but not by much.
[00:07:44] CR: Um, So hopefully there’s a bump in the markets, uh, when that all gets resolved. And then I, then it’ll be interesting to see what happens with all of the US sanctions against Russia, whether or not Trump just gets rid of all of those and then all of the EU sanctions disappear, then the EU can start to buy Russian gas and oil again.
[00:08:08] CR: Um, it, it could have a really interesting impact on the markets earlier in the new year.
[00:08:15] TK: Yeah. It could invert all the things that happened, as you say before, in, I’m not just talking about the market, but, um, commodities markets, cause it affected the oil price. It affected the grain price, which we’ll talk about later on. Yeah. Um, getting back to RSG though, I mean, it’s, I think it’s still actually about a cent below its sell price when I looked at the share price earlier this morning.
[00:08:39] TK: So you probably haven’t done the
[00:08:42] TK: wrong thing. Um,
[00:08:44] CR: Well, I could have
[00:08:45] TK: it’s like one of those, it’s one of those
[00:08:46] CR: 10 percent more this morning.
[00:08:48] TK: if, yeah, if I was out playing golf yesterday and didn’t see you come out of a trading halt, you would,
[00:08:52] TK: you make more money today.
[00:08:53] CR: Yeah. And you know, as we talked about last week, I, even yesterday, I was like, Oh, like they’re probably going to trade through this. It’s probably going to be okay. They’re probably going to be back up, but really how, how long do I want to wait to test that theory?
[00:09:09] CR: I’m going to be sitting and watching it every day. Do I really want the stress of, you know? Worrying about it every time it drops back down again. I don’t know, I’ll just cut my losses and get out, you know, as we always say, like you’re taking a loss on one stock out of a portfolio of 15 or 20. I don’t think I have that many in my super portfolio, but yeah, it’s like 12 or something at the moment.
[00:09:31] TK: And can you find something else which will
[00:09:34] TK: return more than waiting for this one to turn
[00:09:36] CR: Well, I bought Qantas and, hopefully.
[00:09:39] TK: Oh,
[00:09:40] CR: Qantas and, um, and Parenti, actually. Um,
[00:09:46] TK: yeah, I haven’t printed.
[00:09:47] CR: we’ll see what happens with those. I want to talk about MWY, Tony, um, Midway. They’re on our, been on our buy list for a couple of months and I was looking at them yesterday, uh, as a light purchase. Um, very low ADT though, like a 15, 000 ADT, so not big enough, really.
[00:10:12] CR: But, um, interesting, I don’t know if we’ve talked about this recently, but their share price was up like 60%, 67 percent on the 14th of November. So that was less than a week ago, we probably haven’t talked about it.
[00:10:28] TK: We haven’t. No.
[00:10:29] CR: Because of, uh, news about an acquisition, Scheme Implementation Deed with River
[00:10:38] CR: Capital, Yeah,
[00:10:39] TK: A takeover offer, as it’s
[00:10:41] TK: otherwise called.
[00:10:42] CR: that one. Has entered, Midway has entered into a buying scheme implementation deed with RCM BidCo, Proprietary Limited, an entity owned and controlled by funds managed and advised by River Capital for the acquisition of all the shares in Midway by way of scheme of arrangement. So probably a bit late to buy into them anyway.
[00:11:02] TK: Yeah, I think the share price is trading at about
[00:11:05] TK: the big price or thereabouts.
[00:11:07] CR: So I don’t know if any of our members would have been on that, but as I said, they’ve been on the buy list for a couple of months, pretty small, but somebody, if you did have them, you just got a nice, nice exit. Out of
[00:11:18] TK: Yeah. Timber Company, if I recall, and Timber Products. It’s actually, it was one of the first stocks on our buy list, I think, many years
[00:11:25] CR: Really?
[00:11:26] TK: And it went off and it came back. Yeah. I did a pulled pork on Midway in the very early days, I’m sure.
[00:11:32] CR: Hmm.
[00:11:34] TK: That’s how I know about it.
[00:11:35] CR: Australian forestry company based in Geelong. Yeah. Nice one. Wood Fiber. Was that when we were trying to find a wood fiber commodity price?
[00:11:43] TK: We did. We used lumber as the commodity for
[00:11:46] CR: There you go. I remember that. Yeah.
[00:11:47] TK: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:11:49] CR: Jamie sent me an email saying your chat about Lion Town is completely backwards. It’s actually an amazing success story. This is getting back to, um, the discussion last week about, uh, what’s, what’s the Lithium, right? Lithium. It’s actually an amazing success story of initial exploration success and subsequently company growth. Pre discovery LTR was a 20 million market cap minnow, now over 2 billion market cap.
[00:12:20] CR: Many early shareholders have been rewarded in spades, not exactly gone down the gurgler as you guys animated. Just a bit of colour for you on that. Intimated. Yeah.
[00:12:31] TK: Intermated,
[00:12:32] CR: out all the big words, Jamie. It certainly would never have been a QAV stock, but you’ll never see a hundred times return in a QAV stock.
[00:12:40] CR: The lithium market is.
[00:12:41] TK: to talk about one that’s getting
[00:12:44] TK: there a bit later on.
[00:12:46] CR: Oh, okay. The lithium market is cyclical, just like any other commodity. It ebbs and flows on supply and demand. However, its relative immaturity causes the recent volatility, and it’s a relatively opaque and immature market dominated by Chinese converters, so it’s still finding its feet on the world scale.
[00:13:06] CR: I sent, um, Jamie a very pleasantly worded reply, uh, because that’s how my mother raised me, and
[00:13:17] TK: Two
[00:13:17] TK: word reply.
[00:13:19] CR: No, I said, look, you’re right, and if you’d got into it five years ago, you’re a little bit happy. If you’d got into it a lot earlier than that, probably very, very happy. But, uh, if you got into it when lithium was all the rage and the buzz, two or three years ago when it was trading at 1. 90 or 2. 70 and now it’s down at 82 cents.
[00:13:44] CR: Uh, maybe not so happy. So I think that was our point that lithium, not that it’s hasn’t, you know, hasn’t had a lot of success and hasn’t come from being a minnow and turned into a large company, but that, um, we stay away from hype if they don’t, you know, Meet all of our other metrics, and lithium companies were being hyped a couple of years ago, it was going to be the biggest thing, it was tulips, and, uh, it would have been a bad time to buy into the hype, at least when it comes to Liontown, I don’t know about other lithium stocks, but,
[00:14:19] TK: Yeah, I mean, Jamie’s right. It’s been an explorer that’s, I think it has got to production. It may not even be in production. Getting close to production, maybe. However. Oh, however, Jamie, go and have a look at how much they’ve raised along the way. So, even though you may have bought, um, Lionstown or whatever it was, 20 cents or whatever he said at the start, I’m just looking at, in Stock Doctor, at, um, a line in their cash flows called proceeds from issues, which is where money goes if it gets raised.
[00:14:56] TK: This is going back to December 2006, which would have been their initial IPO, I guess. Uh, There’s been one, two, three, four halves. in nearly 20 years, five halves in nearly 20 years where they haven’t raised money. So your 20 cent stakeholder, if they didn’t participate, has been diluted horribly since then.
[00:15:24] TK: But if they did participate, it eats into that hundred times return quite substantially. I haven’t done the maths, but that’s typically the way these things work is that, um, yes, you get growth in the top line share price, but you’ve either been diluted a very small holding or you’ve had to pay for that
[00:15:42] TK: growth along the way yourself.
[00:15:44] CR: and it looks like, going into Stock Doctor, it looks like they floated around 2006, around about 17 cents, Maybe they opened at 0. 12 and went up to 0. 18, so it might have floated around 0. 12. Then they dropped down to 0. 01 by 2008 09 and stayed down at 0. 01 or 0. 02. Until 2019 they started to pick up and then they had a great thing.
[00:16:16] CR: But imagine sitting on it. You got in at 12 cents, it dropped down to 1 cent and stayed there for 12, 13 years. I mean, brave a man than me Gungadin, if you were holding on for that amount of time. But, uh, yeah.
[00:16:32] TK: yeah, but the point we were talking about last week was that they took Lionstown turned down a takeover offer and the shareholders would have been much more enriched if they’d taken it. And, um, it was a very emotional time. Gina Reinhart bought into the company as a blocking stake for it to be able to stay Australian owned and not go overseas and blah, blah, blah.
[00:16:52] TK: So, uh, and then the share price has dropped from 3 down to where it is now, 86 cents or something like it is today. Um, so yeah, it’s, it’s, It’s been a wild ride for sure. It’s not the kind of wild ride I would like to take on though, and certainly couldn’t predict going forward. And you know, as you say, I mean, I think what’s emerged in the thinking in the last 12 months to sort of clarify things is that companies like BHP have said, we’re not touching lithium, it’s too hard.
[00:17:22] TK: To refine, and I know nothing about lithium or the refining process, but it seems like what happens is they pump a whole heap of salt water into the lithium in the ground, and then when it bubbles up, they, uh, they, um, they let it evaporate in big open sort of dams or pans. And what’s left is lithium concentrate, but it takes months, if not years for that to happen.
[00:17:52] TK: process to occur. So, um, it’s a very slow process to get lithium out of the ground and into a useful form.
[00:17:58] TK: It’s one of the reasons why, uh, lithium mines have dropped a lot this year.
[00:18:04] CR: Lithium refining involves extracting lithium from its ores, typically spodumene or brine. For spodumene, the ore is heated to high temperatures to change its crystalline structure, making lithium easier to extract. The material is then crushed. Mixed with chemicals, like sulfuric acid, and processed to produce lithium carbonate or lithium hydroxide.
[00:18:27] CR: For brine, lithium rich water from underground reservoirs is pumped to the surface and evaporated in large ponds over months, concentrating the lithium. The concentrated brine is treated with chemicals to isolate lithium compounds, which are further purified. Both methods require significant energy and water, contributing to environmental concerns. Unlike,
[00:18:50] TK: Yeah, but they go into EVs though, which is great for the
[00:18:52] TK: environment. Yeah,
[00:18:59] CR: involved in that. I just, I,
[00:19:01] TK: yeah.
[00:19:02] CR: I just used the Pacific Ocean’s supply of water to produce that result. Hmm.
[00:19:09] TK: And so that’s the other thing. I mean, one of the reasons why lithium took off in the first place was because of this EV, you know, because of the attractiveness of, you know, Electric vehicles to people who have that kind of ESG minded focus on investing. Um, but yeah, as I’ve said on many occasions before, it’s a great focus to have, but doesn’t always generate good returns.
[00:19:31] TK: And it hasn’t in this case, unless you were in on the ground floor at 12 cents and threw the bread later away and didn’t sell it when it went down to 1 cent and then participated and had had the deep pockets to participate in the capital raisings
[00:19:47] TK: and not get diluted. So you stayed at 1 cent.
[00:19:49] CR: And I suspect Jamie’s one of those people and that’s why he’s defending
[00:19:52] TK: I hope so.
[00:19:52] TK: Well done.
[00:19:53] CR: going to pick us up in
[00:19:54] CR: his, uh, private jet later on and, um, flies to
[00:19:58] TK: no, great
[00:19:59] CR: where he owns
[00:20:00] CR: a palace. Uh, Jordan wrote in too.
[00:20:03] TK: with, does it have big ponds outside? Waiting for the lithium to float to the surface.
[00:20:09] CR: Jordan. Hi Cam. Tony was talking about accruals on last week’s show and considering incorporating them into the checklist if he can find the data.
[00:20:17] CR: I found that Stock Doctor have a metric called accrual percentage, which you can include in the download on the stock filter data. Stock Doctor’s help pages don’t give an indication of what the accrual is actually a percentage of, but I have email support, emailed support, to see if they’ll explain how they calculate the accrual percentage metric.
[00:20:37] CR: The below page on the Stock Doctor Help section explains that the Earnings Quality Metric measures how closely reported earnings matches cash flows. The Earnings Quality Metric is available for download or for previous halves under Financial Statements, Arrow, Financial Metrics on Stock Doctor. So depending on what data you have in the regression tool, you might be able to check this as a proxy for WWOS Accounting Metrics.
[00:21:04] CR: WWOS, WWO, WWO, WWO, WWO. Wubba wubba wubba, wubba’s.
[00:21:10] TK: Well,
[00:21:10] TK: wows
[00:21:11] CR: Um, uh, la la la, On this week’s buy list, only two stocks reported weak earnings quality, ATP and CCV. Oh, don’t talk to me about ATP. Hope this is helpful.
[00:21:23] TK: gone up again.
[00:21:24] CR: Of course it
[00:21:25] TK: sell that one too?
[00:21:27] TK: Did you, did you sell
[00:21:28] CR: After the last time with ATP, it’s in my, uh, you know, red flashing light list. Don’t go near it.
[00:21:36] CR: Hope this is helpful. Well, yeah,
[00:21:38] TK: Now that we, now that we both own Parenti, can you just let me know when you’re gonna sell it so I
[00:21:43] CR: yeah, yeah, yeah.
[00:21:44] TK: buy some more. I’ll buy it off you. If you wanna sell it, just gimme a call.
[00:21:49] CR: Wow. Wow. It’s generous of you. Hope this is helpful. And I’ll let you know if Stock Doctor responds to my query regarding accrual percentage. Thank you, Jordan.
[00:22:01] TK: Oh, that’s cruel. That’s great. That’s really helpful, Jordan. I hadn’t picked up on that. Um, yeah, I had a look because Jordan nominated Atlas Pearls, but also Cash Converters as two companies with um, accruals, um, in their sales. That’s actually a really good way of finding it out too, because I can’t think of another reason why the revenue and the cashflow statement would be different to the revenue in the P& L.
