Skip to content

James Kirby, Financial Literacy: QAV AU #956

This week we chat with James Kir­by from The Aus­tralian’s Mon­ey Puz­zle pod­cast about finan­cial lit­er­a­cy (starts 23:30), AI replac­ing finan­cial plan­ners, and the sur­pris­ing­ly niche world of rare book col­lect­ing. We also cov­er BRI jump­ing 41% on a takeover bid, run the num­bers on Nvidi­a’s PROPCAF, and dig into lis­ten­er ques­tions on the qual­i­ty score and 3PTL back­test­ing. After Hours goes deep into Klaus Kin­s­ki, Wern­er Her­zog, and the great­est unhinged Let­ter­man appear­ance you’ve nev­er seen.

 

This week’s full episode is being made avail­able to every­one. Also check out our pod­cast archives link and our pages on Apple Pod­casts or Spo­ti­fy or watch clips on Tik­Tok. Or vis­it our home­page to learn more about QAV and how it works as a val­ue invest­ing sys­tem that you can learn and apply to beat the mar­ket.

Tran­scrip­tion

QAV AU 956 REVIEW VIDEO

Cameron: [00:00:00] Wel­come to QAV Aus­tralia 956. It’s the 17th of Novem­ber, TK, and you’re in your new digs. Look at that

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Still plen­ty of pack­ing box­es to get through.

Cameron: Yeah. thing you have peo­ple to do that for you

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. That’s the Jen­ny approach. She likes to get peo­ple in all the time. I’m just like, “I’ll get to it.” But no, she’s got peop- which just com­pli­cates things for me. You know? Yeah.

Cameron: Yeah.

Tony Kynas­ton: I’m try­ing to record a pod­cast and there’s peo­ple run­ning around the

Cameron: around.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Any­way.

Cameron: to be, uh,

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, good. Yeah, good. Yeah. But I was, I was say­ing to, uh, some peo­ple I was talk­ing to yes­ter­day, we moved in last week. The movers came on Wednes­day, and by lunchtime it was real­ly clear that half the stuff had­n’t arrived. They’re like, “We’re just the movers. We don’t know where it is. We’ll get back to you.”

Cameron: Oh.

Tony Kynas­ton: [00:01:00] so yeah, we, we’ve been sleep­ing in the place, but, uh, haven’t been able to sit at the table or, um, you know. We had to go out and buy bed linen and stuff like that, and a toast­er and, yeah, ’cause we just did­n’t have half the stuff. And then, uh, uh, we got a call on Fri­day say­ing, “We found it,” and then so they booked in for Mon­day.

But I was in Syd­ney doing climb stuff. And then, um, so Jen­ny had to be here and Alex was here on Mon­day for the removal­ists to come back in, and same thing hap­pened again. By lunchtime they’re going, “Uh, uh, yeah, I can see it on the list, but it’s not here.” So, so we’re wait­ing for anoth­er drop to be. Well, they’ve got­ta find the stuff first and then bring it to us

Cameron: stan­dard of cus­tomer ser­vice in Aus­tralia that we’ve come to

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, you know, it’s just, I don’t. Like I was say­ing, I flew to Syd­ney and I was on the 5:30 flight on Sun­day after­noon, ’cause I had to go to this AGM, right? So I thought I can fly up Mon­day morn­ing, and a cou­ple of the peo­ple from Mel­bourne did, and they got in at, like 11:00 o’clock, and the meet­ing start­ed at 9:00, ’cause [00:02:00] of the delays.

So I thought, you know, go up Fri­day, I go up Sun­day. 1:00 o’clock in the after­noon I get a text from T- uh, Qan­tas, “Your flight’s been can­celed. We’re now putting you on a 3:30 flight, and you’re fly­ing via Can­ber­ra in a light air­craft to get you to Syd­ney.” So I re- that’s like, that leaves at 3:30, so I had, like two hours to get to the air­port.