[00:22:28] TK: It’s got to be accruals, I would think. So it’s a good way of. Working it out. Yeah. And now I just had a quick look at it, um, before when I was prepping for the show, uh, to see what we can do with that. Um, of course my mind straight away said, Oh, I should test that. But, um, really what works on Wall Street’s tested it with much more rigor and, and far greater universe of stocks and what I would do.
[00:22:52] TK: So as soon as I can, I guess I’ll put it into the, um,
[00:22:55] TK: into production. I think it’s a good one.
[00:22:57] CR: So for people who didn’t hear last week’s show, or like me, can’t remember what we talked about, uh, give it, give us the quick summary of what accrual is and how this works.
[00:23:09] TK: Yeah, so what’s, what works on Wall Street, um, gave over a lot of time and effort to not just looking at whether high dividends paying stocks did better than low dividend paying stocks, but accounting ratios, and one of them was accruals. And so an accrual is where, uh, I’ve sold something, and perhaps even delivered it to a customer, but I haven’t been paid yet.
[00:23:36] TK: But the accounting rules allow me to bring the payment from next year into this year’s books. You know, it’s designed to balance up the stock and the movements and all that kind of thing. You know, because you can, there’s two types of accounting, cash or accrual. Cash is very simple, it’s, As things get paid, they get booked and accrual is now going to try and match the, the, what’s the cost of what’s been sold with the revenues from what’s been sold.
[00:24:04] TK: So you can bring them forward as the inventory leaves. Anytime you’ll ask the manager to, to fiddle with the numbers, guess what? They fiddle like there’s no tomorrow. They fiddle like they’re Nero,
[00:24:18] TK: Rome’s burning.
[00:24:19] CR: glad you didn’t say they fiddle, they fiddle like Alan
[00:24:21] CR: Jones. I’m glad you didn’t go there. I mean, because that’s only allegations and we wouldn’t, we
[00:24:26] TK: I didn’t know he played the violin
[00:24:27] CR: Yeah,
[00:24:31] TK: and um, so there’s been cases of companies, uh, getting, getting so stuck into the fiddle. I got the whole, the whole, uh, what is it? The wood, not the woodwind, the whole string
[00:24:44] TK: section of the, of the orchestra
[00:24:46] CR: look, I’ve just
[00:24:47] TK: they bring, they
[00:24:49] TK: bring,
[00:24:49] CR: I cannot allow, I cannot allow the besmirching of Nero’s name like this to go on in one of my shows. There is absolutely no evidence that Nero,
[00:25:02] TK: let Alan, you let Alan
[00:25:03] TK: Jones be the besmirched, but not Nero.
[00:25:06] CR: no evidence that Nero, Was anything but shocked and horrified when Rome burnt. It’s all spurious propaganda spread by his enemies, the Flavians that came after him to make him look bad and justify their, uh, taking the Roman empire. Anyway, continue.
[00:25:28] TK: Yeah, it’s a good story. That’s why it’s stuck for 2000 years. But um, no, so there have been cases of companies who got, uh, on the cruel treadmill and they kept having to, because, you know, if you do it once, right, if you bring sales from January into December, That helps your P& L. Then next year, you’ve only got 11 months sales, right?
[00:25:49] TK: Cause you put the 12th into the year before. So then you have to bring, you have to keep doing that. And you know, if then it’s, yeah, it becomes an, it becomes opportunistic. If, if a February looks really good too, can I bring those forward? So yeah, it just becomes a problem and it has led to the demise of some companies, particularly
[00:26:07] TK: retailers or wholesalers who are selling to retailers.
[00:26:10] CR: So accruals is bad.
[00:26:13] TK: not necessarily if it’s done properly,
[00:26:15] CR: I’m talking about from
[00:26:16] TK: I’m bringing you a day’s
[00:26:17] CR: from a wow’s
[00:26:18] TK: investing point of view, yeah, it’s bad. Yeah.
[00:26:21] CR: So we want to,
[00:26:22] TK: A cross is bad. So we want to try and give a negative one or something in the checklist for, uh, for that.
[00:26:29] CR: um, he calls out ATV and CCV with weak earnings quality. So he said before that, I skipped a bit, he said accruals greater than 10 percent is reported as weak. Right. 10 percent to 5 percent accruals is reported as weak or neutral. 5 percent down to greater than 0 percent is neutral, less than 0 percent is reported as strong.
[00:26:51] CR: So weak earnings quality means a high percentage of accruals and therefore you want to punish them in the scoring somehow. Negative one, as she said,
[00:27:02] TK: Yeah. Yeah. But I mean, it could even be a red flag. I don’t know. I’ve got
[00:27:06] TK: to have a look into it a bit further.
[00:27:08] CR: with my experience with ATP, I’d definitely encourage a red flag on
[00:27:13] TK: well, I’ve got to say off the bat, both of these companies are buys and they’re on, they’re going up. There’s stock prices going up and they’re on the, they’re going up with the bread loader. So, you know. That’s what I’m saying. It’s, it, it, it may be that we don’t want to make it a complete red flag as in
[00:27:31] TK: just eliminate them, but we might want to knock them
[00:27:33] CR: Oh my God. I just looked at ATP.
[00:27:37] TK: I was waiting for
[00:27:38] CR: They’ve gone from like 8 cents to 16 cents. They’ve doubled in the last three months. Oh
[00:27:45] TK: been another pearl sale,
[00:27:46] CR: Oh, you bastards.
[00:27:48] CR: You complete and utter bastards. Oh, I know that you never go and check your old girlfriend’s Facebook page, but, uh, I am, I am. I am gonna check this to see, uh, when did I, what did I sell a TP at? Oh,
[00:28:09] TK: It’s gotta be.
[00:28:10] CR: it at 11 cents
[00:28:13] CR: in complete bastards.
[00:28:15] CR: Um,
[00:28:15] TK: But what did you buy? What did you buy that?
[00:28:17] CR: thir 13. I bought it at 13.
[00:28:21] CR: Sold it.
[00:28:21] TK: What did you buy with the proceeds?
[00:28:23] CR: Oh, I don’t know. How the hell do I know? I don’t know. But it was, um, yeah, it was a light portfolio. Bought it at 13 cents in December 23. Sold it in April after their auction went bad at 11 cents. So I lost 13 percent on it. Anyway, so it’s up to
[00:28:41] TK: It’s gotta, it,
[00:28:42] CR: much.
[00:28:43] TK: it does strike me that, remember we couldn’t find a commodity for pearls ’cause the market’s so illiquid and small. But it does strike me as an opportunity for an enterprising listener to buy some to arbitrage between the share price of a TP and buying the pearls, like influencing the auction, push the price up on the auction and make the money back on the, on the share price.
[00:29:05] TK: Or vice versa, I guess if you were shorter.
[00:29:07] CR: Right, there you go. Alright, so, um, look for an accruals score in the buy list moving forwards. I just finished coding the buy list too over the weekend, so
[00:29:21] TK: I know.
[00:29:22] CR: of course you’ll have to add something to
[00:29:23] CR: it next year, five years.
[00:29:25] TK: Come on. You know my timetable. It’ll be next year before it gets done.
[00:29:28] CR: Writing with a suggestion on
[00:29:32] TK: Yeah.
[00:29:36] CR: zombie companies for the show with a link below to an article on LiveWire I found interesting. The interesting aspect was that some of these companies are in the ASX 300, which blew my mind as I thought zombie companies would be penny dreadfuls or at least small, small caps He’s also asking for a pulled pork on QBE, which is on the buy list and has taken off recently, and he even owns some, so he thinks you’re
[00:30:01] TK: So do I.
[00:30:02] CR: thinks you’re doing a pulled pork on it, it’s going to be good for it apparently.
[00:30:04] TK: help. Well, Tom, if you want to send money through, I prepared the pulled pork when I saw your
[00:30:13] TK: request, but I can leave it till next week if you like.
[00:30:15] CR: Tony’s, uh, bank account details are following. Um, the zombie company’s article is interesting. It says, while everyone’s attention is focused on mineral resources and WiseTech, there are other companies on the ASX that are flashing red. The media has been circling WiseTech Global’s Richard Wyatt and Mineral Resources Chris Ellison in recent months.
[00:30:35] CR: Why to step down? Well, Ellison plans to step down from his post within 18 months, both with the result of investigations and intense scrutiny. Although there are red flags surrounding both these companies, Plato Investment Management’s Dr. David Allen suggests that these are not the only companies in the ASX 300 that investors should be taking notes on.
[00:30:57] CR: Zombie companies are defined as businesses where their interest Costs or debt repayments exceed their cash flows over long periods of time, say three years or more. Usually they trade at high multiples and have a captivating story that sees investors take a punt on these profitless or hardly revenue generating companies like a junior mining business sitting on a very large pot of gold or a biotech with plans to revolutionize healthcare.
[00:31:31] CR: If a company’s got,
[00:31:32] TK: lithium miner.
[00:31:33] CR: if a company’s got negative operating cash flow, and it can’t even cover its assets. Interest costs, they’re going to have to keep tapping the market to get financing just to stay afloat. Their core operations are value destroying, Alan says. When you look at that as a red flag, a company that is a zombie, they perform horribly on average.
[00:31:52] CR: It’s often the case that they’re companies that have a bit of a lottery profile, where they could be ten baggers. So which seven businesses are zombies on the ASX in this wire? You’ll find out. Would you like to know more? Press
[00:32:07] TK: clickbait. Take this
[00:32:08] CR: right, yeah, yeah. Um, so, uh, Mineral Resources, WiseTech Global, the others are NextGen Energy, ASX NXG, market cap 5.
[00:32:21] CR: 5 billion Canadian dollars, revenues zero, status 5, 7 and 10 years, 12 month share price performance 20. 11%, Another one is Mesoblast, ASX, MSB, market cap 1. 52 billion, revenues 5. 9 million, zombie status 5 in 7 years, 12 month share price performance 259 percent I like this note,
[00:32:53] TK: Miso Blast is, is particularly, sorry to interrupt, Miso Blast is particularly pertinent to the story
[00:33:00] TK: category of this, uh, of zombie companies. Yeah,
[00:33:03] CR: its cell therapy has been rejected by the FDA twice, they also had to settle a class action lawsuit over a COVID treatment, where they reportedly misrepresented the benefits of the treatment. Number 3 is Immutep.
[00:33:18] TK: is kind of an asterisk. It doesn’t cure COVID.
[00:33:24] CR: MUTEP, uh, share code is IMM, market cap 422 million, revenue zero. Can you be an ASX 300 with a market cap of 422 million? That seems small.
[00:33:36] TK: It’ll be at
[00:33:36] TK: the bottom end, yeah, but you could. Ha ha ha ha ha
[00:33:40] CR: Novonix, NVX, 353 million market cap, revenues of 8. 1 million, zombie status, five years. It’s share price is down 9 percent over the last 12 months. By the way, Immutep is down 3. 33%. Ioneer, INR, did Barry and Stan come up with all these names? Immu, Mesoblast, Immutep, Novonix, Ioneer.
[00:34:09] CR: Give me
[00:34:10] TK: Mm hmm.
[00:34:11] TK: It’s a theme, isn’t it?
[00:34:12] CR: Yeah, that should be the side of
[00:34:14] TK: If you’re gonna, have a best selling story, you gotta put a good
[00:34:17] CR: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[00:34:18] TK: Ha ha ha ha!
[00:34:20] CR: Don’t need to look at any of the fundamentals to pick the zombie companies, just look at the stupid names. Um, INR. We can talk with QAV as their name. Uh, market cap 538 million. Revenue zero. 12 month share price performance 35%. Guess what? They’re a lithium developer.
[00:34:38] CR: Um, Adriatic Metals, ADT, 846, well not Average Daily Trade, uh, the code is ADT, market cap 846 million, revenue 0, 12 month share price performance 17. 3%. Boss Energy, BOE, 1. 32 billion market cap, revenues 5. 5 million, zombie status 5 years. Share price performance last 12 months, negative 26%. Well, That’s
[00:35:06] TK: another interesting one. Wasn’t it called Boss Resources? That changed its name to Boss Energy. That’s Yeah, no, but that’s another telltale sign of that kind of company.
[00:35:16] TK: It’s like, we’re in the resource game, now we’re in the energy
[00:35:19] CR: Yeah. Energy is much more fungible.
[00:35:22] TK: Ha Ha ha ha. ha ha Ha ha
[00:35:25] CR: So like these,
[00:35:27] TK: were holding us back,
[00:35:27] CR: they’re a uranium producer, Australia’s next uranium producer, according to their website. Um,
[00:35:35] TK: Only got about five,
[00:35:37] TK: fifteen or something listed. Ha
[00:35:39] CR: these companies aren’t going to be on our buy list, are they?
[00:35:44] TK: No! And for good reason! I mean, this is the lottery end of the share market. This is like being a parent with a teenager who keeps starting up businesses and then they fail and you go, Oh, it’s a good learning experience. Have some more money, have some more money. So they, they exist. And look, you know, the one I’ve, I’ve focused in on there before, MesoBlast, it’s been around for almost as long as my, I’ve been investing.
[00:36:09] TK: Um, for, and, what’s his name, uh, Silviu Itescu, I think his name is, professor, so smart guy, is a consummate presenter, consummate, um, hasn’t produced anything that I can think of. Um, but has had such fantastic world changing stories about how he’s going to revolutionize medicine and can cure this and that, uh, 20 years later, or nearly 20 years later, hasn’t happened yet.
[00:36:41] CR: Well, it takes time.
[00:36:42] TK: but what has happened is, uh, every couple of years or even sooner, he goes back to the market and asks, he does another great roadshow and, you know, comes up with another world beating cure for Whatever. Cancer. Um, and raises money from retail shareholders who are entranced by, um, his, his presentation.
[00:37:04] TK: And you know what? Yeah, he, he may well cure cancer. Um, he’s had enough goes at it, so, um, if anyone’s gonna do it, it’s probably him.
[00:37:14] CR: And as the article
[00:37:15] TK: uh, but that’s,
[00:37:16] CR: sorry,
[00:37:16] TK: that’s just not, that’s not how I want to fund my retirement from taking those kinds of punts.
[00:37:22] CR: the share
[00:37:22] TK: And to be fair, the ASXs exist to, to raise money for speculative investments.
[00:37:27] TK: So, you know, I’m not saying, um, shut these down or over regulate them, but if you’re going to invest in them, be aware, you’re probably going to, you may lose your money and you’re definitely going to be asked for more. Um, and then, I don’t know, 1 in 20, 1 in 100 might actually shoot the lights out and cure cancer and then you, you can call us from the Bahamas, but, uh, if you don’t own that
[00:37:53] TK: one, you’re stuffed.
[00:37:54] CR: or you’d be, you’d die of cancer
[00:37:55] CR: before it happens. Um, the share price is up 259 percent this year. It’s gone from, I don’t know, say, uh, 26 cents roughly a year ago, up to 1. 60, which is great.
[00:38:11] TK: Yeah, but
[00:38:14] CR: July, 2011, it was trading at $8 50
[00:38:21] TK: And have a look in Stock Doctor and see how
[00:38:23] TK: much money it’s raised between those two periods
[00:38:25] CR: August, 2020. It was trading at five bucks. had, it had fallen from $8 50 down to a buck, then it went up to five bucks, and then it dropped down to 30 cents.
[00:38:39] TK: Yeah. So it’s a trading stock really, isn’t it? If you, if you’ve got a way of trading that stock, it’s great, but don’t get caught in it and
[00:38:46] TK: don’t, don’t keep tipping into it.
[00:38:49] CR: Don’t believe the story.
[00:38:50] TK: bad. Yeah.
[00:38:52] TK: Yeah.
[00:38:54] CR: Uh,
[00:38:54] TK: And look, I’m, I’m picking on him. There’s, uh, um, he’s a professor, so he’s a smart guy and he probably does want to cure cancer genuinely and thinks this is the best way to go about doing it.
[00:39:06] TK: But as investors, this is a bit like, you know, being, being caught up in the lithium boom because it’s going to, um, power electric vehicles, you know, to eternity, from here to eternity, and it’s going to solve global warming.
[00:39:23] CR: mm,
[00:39:24] TK: No, it’s not. And it’s also, you’ve got to have some numbers to back up that investment thesis too.
[00:39:30] CR: mm. Well, uh, thanks for that article sharing that with us, Tom. Very interesting. Um,
[00:39:38] TK: Some good, good correspondence this week.
[00:39:41] CR: yeah, it’s nice. People are waking up out of their slumber. Um, I just wanted to give people, uh, members a couple of, uh, notices. Uh, the buy list when I uploaded it yesterday was balked. Um, there was some balking of the. Figures. A number of people alerted me to that, including you, Tony. I apologize for that. I fixed it late last night, so if you haven’t already downloaded the fixed version, download, go to the same link I posted in Facebook and download the fixed version, which I think is right.
[00:40:15] CR: Um, and also the AF version of the checklist for those of you using that, when I was doing some coding of it yesterday or over the weekend, I noticed that there was a problem in column AD, which Presented the score for the question, is the forecast IV or the IV2 greater than twice the share price? Um, it was actually being calculated in column AR, and if the calculation in column AR was a zero, AD was actually showing it as a blank, not as a zero. There’s just a formatting issue as it turned out, um, the formatting of that column was set to custom instead of to general and it just didn’t copy it over. Doesn’t look like it changed it, I, I, I went backwards and forwards, um, looking if it changed any of the QAV scores, I don’t think it did. So, I don’t think it’s made a difference to anything, but there is a new version, um, up, uh, you can get via the member resources page if you want to change it, or just change it in your own version from, um, Custom to General and Bob’s Your Uncle.
[00:41:26] CR: Don’t think it’s going to change anything though, just to be perfect. Um, ASG. I did some selling from the DP, finally. Tony, I had to sell something and I sold ASG, finally.
[00:41:41] TK: What’s happened to it? What’s the share price
[00:41:43] CR: well, you’ll remember that back in May they had a dividend. Dividend went X, share price dropped, then it was paid, dividend, the price didn’t recover.
[00:41:53] CR: And I looked at its chart and I said to you, well, it always does this. Like they always have a big dip and then they recover after the dividend. It takes usually a few weeks or a month and then they recover and they go to a new high and then there’s a dividend and it drops a lot of dividend trading. It took forever to took like months to recover from the May dividend.
[00:42:14] CR: finally, it finally did. And then it had another dividend.
[00:42:20] TK: A double
[00:42:20] CR: An October, early November dividend, which has been paid, and it’s still not recovering, and it’s below where it was in May, and I was like, you know what? Screw you, and the horse you rode in on. Um, I’m done. And so I had to sell that from, My, I think my Super sold it from the, no, no, it’s just the dummy portfolio, I think.
[00:42:42] CR: Maybe Super too, I don’t know. Um, Light Portfolios. I had to sell it from everywhere. Um, so that’s finally gone. But it’s the first thing I’ve sold in the dummy portfolio since August, I think.
[00:42:55] TK: just going to email Alex Hay and ask him to buy some ASG for me.
[00:43:06] CR: I wanted to also talk about one more stock, SWM. It’s on the buy list. I nearly bought this. It’s just seven words.
[00:43:15] TK: think it’s a sell
[00:43:16] TK: though, isn’t it? It’s been going down for ages.
[00:43:18] CR: No, it’s on the buy list. Um,
[00:43:21] TK: yeah, but I’m pretty sure it’s a, if you look at the graph, it’s
[00:43:23] TK: a sell. Anyway, go on.
[00:43:25] CR: well it was above its 2BL. It’s been a falling knife for ages, but it’s above its 2BL. It was
[00:43:33] TK: Oh, okay. Yep.
[00:43:34] TK: I can see now you’re right. Sorry.
[00:43:36] CR: So, I mean, I was going to buy it and I went and read the announcements and I’m, you know, having a look at what’s going on.
[00:43:45] CR: And, uh,
[00:43:47] CR: so they just. They had their AGM recently, a couple of weeks ago, and so I was reading through the Chairman’s Address at the AGM, and it just tickled me.
[00:43:59] CR: So Kerry Stokes, good old Kerry Stokes, um, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And he goes, um, We face industry wide challenges, including a subdued economic environment that is putting sustained pressure on advertising, and federal government policy settings that are creating unnecessary roadblocks. Ah, those governments and their roadblocks.
[00:44:25] CR: You’re bou
[00:44:25] TK: Patreon Capitalism.
[00:44:26] CR: Your board acted swiftly this year to confront the headwinds facing our industry, initiating a group wide restructure of our operations and management. This was designed to invigorate the business and set us up to best exploit modern consumer habits, fast track transformation, control costs, grow audiences.
[00:44:47] CR: Can’t do anything about the fact that our audience is just dying off and we’re not replacing them, but you know, maybe zombies, maybe we’ll bring them back as he didn’t say any of that. I’m making that up. Um, But the bit that got me was this bit, um, you know, he’s going on about sports programming, blah blah blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah, telethons, raising money for six kids, our people are deeply ingrained in our towns and cities where we fight for our viewers and readers.
[00:45:16] CR: We are a business built on and loved by millions of Australians who make up our Broad 7 family. This is in stark contrast to overseas base streaming platforms. Unlike them, we pay our taxes, look after our people and follow the strict broadcasting laws. Unfortunately, the federal government has failed to create a legislative environment that allows Australians unfettered and guaranteed access to free sports programming.
[00:45:43] CR: Our parliamentarians are not doing enough to reinforce and strengthen. The anti siphoning rules in order to give every Australian access, for free, to iconic sporting events of national significance. And then he goes on about what they’re gonna do. This is the bit that really got me. Our national broadcaster, the ABC’s Four Corners program, recently veered well away from the ABC charter to engage in an egregious, An unfair assault on our business and the reputation of our good people.
[00:46:16] CR: Our formal complaint to the ABC, making a compelling case that Four Corners had clearly failed to meet the broadcaster’s own principles of impartiality, accuracy, and fairness was unsurprisingly ignored. Despite our request, the ABC’s ombudsman has also refused to investigate the matter. The Four Corners program backfired as the ABC itself is now the subject of charges of hypocrisy and entrenched cultural problems including racism, misogyny and bullying.
[00:46:45] CR: This attack failed to dent the spirit and pride of our incredibly talented, hardworking and professional teams. Oh, so, so professional. So hardworking. Of course, you know, we know what he’s referring to when it comes to The Four Corners, ATT& CK on 7.
[00:47:07] TK: people can go and look at it for themselves.
[00:47:09] CR: Yes.
[00:47:10] TK: Or they can read about the Bruce Lehrmann
[00:47:12] CR: Yes. Yes. So professional. So hardworking. I just, anyway, my bottom line was, I was going to buy it
[00:47:24] CR: and I read that speech and I was like, you know what? Screw you, Kerry Stokes. That was, I’m not, like it wasn’t even, listen, we’ve made mistakes, but we’re, we’re addressing them and we’re, cultural changes and we’re doing that.
[00:47:40] CR: Just like, double middle fingers to the end everybody,
[00:47:45] TK: It’s our competitor’s
[00:47:46] CR: the federal
[00:47:47] TK: and we wrote to them. We wrote to our competitor and complained and they ignored us. How dare they?
[00:47:55] TK: Yeah.
[00:47:57] CR: I
[00:47:57] TK: Well, I remember, Joe, we did the pool, we did the pooled pork last year at some stage and you raised the issues of why would we want to buy into a TV station, um, or a network of TV stations. And I think the share price has reflected that, um, since then, I think you were right. And you, even though it’s a buy on the buy list and the share price has ticked up again, you may
[00:48:20] TK: be right going forward too.
[00:48:23] CR: share price at the beginning of the year was 27 cents, it’s currently at 16 cents. I mean, I mean, how could you go back even longer? It was up 50 cents going back. Wow, February 22 is at 75 cents. Now it’s at 16 cents. I mean, you know, potentially there’s some life left in it yet and it could maybe get a jump start, but fish rots from the head, Tony.
[00:48:51] CR: That’s my basic philosophy.
[00:48:53] TK: well, it’s a it’s a classic cigar butt stud, isn’t it? A Benjamin Graham cigar butt. Pick it up and hopefully it’s got a few more puffs in it
[00:49:00] CR: And as a cigar smoker, I would not touch a cigar butt. There’s no joy to be had in sucking. Somebody’s had that in their mouth. They’ve been sucking on it. I don’t want to put that in my mouth. And
[00:49:16] TK: Could be
[00:49:16] TK: Kerry Stokes has been sucking on it.
[00:49:19] CR: that they’ve been sucking through the tobacco is congealed in it. And it’s going to have that. Maybe if you like licking somebody
[00:49:26] TK: You really are a cigar,
[00:49:28] CR: nicotine,
[00:49:29] TK: aficionado.
[00:49:30] CR: I can tell you about
[00:49:30] CR: cigar butts. I will smoke my own cigar butts. If I’ve, if I’ve been smoking a cigar for an hour and then I need to put it down and go do something and I’ll, I come back a couple hours later, I will clip the end off it, get rid of the congealed nicotine and, you know, revive it, because I’m not going to waste it because it’s taken a bunch of poorly paid people in Nicaragua or Cuba seven years.
[00:49:58] CR: To make that, I’m not going to, you know, uh,
[00:50:04] TK: Bit like a Channel 7 program, isn’t it?
[00:50:09] CR: anyway. So that was my SWM. I was just disgusted when I read that. It was like, uh, um, little bit of tech news. Uh, um, I wrote a news app, finally.
[00:50:22] TK: Whatcha gonna call it Channel eight? not Channel seven The final nail and the coffin for Seven
[00:50:30] TK: West Media.
[00:50:32] CR: So,
[00:50:32] TK: gotta use that.
[00:50:33] CR: you’ve been asking me for a while, is there a way you could like just use AI to get all the news stories of all the stocks in our buy list each week?
[00:50:40] TK: Mm
[00:50:41] CR: And I couldn’t figure out how to do it and I figured out how to do it over the weekend. I had a, I had a light bulb that went off, two light bulbs, really.
[00:50:50] CR: Um, so I did that and I’ve built it now, I can run it. Whenever I want, it’ll produce stories on all the stocks in my portfolio. And the reason that I think that drove me to do it is that stock that I had that got delisted recently, and I hadn’t known
[00:51:05] TK: Yeah. Right?
[00:51:06] CR: But basically what it does, um, quick version of the story is I was thinking about Google News Alerts, which is something that I’ve used for 20 years, but it produces emails and then you get a, just a ton of junk emails.
[00:51:21] CR: And I didn’t want to, I didn’t want to deal with that, but I was trying to figure out a way around it.
[00:51:25] TK: in directors holdings
[00:51:27] CR: that kind of
[00:51:27] CR: crap.
[00:51:28] TK: Yeah.
[00:51:28] CR: and then when I was inside of Google Newsletters, I saw you can create an RSS feed, not, not an email, you can create an RSS feed. So I thought, well, if I create a newsletter based on a stock code, like ASX colon NAB, I can stick it in there, create an RSS feed, then I could drop the RSS feed into my RSS reader and I could scan the RSS feeds, but again, there’s a hundred stocks in our portfolios.
[00:51:53] CR: The light. dummy, my super, whatever. I don’t want to have to read through all of the bullshit stories. Then I had the idea. What if I write an app that downloads the RSS feeds and then passes them through to OpenAI’s API and gets it to read them. Analyse them, prioritize them, give them a score out of 10 being the most important, down to one, being unimportant.
[00:52:20] CR: Look for certain criteria. So I’ve told it. Anything that talks about an acquisition or a merger, anything involving a change to the status of the CEO or the CFO, A few other things. Uh, profit guidance changes, revenue guidance changes,
[00:52:40] TK: Oh, you could do
[00:52:40] TK: buybacks.
[00:52:41] CR: could do buybacks.
[00:52:43] TK: Yeah. Good
[00:52:44] CR: Write that as high as you
[00:52:45] TK: in dividends.
[00:52:46] CR: then it goes all the way down to, you know, Broker, Bullshit, or, you know, those sorts of things down the bottom.
[00:52:53] CR: So I get a report, and it’s lovely, it’s, it’s formatted, it’s HTML, it looks lovely, I can just look at it once a day, and it gives me the highlights of everything. But, I didn’t want to have to create a hundred alerts in Google either, so then I wrote a script that just, Logs into Google News Alerts, creates the alert, grabs the RSS feed, puts it in an OPML reference list that the report then reference every time it runs the OPML list.
[00:53:19] CR: I’ve got it all set. I was like, Oh my God, this is so great. So yeah, I wrote that in an hour on the weekend.
[00:53:26] TK: Wow.
[00:53:28] TK: Yeah, that’s great.
[00:53:29] CR: great. It’s awesome, man. I was so, I was so pumped. I called Taylor. I was going to tell somebody this. Can’t believe I just did this. It’s like, Amazing.
[00:53:39] TK: What did Taylor say?
[00:53:40] CR: Yeah, it’s really cool.
[00:53:42] TK: Well done, Dad. Good
[00:53:44] CR: good boy. Yeah.
[00:53:45] CR: But the thing was, the thing I wanted to say to like, I started off thinking, Oh, well, like RSS feeds and Google Newsletters, I don’t want to have to enter them all manually. So I’ll write a script that will do that. And that was the first thing that I did. But But then it was that, well, why don’t I just write an app that does everything that I want?
[00:54:01] CR: Like, what’s the dream here, here? Why don’t I just write the app that does But I was saying to Tay, and I was saying this to Sammartino on the Futuristic Show yesterday too, my brain still doesn’t go to roll your own. With this sort of stuff, it hasn’t been trained to think, well, I’ll just build the whole thing that I want, because I can probably do that now.
[00:54:20] CR: I just tell the AI what I want, and I can probably figure out a way to piece together the full solution. I don’t need to just use pre existing stuff. I can build the, the, the. Full kit and caboose. So that was like, Oh shit, why don’t, why don’t I just do that? You know, like I’ve been trying to work this out for months.
[00:54:43] CR: I’ve had a couple of cracks at it over months too. And looking at List Corp and looking at existing service providers that didn’t give me exactly what I wanted and make it easy. Like here’s a hundred stocks and every week in the buy list there’s, you know, a hundred stocks and 20 of them are new and they need alerts and all that kind of stuff.
[00:55:05] TK: Yeah. Right. Oh, well done. That’d be particularly helpful if we can get some of the manually into data, um, automated. That’d be great. And some of the new stuff that we’re looking at, like, um, like buybacks and changes in dividends or cuts and
[00:55:20] TK: dividends.
[00:55:21] CR: All the manually entered data is automated. The,
[00:55:26] TK: I thought Alex was still doing
[00:55:27] CR: she does, but I give it to
[00:55:29] CR: her. I’ve got the whole thing automated. When she does her long download,
[00:55:35] TK: Well, good boy.
[00:55:36] CR: download, when she does her long download, her download once a month, she does it manually, but the rest of the time. It’s all automated now, but the one thing that isn’t, that I haven’t cracked yet, is the Qualified Orders.
[00:55:51] CR: The only thing I haven’t been able to crack is the Qualified Orders. And that is, that’s like, that’s the golden ring.
[00:56:00] TK: Book it in for
[00:56:01] CR: Oh yeah, it’s Sunday afternoon.
[00:56:02] CR: yeah. Cigar, glass of scotch, solve this
[00:56:07] TK: Cigar
[00:56:08] TK: butt. Yeah.
[00:56:10] CR: two stories that came out that I wanted to talk about and then I’ll shut up and you can talk for the rest of the show.
[00:56:14] CR: Um, uh, JYC, Joyce Corporation, it said Dan Smetana retires after 40 years. Dan Smetana. It’s got a nine out of 10 on my importance ranking system. Um, and it also analysed, so
[00:56:34] TK: Dan scored a 10.
[00:56:35] CR: nine out of
[00:56:36] TK: A 9. A 9, sorry, a 9.
[00:56:38] TK: Right,
[00:56:39] CR: AI, uh, ChatGPT said the retirement of a longstanding leader like Dan Smetana could lead to significant changes in company strategy and operations, influencing both management dynamics and investor confidence.
[00:56:53] CR: So there’s a full article here. Don’t need to read it, but, um, there you go. So he’s
[00:56:59] TK: Don’t think it has, Cam. Share price has,
[00:57:01] TK: gone up tremendously.
[00:57:02] CR: right. There you go. They, sorry, Dan,
[00:57:05] CR: people were like, you know what? You’re not that
[00:57:08] TK: So, so hang on. So, this is, is this the black box where the AI says this is important? You haven’t told the AI that someone who’s been involved for 40 years
[00:57:19] TK: retiring is important. It’s just worked it out, has it?
[00:57:21] CR: Yeah, ChatGPT read the article, summarized it, and then scored it based on the content of the article. Yeah,
[00:57:29] TK: but based on parameters you’ve set or
[00:57:31] TK: just worked it out for itself, it was
[00:57:34] CR: I told it to look for anything involving changes to the CEO or the CFO and stuff like that. Yeah, I gave it some parameters to guide it in its
[00:57:43] TK: Yeah. Wow.
[00:57:44] CR: And, um, this is one of the things that it
[00:57:47] CR: found. So, it looks like it’s a nice, smooth transition, um,
[00:57:54] TK: Well, looking, digging into it, which I did when I saw it, saw your notes. Uh, I mean, yeah, he’s, he has run the company since it listed, but since they bought it from, uh, Was it Western Foods? Anyway, since they bought it out of someone else’s conglomerate that was doing poorly. Um, the shares are held in a family name, so chances are there are other people involved, but they own 30 something percent, 36, 37 percent, 36.
[00:58:26] TK: 86 percent of the company. So the question is, will they continue with that shareholding or will they sell
[00:58:33] CR: hmm, Smetana,
[00:58:36] TK: if he’s retiring? There’s no other, there’s no other, um, What’s his name? SS No, that’s on the board. So that says to me that perhaps there isn’t a dynasty being created here and he’s the last one interested.
[00:58:51] TK: I don’t know. Um, but yeah, I think the interesting thing from that article is what happens with the shareholding.
[00:58:56] CR: hmm, okay, hmm, could end up in the market,
[00:59:01] TK: Yeah. And I, I imagine that a trade that big, um, might affect the, might depress the share
[00:59:06] CR: hmm,
[00:59:07] CR: so, hmm,
[00:59:11] TK: probably, take our, the founder status away from in our buy list as well.
[00:59:15] CR: okay, so, if you held the stock and you got this situation, news item. Um, I do hold it in a couple of portfolios and it’s up a lot. And it’s, uh, in the Stockopedia Australian portfolio, it’s up 56%. Um, in over a year we’ve held it. And in one of the live portfolios, it’s up 32 percent since February. Um, how would you play it?
[00:59:46] TK: Same way as I’d always play. Um, I don’t think it’s a red flag. I think I’ll just wait and see what the ship, whether it becomes a sell with the bread
[00:59:52] CR: Yeah, ok, right.
[00:59:54] TK: Yeah. Um, but yeah, there’s a risk. It’s heightened the risk of that block being sold on market at some stage. But yeah, it’s, it’s, it’s been doing well.
[01:00:03] TK: I mean, I, I’m more worried about doing a pulled pork run than a few months ago. That could be, that could be a bigger red flag than, uh, Dan Smetana getting old and taking his, um, retiring from the board and taking his, uh, toys home.
[01:00:20] CR: The other story that it pulled up was about, one of the other stocks that I hold, the National Australia Bank. They are being sued by ASIC for failures in financial hardship claims. Oh, by the way, one of the other things my script does is it removes duplicates stories. Cause always there’s like 10 duplicate stories in any feed from different outlets.
[01:00:46] CR: Scans them, analyses them for duplicates, removes all the duplicates. So I only get one version of each story. Chef’s Kiss. Oh! Oh! Oh!
[01:01:01] CR: Oh! If only I could write software to put into the brains of my family. Um. That, that’s where I’m going, just upgrade Fox’s, uh, brain to be great. Shut up about
[01:01:15] TK: Well, it’ll up upgrade as he grows older.
[01:01:18] CR: Yeah, well, I’m not sure it’ll be an upgrade. National Australian Bank has been sued by the corporate regulator for failures in dealing with customers experiencing financial hardship. ASIC has alleged that NAB did not respond to 345 hardship applications within the 21 day timeframe legally required. So, that’s all there is to that story.
[01:01:38] CR: Don’t think it’s going to affect NAB’s business a great deal, but, uh, always disappointing.
[01:01:44] TK: didn’t think so. They came out and apologized and said they got it wrong. Um, basic, get a bit of a win in the media might get a fine. I, I dunno if this one’s nine outta 10 too. I’m not sure if it’s a nine on my, uh,
[01:01:59] CR: Yeah,
[01:02:00] TK: profile of news stories.
[01:02:02] CR: it says potential damage to NAB’s reputation, it’s not really assessing who NAB is, I guess, and, you
[01:02:08] CR: know, the fact that, ha
[01:02:12] TK: I’m not sure, I was gonna, I was gonna make a bad joke about the reputation, not going any lower,
[01:02:17] TK: but
[01:02:18] CR: ha, yeah,
[01:02:19] TK: is a bad joke.
[01:02:19] CR: ha ha ha ha, yeah, yeah, anyway, that’s, uh, that’s all I got for you, Tony,
[01:02:28] TK: Well done.
[01:02:29] CR: it’s a big
[01:02:29] TK: Good stuff. Well, you’re gonna, you’re gonna make that, you’re gonna make your news, news, what do you call it? News app? News widget? Available to the members?
[01:02:39] TK: Are you gonna sell it? What are you gonna do?
[01:02:41] CR: I mean, I’m And what I am doing is, and I’ve been doing this last couple of days, is, um, if there’s something that comes up that I think is relevant, I’ll post it to our website. Um, and I’ll put it in the newsletters when they go out. Anything that’s relevant and, um, anything that’s really relevant like RSG related stuff, I’ll throw it up on Facebook and whatever and let people know.
[01:03:04] CR: But yeah, it’ll just become part of the, part of the service that we provide. Um,
[01:03:09] TK: Very good.
[01:03:11] CR: I, uh, I,
[01:03:12] TK: I guess if If 20 years of podcasting has taught you anything, it’s that you need content. This is generating content.
[01:03:20] TK: for you.
[01:03:20] CR: I’m a content producer, Tony. I’m a content generator, that’s what I am.
[01:03:26] TK: Soon to be replaced by AI. Yep. Well, I’ve got a few stories, Cam. We’ve had some stocks in the news over the last week. First one, good news stories. Our old friend, Daniel Smedley. Who still hasn’t come on the show, even
[01:03:50] TK: though you’ve asked him a couple of times. But he’s too busy. He’s too busy taking over
[01:03:55] CR: my report did pull up this story. My report,
[01:03:58] CR: it pulled up this story, but I didn’t think it was worth
[01:04:00] CR: talking about. But, um, okay. Yeah.
[01:04:04] TK: This could end up being one of the megafloats
[01:04:06] TK: of 2025.
[01:04:10] TK: Or 2026,
[01:04:11] CR: didn’t understand it.
[01:04:13] TK: Alright, I
[01:04:14] TK: didn’t.
[01:04:16] CR: No, it flagged it. And I was like, I read, I was like, I don’t care about what they’re doing with that. That’s that’s nothing.
[01:04:22] TK: Well, by the way, I mean, the background of Findi is that, um, it’s kind of resurrected from, it’s morphed from a different company into what it is now, which is an ATM provider in India. And it’s growing from there into providing digital banking services. The story is about it buying, um, uh, a whole heap of ATMs from Tata, the big Indian conglomerate.
[01:04:46] TK: And then, um. It also talks about, this is what really caught my attention, uh, the business being floated off onto the Indian Stock Exchange and suggests the guide is a float of 800 to a billion dollars, 800 million to a billion dollars. So, you know, this, this is a stock which if you bought it at the low point after, You know, gone through that restructuring and pivot in its business.
[01:05:13] TK: It’s up 20 times since then. It’s up a lot since I did the pulled pork on it. Um, and its market cap is at the moment is 370 million and it’s going to sell off a division for a billion dollars at the end of 2026. It’s saying it’s already hiring investment banks to do that. So, you know, it’s, it’s, um, this could be up If you bought it at the low point, 60 or 70 times in a couple of years.
[01:05:39] CR: Hmm. When
[01:05:40] TK: even though it’s a QAV stock, it’s done well, but really interesting article, interesting business, even if the IPO, you know, is a pipe dream. I don’t think it is, but it may not get away at a billion dollars. But, um, uh, the article says that, uh, Findi’s agreed terms to carve out a 75 million business from Indian juggernaut Tata’s communications business, Tata, I love that name, Tata, see ya, um, in a deal that will swell its top line by at least a third.
[01:06:08] TK: Uh, Street Talks, this is an article from the AFR, can reveal Findi is set to acquire Tether Communications Payments Solutions, which will bring 4, 600 operational ATMs into its network, another 3, 000 sitting in a warehouse, and the strategically important ability to connect directly with core banking systems.
[01:06:29] TK: Sources say the acquisition adds 30 million revenue to Findi’s guidance of 80 to 90 million for the 2025 financial year. So yeah, big, big boost to the current business. And if you think about What’s that? 7, 600 ATMs. I don’t know how many ATMs there are in Australia. I guess we could Google it and find out, but that’s probably like
[01:06:50] TK: buying the network in Australia.
[01:06:52] CR: the last time you used an ATM?
[01:06:56] TK: question, not for a while. And, you know, that’s the thing about this particular company. India hasn’t reached our stage of, you know,
[01:07:04] CR: Cashlessness.
[01:07:06] TK: yeah, everyone’s still using cash in India. But Findi are also acknowledging that the digital revolution will hit and they are investing in apps for banking as well.
[01:07:16] TK: And, you know, I think they’ll, well, they’re saying that they can transit from one to the other in time. But yeah, it’s, uh, it’s a huge, huge investment. Um, it’s also saying that they bought the business, which comes with 50 million in cash on the balance sheet. And, um, and it also gets the benefit of 10 years of tax losses.
[01:07:37] TK: So apparently there’s an accounting law in India, which says that not only can losses be carried forward, but if you transfer ownership, they get taxed. Transferred to the acquirer as well. So that’s a bit different to Australia, but, um, uh, that’s a huge benefit for them as well. So, you know, this, um, Daniel Smedley is doing a good deal
[01:07:56] TK: for the company, I think.
[01:07:57] TK: So, um,
[01:07:58] CR: Do you think he knows Mr. Smetana? Do you think the Schmedleys and the Smetanas hang out?
[01:08:05] TK: I don’t know, possibly, maybe they’ve got ATMs in the,
[01:08:09] CR: Smeg
[01:08:10] CR: Kitchen, Smeg Kitchen, and stuff. By the way, as of, according to ChatGPT, uh, as of June 2024, Australia had approximately 5, 476 ATMs, marking a 4 percent decline from the previous year and a 53 percent drop since 2019.
[01:08:31] TK: Yeah, there you go. So they’ve actually picked up in one deal more ATMs in India than they there are in Australia. Oh, as an aside, I was scratching my head during the week. I heard, I heard an announcement from the treasurer, Jim, Jim, I had to wash my hair, Jim Chalmers, saying that he was going to, Going to legislate to make sure that you could use cash to buy, to buy essentials.
[01:08:55] TK: And then, then, um, I think I heard it on the ABC News in the morning, and they were, they were asking viewers to come in and talk about when, you know, what essentials they used to buy cash. I think almost everyone said, They only take cash at the markets. And I’m like, what the, what the hell is the government doing trying to keep the cash economy going?
[01:09:15] TK: It’s, it’s, it’s the biggest anti avoidance of
[01:09:18] TK: GST
[01:09:19] CR: a drug dealer! The
[01:09:21] TK: Yeah.
[01:09:21] CR: you’re a drug dealer. You’re a drug dealer’s the
[01:09:23] TK: you want to be shutting down tax? Give all these people who want to use cash to buy their petrol and groceries. Some kind of card. Government should be doing that. Get it all on the, on the payment system so they can charge proper GST and collect the taxes to the right.
[01:09:39] TK: I thought that was very strange. Anyway, that’s an aside, but well done to Fendi. It’s, um, not only has it been, you know, restructured and, um, they found a very profitable market opportunity in India
[01:09:52] TK: for them. So, hats off to them. That’s
[01:09:54] CR: up 150 percent since I added it to our light portfolio back in May. Just
[01:10:02] TK: Maybe you sold
[01:10:04] TK: Atlas Pearls and
[01:10:05] CR: Yeah. I sold that was pearls in April. There you go. I
[01:10:09] TK: Ha ha ha ha ha.
[01:10:11] CR: All works out.
[01:10:13] TK: It does, yes. It’s a system. Um, and, and hats off to Gary, um, who, I think I owe him a beer, because he pointed out, I don’t know, what, about a month ago, that, uh, he said, hey, how come Tony Stallone in GrainCorp, because as you know, we put our stocks that we own on, on our disclosures page, what, why is Tony Stallone in GrainCorp when wheat as a commodity as a sell.
[01:10:40] TK: So, um, I looked into it and he was right. I shouldn’t have been owning it and, um, I sold it. And lo and behold, the price
[01:10:48] TK: dropped not too long
[01:10:50] TK: after it. So,
[01:10:51] CR: go up.
[01:10:51] TK: thanks a lot, Gary. No, that went down. I, I sold it,
[01:10:55] CR: What am I doing wrong? You sell it,
[01:10:57] TK: gotta wait for Gary to give
[01:10:58] CR: it, goes, Oh,
[01:10:59] TK: Gary gives you the inside word. Yeah.
[01:11:01] CR: okay, Gary.
[01:11:01] TK: Gives you the inside
[01:11:02] CR: you doing, Gary?
[01:11:04] TK: Yeah. So, um, the article again from the AFR, uh, East Coast Bay, East Coast based grain receival and storage company, GrainCorp, reported net profit of 61. 8 million in the 2024 financial year, a 75 percent drop from last year’s 250 million. Uh, revenue also fell 21%. Uh, and, uh, the CEO said relative to the To the site, well, our earnings in 2022 and 2023 were outsized.
[01:11:35] TK: We had earnings stream of over 700 million in 2022, 550 million in 2023. This year’s result is a normalization of those conditions. You have a couple of great years, and then it drops back down. That’s just what happens in farming. So, um, that’s why we use the Brain Commodity Price Chart as an indicator of what might happen.
[01:11:58] TK: Uh, yeah, so the article goes on to say, The more wheat, barley, and canola that passes through GrainCorp’s storage and handling network and seven port terminals, the more money it makes. In the 2024 financial year, GrainCorp handled 28 million tons of grain down from 37. Million, the previous year, uh, Mr.
[01:12:18] TK: Spurway, noted that’s the CEO, noted that international grain production over the past year had been reasonably strong in all areas which had dented Grain Corp’s margins. So I think actually, this is one of the stocks that benefited from the Ukraine war breaking out, because I think, uh, Ukraine was a big.
[01:12:39] TK: exporter of wheat, which, um, swung, swung back in the favour of GrainCorp being able to, or the farmers in Australia being able to export via GrainCorp more wheat overseas. That seems to have caught up with them now. Yes, so that was an interesting article, and I have one more, if you can bear with me, and this was sent in By Steve Mabb.
[01:13:03] TK: I saw it on the weekend. Thanks for coming down, Steve. Good to see you. Uh, but, um, I meant to read this out when you were talking about zombie companies. Um, this is, I think I meant to talk about this last week as well, and we didn’t get time, but, um, uh, the headline is Bright Brokers Hike Profitless, A SX, stocks to Rake in Fees.
[01:13:25] TK: Shameless, shameless Brokers, all About Moneymaking. Uh, it’s by our friend
[01:13:30] TK: Alex Glorias, who we’ve, um,
[01:13:33] CR: I reached out to Alex.
[01:13:34] TK: about a few times.
[01:13:35] CR: reached out to him. I invited him on the
[01:13:36] CR: show. he didn’t reply. Never replied.
[01:13:39] TK: Oh. Bummer. Analysts are encouraging investors to buy profitless ASX listed stocks despite their dismal track record of returns, creating a potential windfall for brokers who stand to rake in the fees if the troubled companies are forced to raise capital.
[01:13:58] TK: That’s part of what we were saying before, that if you’re holding these zombie companies, they’re going to raise capital, and there is a beneficiary to that, which is the broker. Uh, something which caught my eye in the article was that, um, uh, the analyst who’s quoted, MST Marquis, is the, is the company, uh, put together a dummy portfolio.
[01:14:20] TK: If a 100 model portfolio was to back loss making companies since 2000, the book would be worth just 0. 12 today, after compound average losses of 24 percent a year, according to MST. The ASX 300, meanwhile, has earned 8 percent a year on average over that time frame. So uh, Interesting dimension to why zombie companies exist and continue to exist, even when they don’t make money.
[01:14:46] TK: They make money for someone. Yeah.
[01:14:50] CR: mm
[01:14:52] TK: Thanks to Steve for sending that
[01:14:53] CR: It’s the, it’s just the, it’s the financial, financial industry. I won’t call it a scam, but it’s the business model. Right. It’s
[01:15:03] TK: a business model. It’s not a scam. I’m not doing anything untoward, but you’ll never, I think the article also points out the number of buy recommendations that exist by brokers on these
[01:15:14] TK: stocks. There’s a large number of buy
[01:15:16] CR: well, scams are business models too, just,
[01:15:19] TK: They are.
[01:15:20] TK: Yeah,
[01:15:22] CR: but it’s, yeah, taking, taking advantage of gullible investors, um, who are sold on the story and, um, uh, are willing to take a gamble and lose and then gamble again. Oh, there’s always fresh meat. Mmm,
[01:15:45] TK: There’s always fresh meat. There’s always a fresh story. It’s always a good story. We’re going to cure cancer. We’re going to solve climate change, global warming. It’s a thing of the past once we get all the slithy mad to the ground. All that kind of stuff. Yeah. So, um, someone benefits from it. A lot of
[01:16:03] TK: money.
[01:16:05] CR: Cui bono,
[01:16:06] TK: that’s all, that’s all I had. Um, I do have a pulled book, which I prepared on QBE, but we’ve been going for a while now, so I wonder if we should just hold it off till
[01:16:17] CR: yeah, hold it off until next week.
[01:16:19] CR: when my app
[01:16:20] TK: think
[01:16:20] TK: so.
[01:16:23] CR: I got no stories. Let’s get into after hours, Tony. What do you got?
[01:16:28] TK: Well, back from Cape Shanks, I’ve been down. We extended the stay down at Cape Schanck so we could watch Double Market on the weekend, race in a Group 1, our horse, which Steve Mabb and I own, or own most of, and, uh, unfortunately it didn’t do well. We, um, we were both excited. We thought it would do well, the stable thought it would do well, um, but it was a very windy day at Caulfield and the jockey sat four wide into a headwind for 800
[01:16:55] TK: metres and, uh,
[01:16:57] CR: translate that into
[01:16:58] CR: English? He sat four wide.
[01:17:01] TK: Uh, okay, so in racing, if there’s a headwind, you try and snuggle in behind the horse in front, like bike riders do on a peloton. So you’re not, you’re not exerting energy to pushing to a headwind like you’re not swimming against the tide so all the other smarter jockeys did that but left our jockey out on a limb um swinging against the 40 km headwind so we didn’t do too well he got off the horse and apologized and said that um it didn’t pan out the way he thought it would and he said if he had to run the race again he would have gone to the back and and then tried to Peel off and run home.
[01:17:39] TK: I didn’t say anything, but I thought to myself, yeah, I had 800 meters, 800 meters to work that out. You see, you couldn’t just pull the horse up and duck in anyway. But I don’t like armchair jockeys or grandstand jockeys as they’re called. Um, it’s a hard job, but, uh, you don’t get many horses in group ones, and that was a golden opportunity and we, we squandered it.
[01:18:00] TK: Or the jockey squandered it, or someone squandered it. So, the only good news is it wasn’t the horse’s fault. The horse has pulled up fine,
[01:18:06] TK: So hopefully we’ll get another shot at a good
[01:18:08] TK: race in the
[01:18:08] CR: So the jockey goes to the glue factory and the horse gets to run another day.
[01:18:14] TK: Well, that may have been Steve Mabb’s opinion. He was, uh, he was lobbying for a change of jockey, but, um, I’m going to sort of let my, let myself cool down before I call the trainer and have a chat about that. And we don’t have to hurry. The horse won’t race now until the order again. So we’ve got plenty of time to work out what to do about jockeys between now and then.
[01:18:36] TK: Yeah. So, um, exciting up until. The main race at Caulfield on the weekend and then a bit of a letdown after that. Uh, we also had Indubitably racing, was meant to race, uh, in, in and around Southeast Queensland and was accepted all over the place. But most of the races in Southeast Queensland were abandoned on Friday because of the wet weather.
[01:19:01] TK: And they were supposed to race today, I think. Um, and then that was abandoned because of the wet weather. So, um, she, she hopes to get a run on Friday at this stage. Depends on the weather gods up there. I guess it’s raining up there, what’s the weather like in Brisbane?
[01:19:17] CR: down. It’s
[01:19:18] TK: There you go. Yeah. Uh, so that’s the horse side of things.
[01:19:23] TK: Had a great stay at Cape Schanck. They played some, uh, a lot of golf and always helps being down playing golf. Your golf gets better. Uh, and then, oh, in terms of what I’ve consumed, the media I’ve consumed, uh, I’m into the second season of Broadchurch, which I’m enjoying. Um, very good. Uh, but I watched the movie.
[01:19:47] TK: It’s very dark. Oh, yeah, I mean, it is. Yeah, I warn you, it is dark, but just, it’s great to go back, you know, 10 years or however long it’s been and see those actors all together. It’s a bit like a Harry Potter film, it’s like every, all the best working TV actors in the UK have been put into the one series.
[01:20:05] TK: And series two, I think it’s Catherine Deneuve, I think is in it all, one of those old actresses.
[01:20:11] CR: Oh, I don’t remember.
[01:20:13] TK: 70s, someone, yeah, someone famous is playing a barrister in it. And Phoebe Waller Bridges, a young Phoebe Waller Bridges is playing the assistant barrister in it. So, yeah, so that’s what I mean.
[01:20:26] TK: There’s all these like Easter eggs
[01:20:27] TK: in there.
[01:20:28] CR: Wow. Before Fleabag or after
[01:20:30] CR: Fleabag?
[01:20:32] TK: I think it would be, I’m guessing before.
[01:20:35] CR: Wow.
[01:20:37] TK: Yeah. And plays the sort of really awkward, gangly, nerdy, smart girl,
[01:20:44] CR: She’s not the journalist?
[01:20:46] TK: making
[01:20:46] CR: Is she the
[01:20:47] TK: No, no, she’s the, no, she’s the solicitor assisting the barrister, whatever they call it in the
[01:20:52] CR: Right. Huh.
[01:20:55] TK: don’t know if they have solicitors in the UK, but that’s what she’s doing. But I watched the movie last night. Have you seen Prey?
[01:21:02] CR: Is that the Predator one? I
[01:21:05] TK: It is.
[01:21:06] CR: think I watched a bit of it
[01:21:08] CR: and just didn’t finish it. Yeah.
[01:21:12] TK: Yeah. Okay. Look, it’s low budget. Um, all the, all the computer graphics and, and computer sounds. I just, You know, recorded from the original Predator movie and replayed. So it’s, it’s low budget, but I really enjoyed it. I thought the acting was great. I thought, um, it was just a nice, tight, small budget, you know, low, low budget, high, uh, sci fi
[01:21:37] TK: movie.
[01:21:37] TK: I really enjoyed it. Ah,
[01:21:40] CR: Rampling is the actress in Broadchurch who we’re trying to recall.
[01:21:45] TK: I was not Catherine Deneuve, Charlotte Rampling,
[01:21:48] CR: her in it now. Yeah, she’s fantastic. She’s always fantastic. Hooray! I’ll have
[01:21:54] TK: I enjoyed Prey.
[01:21:54] CR: go. Yeah, I, the boys
[01:21:56] CR: raved about it when it came out. I think I watched a bit of it. I don’t remember finishing it though.
[01:22:03] CR: Well, I finished Banshees of Inisherin. Uh, Chrissy and I finished it. Loved it. Just loved it. Yeah.
[01:22:11] CR: Yes.
[01:22:12] TK: dark as well. Speaking of Dark, movies.
[01:22:14] CR: Dark, but with a lot of comedy in it. Very black comedy, but yeah, very dark. It just, those guys, Brendan Gleeson and Colin Farrell and the woman who played the sister, whatever her name is, I can’t recall, and all the smaller characters, just fantastic.
[01:22:31] CR: Yeah, it’s really good.
[01:22:34] TK: What’s the, what’s the, um, Irish guy? Is it Keoghan who played the small part?
[01:22:39] CR: Oh.
[01:22:39] TK: to make Saltburn
[01:22:41] CR: I, I
[01:22:42] TK: Barry. Barry Keoghan, I
[01:22:43] CR: something like that. Hunter was telling me that, I haven’t seen Saltburn yet, but we were talking, Hunter mentioned that guy and how he’s. Quite big now, but he was great in it as
[01:22:53] TK: He was,
[01:22:54] CR: slightly mentally deficient son who was getting sexually abused by his father, the police chief or the cop in town or whatever it was, alcoholic
[01:23:03] TK: mm Mm
[01:23:05] CR: And yesterday, uh, you and Spence and I did a podcast for a couple of hours to sort 20 years in politics. podcasting this week or next week. It’ll be my 20 years. The first episode of G’day World came out 29th of November, but we recorded it four or five days before that. Um, so right about the 24th, 25th of November.
[01:23:30] CR: Uh, 20 years of podcasting, and then Ewan, uh, we interviewed a few months later and his, his show on the Podcast Network came out in February 2005, the Mobile Show, Mobile’s Technology Show. Um, pre iPhone, two years pre iPhone. I was, I was explaining to him on the show, like, just to put it in context, how long ago this was, this is before the Doctor Who reboot.
[01:23:55] CR: That’s when we started
[01:23:56] TK: Oh wow.
[01:23:57] CR: the Doctor Who reboot. Because Ewan’s a big Doctor Who fan, being a Scotsman, and, um, we were, uh, I remember us talking about, I didn’t know who Russell T Davies was, I didn’t know really who Christopher Eccleston was, and we were talking about, Yeah, that later on when it happened, I think that was 2005, but yeah, 20 years in podcasting, uh, this week.
[01:24:21] TK: Is it still possible to download Gade
[01:24:23] TK: World? Are they still up there on the server in the cloud
[01:24:26] CR: many of them are, um, well, they were until the whole Spotify issue that happened a couple of months ago. I haven’t gone to the effort of fixing all of them yet. I’ve, the first one is, and some of the early ones, but, um, I haven’t. Got around to doing that one yet. Cause it’s not really a priority, but yeah, we lost a lot when I had the server crash of 2008, a lot of them got lost cause there weren’t backups.
[01:24:54] CR: Uh, but I do have backups of a couple of hundred G’day World episodes. They’re up on my cameronreilly.com site now, cause I didn’t renew the G’day World, um, domain name cause I couldn’t afford the 50 bucks to renew it at some point, somebody else has that now. It’s like a travel site. But, um, Yeah, so that was fun talking to Ewan.
[01:25:17] TK: do yourself a favour if you haven’t listened to some of those G’day Worlds and download them and have a listen. That’s
[01:25:23] TK: still my favourite. I loved
[01:25:25] CR: I’ll,
[01:25:25] TK: And I think, I think I was just admired your hood spirit. Ringing up people and getting them on the
[01:25:31] TK: show
[01:25:32] CR: We talked about that. Like we invented, because, uh, Mick and I, my original co founder, co host, uh, the first, we, I played a little bit of the first episode on this thing we did the other day. And the first 10 minutes were just Mick and I talking about how hard it was to make the podcast. Cause I, we call each other over Skype.
[01:25:54] CR: But then we had to figure out how to record the Skype call. The technology didn’t exist back then to do that. We had to figure it all out and we had cables going in and out of PCs and it was just a complete nightmare and then I had to upload the file to him via FTP and back in those days we Internet, and the, trying to upload a 150 meg audio file, which would fail, you’d, it’d spend 12 hours trying to upload, and then it would fail, and you’d have to start it again, and it was just this complete nightmare of production.
[01:26:33] CR: But then we’ve, when we figured out how to do it, we would start to Skype people and just say, hey, you’re on a podcast, and they’d go, what’s that? And,
[01:26:43] TK: But not just people. I mean, you had, uh, Tim Burners, Leon, you had,
[01:26:47] TK: um,
[01:26:47] CR: no, not Tim Berners Lee, never hit him on, I had, um, Vince Cerf.
[01:26:51] TK: oh, sorry. Vince
[01:26:52] CR: Yeah, and Ewan was saying he met Vince Cerf at
[01:26:55] CR: some event
[01:26:56] TK: Oh, right. Okay.
[01:26:57] CR: for people who don’t know Vince Cerf, in the 70s, Vince Cerf and one of his colleagues sat down in a hotel room somewhere near San Francisco and wrote a book. TCPIP, The Protocol, On Yellow Legal Pads, which is still the foundation of the internet today.
[01:27:18] CR: if you’ve ever seen the Matrix films, the, when Neo meets the Architect, the Architect is based on Vince Cerf, because he is the architect of the internet. And, uh, yeah, I got to, I got to talk to him, which, and Ray Kurzweil, and Leo
[01:27:33] TK: Well, that’s right.
[01:27:34] CR: Leo Sayer I got
[01:27:35] CR: to chat to, which was huge because I’m a huge Leo Sayer fan.
[01:27:40] TK: Yeah, but so many people, it was just incredible, the
[01:27:43] CR: Noam
[01:27:44] TK: of, I, Chomsky was the one I was trying to think of, yeah. You hit him on a couple of times I think,
[01:27:49] TK: didn’t
[01:27:49] CR: No, just once for Chomsky, but I had other guys on, um, and even, um, Oh, one of Spielberg’s partners, the guy who runs Spielberg’s animation company, whose name
[01:28:03] TK: right, you had, is it Katzenberg, not, it’s Katzenberg, wasn’t it?
[01:28:06] CR: Katzenberg, Yeah. had Katzenberg on? Yeah.
[01:28:10] TK: I know,
[01:28:10] CR: But yeah, it’s crazy, just talking about all the things that have happened, like, I remember having to explain to people what a podcast was when I launched it in February 20, 2005
[01:28:23] CR: at a conference in the U.
[01:28:24] CR: S., the podcast network, um, to all of the big hitters of the tech journalism industry over there. To today, where Trump being on the Joe Rogan podcast, a lot of people are saying is one of the, Turning the defining factors in in winning the election, probably played a small role, I think, but, you know, podcasting is now pretty mainstream, TV shows, Only Murders in the Building, Steve Martin, and Martin Short, Play podcasters in a TV show.
[01:28:59] CR: Like it’s, it’s been a crazy 20 years. And of course I’m rich and famous and have my own Island and private jet. And, um, It all panned out
[01:29:09] TK: bucks to register your company name, yeah. Well, it’s been an amazing journey, hats off to you. And I say, thank you, because, um, you know, you, you won’t believe this, but I was at the cutting edge of technology
[01:29:25] TK: 20 years ago and
[01:29:27] CR: You must’ve been, if you were listening to
[01:29:29] TK: early iPod. Yeah. Bought a very early iPod. And I think there wasn’t much out there to listen to in terms of podcasts, but the, the app was there, but, um, wasn’t much behind and not, not much that I wanted to listen to anyway.
[01:29:42] TK: There was, you know, like, uh, TV show clips and things like that. Radio, like The Breakfast Radio, people are just Record what they did and put it as a podcast. But, um, but no, um, Napoleon podcast was, um, just such a breath of fresh air. And the G’day World podcast was just
[01:30:00] TK: huge. I, loved it.
[01:30:02] CR: I always ex, you know, I explain to, to you, and I’ve always told this story, the, the turning point for me. ’cause I left Microsoft at the end of June, 2004. Went to Europe for a month, bought an iPod, went to bought, listened to audio books on it. When I went to Europe. Came back, podcasting kind of got invented, they say now in 2003, but it really, the first podcast really was 2000, July, 2004, no, August, 2004, the Daily Source Code when Adam Curry, former MTV VJ started his show. I started listening to that in August when I got back and then listened to the Engadget podcast, which was two tech. Journalists talking about, bloggers talking about the technology industry and in 2004, when you listen to anything about mainstream media, on mainstream media about technology, morning shows or radio or TV, it was always, have you seen what the kids are doing with the internet and the thing and it was all
[01:31:10] TK: Yeah.
[01:31:12] CR: and it
[01:31:12] TK: Oh, yeah.
[01:31:13] CR: to drive me nuts.
[01:31:13] CR: And then I listened to this
[01:31:14] CR: Engadget podcast and I was like, holy shit, this is like my friends and I talking about technology. I could listen to these guys for half an hour and it sounded like my friends and I, and that was the, like, blew my mind. I could listen to real people have real conversations about shit that I was interested in, which wasn’t radio.
[01:31:34] CR: You know, you could find stuff on RRR or something like that, but it was hard, you know.
[01:31:41] CR: The idea that you could just tune in and listen to intelligent people have intelligent conversations about intelligent topics was,
[01:31:50] TK: And carry it around with you, go for a walk, listen to it, catch up. Next week there’d be another one. And, um, and you didn’t have to sort of stay up until three o’clock in the morning to listen to the RRR to get this, the half an hour of. Interview you wanted to listen to, you could, you know, you could have it with you.
[01:32:07] TK: But I, but I remember too at the time, like, um, what, how revolutionary the design of the pod, the iPod was. So I was given, um, by my brother in law, Wal, who listens to this show, um, I think it might’ve been like a 500 gig hard, like portable hard drive, and it was like this brick. And I’m like, thanks. Merry Christmas.
[01:32:33] TK: Thank you. What, what do I do with this? You guys, it’s great. You can download all your music onto it. You can plug headphones and then listen to it. And you know, I got, I got to about the third CD, putting it into the disk drive on my Apple XT and loading it onto the thing. And then the thing was heavy to carry around.
[01:32:50] TK: It just didn’t work. But then the iPod came out a few months later and just all makes sense. Ah, this is what, That was trying to be, but it was, you know, hadn’t sort of gotten to the stage of being user friendly and it was just like a light bulb going off. You could take all your music with you, you could listen to podcasts.
[01:33:07] TK: It was just great.
[01:33:09] TK: Audiobooks.
[01:33:10] CR: hmm.
[01:33:11] TK: But, but yeah, no, like you’ve been a big part of my life over that 20 years listening to you regularly. Um, interest, always interesting, always, um, challenging, thought provoking. It’s been great.
[01:33:23] CR: I’ve got people that have been listening to me for 20 years out there, like, have grown up. Like, people that were listening to me when they were 20 and are now married kids, I get emails from people all the time going, you know, You’ve been in my head for half my life,
[01:33:39] TK: Yeah.
[01:33:39] CR: and shaped how I think
[01:33:41] CR: about politics and work and
[01:33:43] CR: philosophy, people who listen to The Three Illusions and all sorts of stuff.
[01:33:49] CR: Yeah, so it’s been about, you know, and I met Chrissy because of the Napoleon podcast. So if nothing else, It led me to you, it led me to Chrissy, to Ray, Ray and I have been working together for over 10 years. You know, some of the best friendships, working relationships, and you know, the, my wife, Fox, all came out of podcasting.
[01:34:10] CR: No money, but uh,
[01:34:13] TK: Ha ha ha ha
[01:34:14] CR: Lots of other great things came out of it, um, anyway. And then, um, I’m gonna do a series on fascism on the bullshit filter, I think, uh, next. So I’ve been reading a lot of books on fascism recently.
[01:34:28] TK: What do they call that when This is where podcasting’s gotten to. When they bring
[01:34:33] TK: up Hitler. What’s that called?
[01:34:35] TK: Is it
[01:34:35] CR: Rule 34.
[01:34:37] CR: Yeah, It’s Rule
[01:34:37] TK: Rule
[01:34:38] TK: 34, is it? Yeah. Okay.
[01:34:40] CR: everyone gets referred to as Hitler. Yeah, Rule 34 might be the porn version of something. It’s one of those rules.
[01:34:47] TK: Yeah.
[01:34:48] CR: There’s one of the rules that like, if it exists, there’s a porn version of it. I think Rule 34 might be the Hitler one. If
[01:34:59] TK: Yeah. Ha ha ha ha ha.
[01:35:00] CR: it goes on long enough,
[01:35:02] CR: yeah, no, it’s interesting because, you know, there’s, there was a lot of people, um, including former cabinet members or former chiefs of staff of Trump from his first administration, John Kelly, who said that he has fascist tendencies.
[01:35:17] CR: Mark Milley, who was the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff under Trump said that he’s a fascist. A lot of allegations that Trump is a fascist and a lot of people are pushing back on calling him a fascist or Hitler and, you know, I really, you know, I’ve, I’ve read stuff on fascism over the years, obviously in my study of, of the Cold War and World War II and stuff like that. But, um, I’m really interested in what, 20th century fascism was really shaped during the interwar period the conditions, particularly in Europe, very different to the conditions that we have in a place like The United States today, but there’s a lot of, a lot of, a lot of common elements, a lot of different elements, you know, fascism, you wouldn’t expect fascism to take the same form in America in 2024 that it took in Germany in 1924, right?
[01:36:18] CR: Or Italy or Spain. Um, so I’m, you know, I’m, I’m, I’m, Gonna do a deep dive, I’m looking at all of the old stuff, like I pulled out my old Trotsky book on fascism, he wrote a really good analysis of fascism in the 40s, um, but some more modern scholarly works too on fascism that I’m looking at by guys like Michael Mann, not the director, but a university professor in the U.
[01:36:46] CR: S. But, um,
[01:36:48] TK: And you know, there are some similarities. I mean, I read that Trump’s had over 900 rallies, you know, in his campaign for president. And that’s, I mean, that’s, we’ve all seen the footage of Hitler at rallies, whipping up the crowd with his speech. So it’s a similar, it’s a, it’s a parallel. I’m not sure if it’s exactly the same.
[01:37:14] TK: Because as you say, there’s no, yet, there’s no Great Depression. Going on, and particularly hard hit in Germany
[01:37:22] TK: with the constraints placed after World War I on
[01:37:24] CR: but there is a huge amount of economic inequality in the United States, and it’s been
[01:37:29] TK: that, but there is, yeah,
[01:37:31] CR: And I went back, you know, I’ve been drawing the lines to, for my boys actually, um, been explaining to them over the last few weeks what Citizens United was, cause they don’t know, they’ve never heard of the Citizens United ruling.
[01:37:45] CR: They don’t know anything about Occupy Wall Street. And I’ve been trying to explain to them these things that happened during the Obama administration, Occupy Wall Street, Citizens United was 2010, uh, where basically the United States Supreme Court decided that corporations could spend as much money as they wanted on election campaigns.
[01:38:07] TK: set up the
[01:38:07] CR: Who could have thought that would end badly? And then you had Occupy Wall Street
[01:38:14] CR: in 2011, and I went back, Yesterday, and I was looking at what Trump had to say at the time about Occupy Wall Street and what Obama had to say about Occupy Wall Street. And they both basically threw it under the bus. Both said similar things, actually.
[01:38:32] CR: Well, look, we understand, we kind of understand that they’re angry and why they’re angry, but basically, you know, then it got crushed. The police came in and crushed Occupy Wall Street and Obama did nothing about it. The Democrats did nothing really to change. The trajectory of growing income inequality in the U.
[01:38:52] CR: S. under him or under Biden. Uh, and so you’ve had this thing that’s been growing. He had the Tea Party around the same time, which was driven by the Koch brothers, but they were trying to, um, uh, uh, engage the dispossessed and the disenfranchised. And so, yeah, there’s a lot of similarities there. Uh, and, and, uh, It’s not as bad as Germany or Italy in the early 1920s, but, or during the Great Depression, but a lot of similarities, they’ve had depressions in the US, we’ve had recessions, we had 2008, you know, we’ve had these sorts of things happen, we’ve had manufacturing get stripped out of the country.
[01:39:35] CR: Then the other thing is looking for paramilitarism. Um, obviously one of the big defining factors of fascism was the paramilitaries.
[01:39:44] TK: yeah,
[01:39:45] CR: not walking around with a paramilitary, but the,
[01:39:50] TK: proud boys stand down,
[01:39:51] CR: yeah, so you have the Oath Keepers, you had the Proud Boys, you had the whole capital rights thing, which they were big.
[01:39:57] CR: Fifteen hundred of them have been charged, which will all obviously go away. Wait to see, I’m, I’m waiting to see what happens with their recruitment drives after all of their charges get dismissed and Trump’s. in the White House again.
[01:40:13] TK: lots of them are in jail, so they’ll be released, they may have already been released,
[01:40:17] TK: by now.
[01:40:18] CR: Some of, some of the leaders are in jail. Um, the, the organizations themselves pretty much fell apart after the Capitol riot charges and convictions and all that kind of stuff. But I expected them, I expect them to all be back. In a huge way now.
[01:40:35] TK: With their own version of Mein Kampf under their arm from time on their hands in
[01:40:39] TK: jail.
[01:40:40] CR: Yeah. And you know, people say to me, people arguing, Oh, Trump’s not a fascist. He just says stuff. It’s just political theatre. And I go, yeah, that’s what people said about Mein Kampf when it came out too. Oh no, you can’t take Hitler seriously. He’s just crazy. He just says stuff. He’s just saying stuff to, you know, get people’s attention.
[01:41:02] TK: Well, I think, what do I think? I think that Trump, I think you said it before, Trump does display fascist tendencies, and it, you know, there won’t be another Nazi Germany. I don’t think anyway, it looks like Nazi Germany did in the 1930s, but there could be something which is fascist in nature. I’m careful of throwing that word around, I used to throw it around a lot, you know, called Malcolm Fraser a fascist.
[01:41:34] TK: When he cut welfare for students. So, um, you know, it’s a word that gets tossed around a lot, particularly against, um, conservatives. Um, but I think there’s a, there’s an element of truth in what you’re saying. And so I think the thing is, what are the, what are the, What are the signs to be aware of? If I ever, and I think, you know, back because probably everyone has done, what would I have done if I was around in Nazi Germany in 1933 or 34?
[01:42:06] TK: And I think, you know, you’d probably try and go about your life. You might try a bit of passive resistance, sort of, you know, passive aggression or something. But the, if I think about it, the only outward visible sign that the world had that something was bad was going on in Germany was that smart people were leaving.
[01:42:25] TK: We haven’t seen that yet for the U. S. I remember when Trump got elected the first time, Alex was deciding where to go to university, and I think from memory, in what was usually a big market at a Canadian school, for U. S. enrolment, one person in her whole senior year went to an American university.
[01:42:45] TK: Whereas you’d expect, You know, the majority of them to go down to an American university because they’re just across the border. They’re on their doorsteps. Um, and there’s such a big thing on the CV. So if you have a chance to go to Princeton or Harvard or one of those prestigious places, you’d take it.
[01:43:00] TK: But I think only one person did because they were, they were just frightened of being a part of Trump America. Um, so that’s, they’re the kind of telltale signs I’ll be looking for is when, when do the. When do the
[01:43:12] TK: smart people leave?
[01:43:15] CR: Well, in Germany it was the smart Jewish people who left when things started to look dicey. Um, I don’t think Trump,
[01:43:26] TK: too far gone,
[01:43:27] TK: but yeah.
[01:43:28] CR: yeah, I don’t think Trump’s America is going to be that anti Semitic, but they’re going after a different kind of target.
[01:43:35] TK: They’re still going after elitists and, you know, a lot of people in the universities left Germany early on.
[01:43:41] CR: The radical
[01:43:42] TK: They just couldn’t get work.
[01:43:43] CR: is who they’ll go after in the
[01:43:44] CR: US. I got this quote, a guy called Roger Berkovitz, who, you know who Hannah Arendt was? You ever read her stuff?
[01:43:53] TK: do not, no.
[01:43:54] CR: Uh, Hannah Arendt was an author, a German. Uh, Descended Scholar, who wrote a lot of stuff about the holocaust in Germany. Um,
[01:44:06] CR: she, um, she was a Jewish, uh, German Jewish American scholar, I think, from memory.
[01:44:11] CR: I read one of her books years ago, but Roger Berkowitz sort of runs the Hannah Arendt whatever, you know, um,
[01:44:20] TK: foundation,
[01:44:21] CR: something like that. I was reading one of his articles. From a little while ago, but I like this, this, uh, paragraph. The modern condition of rootlessness is a foundational experience of totalitarianism.
[01:44:35] CR: Totalitarian movements succeed when they offer rootless people what they most crave, an ideologically consistent world aiming at grand narratives that give meaning to their lives. By consistently repeating a few key ideas, a manipulative leader provides a sense of rootedness grounded upon a coherent fiction that is consistent, comprehensible, and predictable. He wrote that in 2017. So in the early stages of Trump’s first term,
[01:45:14] TK: I was listening to a couple of podcasts in my journeys over the last few days, some long, long form ones analysing the elections, and one of the things that seemed to be settled on was that Trump picked up the disaffected voter that, you know, so many people in the US don’t vote because they just don’t have time for the system.
[01:45:33] TK: But Trump made inroads into that disaffected voter
[01:45:37] TK: along the lines of what you’re saying or what that article was
[01:45:39] CR: but also picked up the working class, I mean, you know, picked up the working class and got, made inroads into the Latino and the African American vote.
[01:45:50] TK: Yep. Mm
[01:45:51] CR: Um, you know, there’s a lot of, like, it gets back to. Occupy Wall Street and the Tea Party and all that kind of stuff. There’s been this growing movement for decades of the disenfranchised in America who, manufacturing has gone to Mexico and China, farming is struggling, you know, it’s been farming is sort of been, um, centralized and, you know, uh, they’ve corporatized,
[01:46:15] TK: corporatized,
[01:46:17] CR: that’s the word I’m looking for, and the financial sector has gone, you know, it keeps having.
[01:46:24] CR: These huge busts and all this money’s
[01:46:26] TK: Oh, I mean, I mean,
[01:46:27] CR: and,
[01:46:29] TK: and most big companies only employ university
[01:46:31] TK: graduates. That kind of thing,
[01:46:33] CR: and it costs you a million dollars to get a university education. Um,
[01:46:39] CR: yeah, so there’s this undercurrent of, uh, stuff happening over there. And here too, we’ve got the. Housing crisis here, you know, it’s, it’s, there’s a lot of, a lot of anger, a lot of, uh, people feeling like they’re missing out on the Australian dream.
[01:46:57] CR: Like these people feel like they missed out on the American dream. It
[01:47:03] TK: Well, be careful what you wish for because, um, I played golf with a guy who’s older than me. He worked in Japan, lived in Japan, and he was saying that 30 years ago, the property market, the average price was a million bucks for a house and it dropped back to 300, 000 overnight. And it’s only getting back up to that level now, 30 years on.
[01:47:24] TK: So that solved the problem. Better access to housing, but it’s not, it’s not a solution that people will find palatable.
[01:47:34] CR: was an economic collapse
[01:47:35] TK: other things done. Yeah. But, um, you know, that, that struck me yesterday, like, or soon after the election. It may not have been yesterday, but I agree with you. It’s glaringly obvious that if the government wants to be re-elected in Australia, or if they’re the opposition and want to be elected, it’s the economy stupid.
[01:47:54] TK: And what’s the government Come out on Monday and spend political capital on? Keeping kids off social networks. It’s like, fuck, that’s a classic elitist democrat, you know, big government will run your family better than you can approach to policymaking. When big, the big relative overseas has told you what you need to focus on and you’re not doing it.
[01:48:24] TK: It’s just, it’s just absurdly stupid. It’s like going to see a Godot play.
[01:48:30] CR: Yeah. But, you know, yes, but we’ve seen the rise in this country. We saw it during COVID, uh, like they did in the US, the rise of people getting sucked into stupid narratives too.
[01:48:46] TK: Yeah. Yeah,
[01:48:47] CR: Um, people who should know better, like I had friends, and I’m sure you had friends that I thought of as intelligent
[01:48:56] TK: Mm hmm.
[01:48:57] CR: people. I just saw got caught up in the QAnon narrative and at first I gave them the benefit of the doubt.
[01:49:07] CR: I spent like the first year of COVID going, all right, let’s, let’s have a conversation about what you believe and why you believe in what’s the evidence for this case that you’re making. And after about a year, I just gave up. I was like, okay, you don’t, um, you don’t really care about facts or evidence or logical reason.
[01:49:26] CR: Do you just want to believe what you want to believe?
[01:49:28] CR: And.
[01:49:29] TK: Well, they think they are. They think they are. They think they have the set of facts. I think Moses has come down the mountain and they’re, and it’s a, yeah, they’re the chosen people to interpret the
[01:49:39] CR: I would get emails from people, you know, from around the world, listening to the bullshit film or whatever it was, that would send me, like, lengthy emails. Watch all these YouTube videos and read all these things, and I would, and it took me about three minutes with each one to just go, oh, hold on.
[01:50:01] TK: yeah,
[01:50:02] CR: What? And I would point that out to them.
[01:50:05] CR: Hold on. Well, they said that they made these claims in the first three minutes of the video, which are objectively wrong and, and, and
[01:50:12] TK: yeah, it can be
[01:50:13] CR: with the smallest amount of, you know, looking into it and they go, Oh, but then you watch these 12, three hour long YouTube videos. I’m going to wait, deal with this one first.
[01:50:24] CR: And then we’ll talk. No, but it’s just, it’s
[01:50:27] TK: I know. you know what? I saw that, I saw that 30 years ago when I was working in central Queensland, but it just didn’t have the technology boost behind it. So I remember being given a VHS recording, kind of like, you know, yeah, check this out, Tony, don’t tell anyone you watch it tonight when you’re at home by
[01:50:47] CR: Yeah,
[01:50:48] TK: And it was this guy. Uh, really low grade video, standing behind the lectern,
[01:50:54] TK: talking about the One
[01:50:56] CR: the New World Order. I used to
[01:50:58] TK: But you will order! Yeah!
[01:51:00] CR: people in the late 80s, early 90s. I used to have guys telling me about that. And I used to say, sounds good to me, like one world government, like I can move to any country I want, like we just have one set of laws. So what’s
[01:51:15] TK: no more
[01:51:16] CR: yeah, what’s the problem?
[01:51:17] CR: They go, I
[01:51:17] CR: don’t understand. I go, yeah, what’s,
[01:51:22] CR: isn’t
[01:51:22] TK: But I remember
[01:51:23] CR: that what we want to get to? Isn’t
[01:51:25] CR: that the goal?
[01:51:26] TK: the first three minutes of this video was this guy going, went into the New York Public Library and tried to get these books out on the New World Order, and they wouldn’t give them to me. That’s proof! It’s proof it exists! I’m like, no, they just, either they didn’t have them, couldn’t find them, or they just, well, they didn’t have a library card, yeah.
[01:51:49] TK: Why would they try, they’re a library, why would they try and hide books?
[01:51:53] CR: Yeah. Look, the thing, like, the difficult thing, you know, we had to handle when we did the Psychopath Epidemic book, and I’ve had to handle on all my shows over the years, is that the more you read about history and the more you read about how the world works, There is a lot of propaganda. There is a lot of lies being told.
[01:52:16] CR: We are being lied to constantly by corporations and politicians and religions and think tanks,
[01:52:25] TK: Kerry Stokes,
[01:52:27] CR: Stokes,
[01:52:27] CR: the media. We, so people are right to be, like I always say, you
[01:52:33] TK: Alan Jones.
[01:52:34] CR: right to be skeptical.
[01:52:36] TK: Correct.
[01:52:37] CR: Being skeptical is your first response to anything you hear, I think, is the rational response.
[01:52:45] CR: But before you believe in a, in some theory or whatever’s happened, what, if something’s going on, some theory that
[01:52:53] TK: used to be UFOs. Now
[01:52:54] CR: still UFOs, UFOs are huge, man. I follow all of the UFO subreddits because they amuse the hell out of me. Um, and it’s, they’re absolutely bonkers. Um, And they’re so convinced they’re right, and everyone’s crazy, and oh, it’s all gonna come out!
[01:53:11] CR: Soon as Trump’s in the White House, the first time, it was all gonna come out. Trump
[01:53:15] TK: Yeah, that’s right, he was gonna release, he was gonna, yeah,
[01:53:18] CR: assassination, he’s gonna release it all!
[01:53:21] TK: the footage,
[01:53:22] CR: This time it’s going to be Jeffrey Epstein’s murder. He’s going to release all the information. Well, except Trump goes, some people’s lives could get ruined and we don’t want to do that.
[01:53:31] CR: And by some people, I mean mine. And
[01:53:34] TK: I’ve looked at it. I’ve looked at it. It’s, it’s incredible. What just
[01:53:39] TK: happened?
[01:53:41] CR: uh, but yeah, like, like my thing, like, yes, you should be skeptical. We’re being lied to, but before you believe a theory is true,
[01:53:54] TK: Yeah.
[01:53:54] CR: sure you have enough evidence. To be able to back it up, um, do, do some work, do some research.
[01:54:02] TK: Especially in this day and age, when you’re carrying around the Encyclopedia Britannica in your pocket, just
[01:54:06] TK: look, look it up.
[01:54:08] CR: Yes. And then, you know, I always go on about my rule of thumb, which is heuristics and, and epistemology have, have, have a way of understanding. How do we know what is true in this particular, yeah. Have a framework. Exactly. Have a framework for how you think. Think about the topic that is rational and objective.
[01:54:29] CR: Cause you can’t be an expert. You’re never going to be an expert on stuff. It doesn’t mean you can’t educate yourself, but you have to know, okay, what’s my heuristic for this? Who do I turn to? Why do I turn to these people? Why are all these institutions, why are they credible? Why are they respectable? How do I know they’re not full of shit?
[01:54:50] CR: and running their own scam, um, you have to have a, we don’t, we don’t get taught how to do that. We don’t get taught how to think logically and rationally. It’s, there’s no, I don’t know.
[01:55:06] TK: And it, there’s no money. And it’s one of the things that Trump’s going to shut down or Elon’s going to shut down. The
[01:55:12] TK: liberal universities. Yeah.
[01:55:15] CR: you know, and again, getting back to fascism, like Trotsky always, Trotsky’s view was that fascism was where capitalism went when it’s traditional mechanisms of control. I’m pretty sure I quoted this in the psychopath epidemic. When capitalism’s traditional methods of controlling the people started to falter.
[01:55:40] CR: They went to authoritarianism and fascism tended to be a pro capitalist form of authoritarianism as a means of reasserting control when the traditional institutions of control started to fail. People asked too many questions, started pushing for too much change, too much revolution, you know.
[01:56:07] TK: So we should all go out and buy 7 West Media shares to
[01:56:10] TK: keep that method of control alive. Yeah, it’s our bulwark against fascism.
[01:56:17] CR: Free sport. People need the Free sport.
[01:56:23] TK: Actually, the people can go and watch it if they want. It’s 7 West Media who needs the free
[01:56:27] TK: sport. It’s not the
[01:56:29] CR: I watched the Tyson fight for free on the weekend. Did you watch that?
[01:56:33] TK: God. No.
[01:56:35] CR: I wasn’t planning on it, but then we got home from Kung Fu and after,
[01:56:41] TK: fired up.
[01:56:41] CR: oh, and my finger got
[01:56:42] CR: broken, You see my finger?
[01:56:45] TK: Oh, wow.
[01:56:48] CR: what it should look like.
[01:56:49] TK: Yeah,
[01:56:50] CR: This finger got bent
[01:56:52] CR: back during sparring on Friday night and it all got swollen and it was all bruised.
[01:56:56] CR: I went and did, that was Friday night, then I went and did another couple of hours of kung fu on Saturday morning and we got home and we were just knackered and it was about the time the fight was due to start so I said to Fox, hey you want to watch Mike Tyson fight?
[01:57:10] TK: Oh.
[01:57:10] CR: So we sat down and we watched
[01:57:12] CR: it and afterwards Fox, and we had Hunter and Taylor on FaceTime watching it as well so we’re all doing it.
[01:57:19] CR: Afterward Fox went Well, that was the biggest waste of time I’ve ever seen.
[01:57:25] TK: Oh, because there was no
[01:57:26] TK: knockout.
[01:57:27] CR: Cause it was just stupid. The whole thing was Tyson basically just. Barely threw a punch, it was just get through eight rounds, that was like against a guy half your age. Tyson just
[01:57:42] TK: Because he bet
[01:57:42] TK: on himself to last eight rounds,
[01:57:45] CR: Well, I think he was
[01:57:45] CR: getting paid 20 million dollars either way and probably, I don’t know, I’m guessing it was a, there was a bonus for From Netflix, if it went on as long as possible.
[01:57:59] TK: Yeah,
[01:57:59] CR: know, I said to the boys at the, before it even like, when it was announced, I said, this is a, this, like everything Jake Paul does, it’s, uh,
[01:58:07] CR: It’s bullshit. It’s just, it’s, it’s a
[01:58:10] TK: Yeah.
[01:58:11] CR: It’s WWE boxing, you know.
[01:58:15] TK: just like the American
[01:58:16] TK: elections are WWE
[01:58:18] CR: America’s been completely WWE’d. The whole culture’s WWE’d. Anyway, so then we, and it was. It was just such a,
[01:58:27] TK: And I didn’t
[01:58:27] CR: uh, it was so appalling.
[01:58:29] TK: not a big, I must admit, I’m not a big fan of boxing anyway. I mean, I, I did grow up watching Muhammad Ali, who was an amazing
[01:58:37] CR: Yeah.
[01:58:38] TK: Um, yeah,
[01:58:39] CR: an incredible human being, too. I mean, really, a man with very, very high integrity and principles and, um, put it on the line, had his belt taken away from him. no Viet Cong never called
[01:58:54] TK: gold medal in the river.
[01:58:55] CR: N word. Yeah, Yeah, like a man of very high principles and integrity.
[01:59:02] CR: I mean, I, I think he may have one of his wives a few times, so I don’t want to apologize for that, but he was a black man who grew up in the South in the fifties and sixties.
[01:59:12] CR: So, you know, not making excuses for violence against women. You know, there was a time Sean Connery did it.
[01:59:22] TK: Did he really?
[01:59:24] CR: yeah.
[01:59:24] TK: Oh, that’s,
[01:59:25] CR: Oh yeah, Sean Connery had a
[01:59:26] TK: was a, I was a
[01:59:27] CR: Sean Connery used to go on talk shows and say that, uh, you know, you have to smack a woman around, smack her in the mouth a few times so she remembers her place.
[01:59:38] TK: Okay.
[01:59:40] TK: I never saw any of those
[01:59:41] CR: But the way he said it,
[01:59:43] TK: They’ve been, probably been,
[01:59:44] TK: censored. Probably can’t see them
[01:59:45] CR: I don’t know, when he died, all this stuff came out. It was, it got revived by certain people, but he said it, it sounded cool. You know, you gotta, you gotta hit her a few times, slap her in the face a few times, just so she knows where she stands. She’ll appreciate it. You know, she knows that, uh, she’s truly loved if you slap her in the face a few times, Miss Moneypenny.
[02:00:08] TK: Did he, Did
[02:00:08] TK: he really say that?
[02:00:10] CR: I, I swear to God, like, I can’t, I can’t believe you’re questioning me. Well, like, like, who am I? Like. Conspiracy,
[02:00:19] TK: who are you? You, you are, you’re, I’m gonna have to go away and
[02:00:25] CR: to this I know Sean Connery regrets this conversation. An interview in which you said, What’s the worst thing to slap a woman now and then? As I remember you said, you don’t do it with a clenched fist, it’s better to do it with an open hand.
[02:00:38] CR: Yeah, remember that? Yeah. Yeah. I didn’t love that. I haven’t changed my opinion. You haven’t? No, not at all. You think it’s good to slap a woman? No, I don’t think it’s good. You don’t think it’s bad? I don’t think it’s that bad. I think that it depends entirely on the circumstances and if it merits it, yeah.
[02:00:55] CR: And what would merit it? Well, if you have tried everything else, and women are pretty good at this, they can’t leave it alone, yeah. They don’t want to have the last word, and you give them the last word, but they’re not happy with the last word. They want to say it again and get into a really provocative situation.
[02:01:18] CR: Then, I think it’s absolutely right. ha!
[02:01:26] TK: No
[02:01:26] TK: dear.
[02:01:27] CR: ha!
[02:01:28] TK: I didn’t, I didn’t know
[02:01:29] CR: no. Any, any other heroes you want me to destroy while we’re on the show?
[02:01:37] TK: Don’t say anything about Michael
[02:01:38] CR: Oh, no, I’ve got nothing bad to say about Michael Caine.
[02:01:43] TK: Well that’s cool
[02:01:43] CR: You’re only supposed to blow the bloody doors off!
[02:01:49] TK: Yeah. Yeah, Kane and Sean Connery are my two favourites from growing up.
[02:01:54] CR: Ugh,
[02:01:55] TK: The Men Who Would Be Kings, one of my favourite films when I was growing up.
[02:01:59] CR: don’t think I’ve seen that one. I mean, it would be King’s, eh?
[02:02:02] TK: Do Yourself A Favour,
[02:02:03] CR: Gotta add that to my
[02:02:04] CR: list.
[02:02:05] TK: Peachy, Peachy, and who was the other guy? They played British army officers who went rogue and went freelance in Pakistan or India
[02:02:13] TK: or somewhere like,
[02:02:13] TK: that.
[02:02:15] CR: Oh, like,
[02:02:16] TK: war so they could fight either side. It’s a Rudyard Kipling book.
[02:02:19] CR: oh, okay. Like
[02:02:20] TK: And it’s where Michael Caine hired Shakira, uh, Shakira, his wife, to, to be in
[02:02:27] CR: Oh, have you ever seen the Three, the Three Kings?
[02:02:33] TK: The George Clooney
[02:02:34] CR: Yeah,
[02:02:35] TK: Yeah.
[02:02:36] CR: sort of thing.
[02:02:37] TK: Where they steal the gold? Nah. Completely different.
[02:02:39] CR: okay.
[02:02:40] TK: Yeah. These are good actors. Iconaria. Iconaria.
[02:02:44] TK: And Caine. Hahaha. Haha.
[02:02:47] CR: Okay.
[02:02:49] TK: Ooh, nah, great film.
[02:02:50] CR: All right. Well, I think that’s enough. It’s another like two hour show talking about fascism or something. Tony, we, you know. What?
[02:02:58] TK: hours 20. Well, it’s 20, it’s 20
[02:03:03] TK: past 6 my time here and we started at
[02:03:05] CR: Oh my God. I was only joking. I didn’t know. We gotta stop talking. All right.
[02:03:14] TK: Time flies when we have fun and we do.
[02:03:17] CR: All right. Thank you, Tony. Have a good week. Anyone
[02:03:19] TK: You’re welcome. Thank you.
[02:03:24] TK: Yes, happy ASX.

0 Comments