Ring ’em up. Um, delays on the, on the ser­vice line. “Okay. Well, we’ll put you on the 8:00 o’clock flight.” Yeah, that’s fine. Get to the air­port, that’s delayed. So, you know, I got into Syd­ney just before the cur­few at 11:00, 11:30 or what­ev­er it was. Got to the hotel. You know, it’s just noth­ing works any­more, Cam

Cameron: Why do you think it is, Tony? Is it Albo’s fault? Albo

Tony Kynas­ton: So that’ll be RBA’s fault. It’s always the RBA’s fault.

Cameron: RBA, RBA

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Put inter­est rates up and every­one just went, “Oh, it’s all too hard. We’ve got­ta cut costs.”

Cameron: [00:03:00] I’ll tell you who else isn’t hap­py, peo­ple that bought Trump coins, Tony

Tony Kynas­ton: Do you think Trump’s hap­py?

Cameron: Prob­a­bly. Yeah, he’s prob­a­bly made

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: I see that, uh, the Trump coin, this is in the Reuters I saw this morn­ing. Trump coin launched, it went up to $74 in 2025. You wan­na

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: at what a Trump coin is worth at the moment?

Tony Kynas­ton: A pen­ny.

Cameron: How about that? Yeah.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: I don’t know, some­thing like 94 cents or some­thing like that.

I don’t know. It’s dropped 94% is

Tony Kynas­ton: That’s a big tar­iff.

Cameron: But, uh, th- they’re, they’re doing the third round of Trump coin plugs at the moment, and the peo­ple who invest the most get to have din­ner with Trump, and some­body said, “Yeah, it’s almost free now,

Tony Kynas­ton: I was, well, his diary.[00:04:00]

Cameron: No. Yeah, that

Tony Kynas­ton: He’s sud­den­ly got time for din­ner with peo­ple who own Trump coins.

Cameron: Yeah.

Tony Kynas­ton: He’s a lame duck, lame duck pres­i­dent now

Cameron: why would I not go if it cost me noth­ing to go?” said some­one

Tony Kynas­ton: Hey, we should buy 90. Yeah, you got 94 cents? We’ll go and have din­ner with Trump.

Cameron: Right

Tony Kynas­ton: But our plane will be delayed. Our f- We’ll miss it. Yeah

Cameron: I think it’s got to the point where Trump’s pay­ing peo­ple to take the coins now, but he’s not pay­ing it out of his own mon­ey. He’s get­ting the trea­sury to pay it or some­thing like that

Tony Kynas­ton: He’s get­ting Jensen Huang to play, to

Cameron: Yeah.

Tony Kynas­ton: pay.

Cameron: Well, speak­ing of Jensen Huang, uh, there’s been a lot of talk that he might be going back, but I see the New York Times today is say­ing that, uh, uh, anony­mous mem­bers who rep­re­sent the board are say­ing, “No, he’s not com­ing back. That is not under dis­cus­sion.” And I had some peo­ple me if Nvidia is now a good, uh, val­ue buy, see­ing as the price has dropped. So I ran some num­bers on it over the week­end, and the PROPCAF was 38 times.

Tony Kynas­ton: Okay.

Cameron: And I was like.

Tony Kynas­ton: yeah.

Cameron: You were like, “What?”

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, it’s get­ting back into the realms of real­i­ty then, isn’t it? I expect­ed you to say the PROPCAF was like a thou­sand times or neg­a­tive or some­thing like that. Neg­a­tive infin­i­ty. Yeah

Cameron: Oh, I remem­ber when we did the PE analy­sis of the Mag Sev­en six months ago, and most of them had rea­son­able PEs com­pared to the dot­com boom,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: Tes­la. But, um, I still said, “Look, no, 38 times? I’m not. I don’t know what’s gonna hap­pen to Nvidia tomor­row, let alone 38 years from now.” it’s all of this fore­cast­ing.

Uh,

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: gam­bling. You know, peo­ple

Tony Kynas­ton: Absolute­ly

Cameron: They own 90% of the AI chip mar­ket w- today, which is great. I mean, great busi­ness. Hats off to Jensen Huang and the Nvidia team for what they’ve done. But do I think they’re going to main­tain that dom­i­nance for­ev­er? No. How long do I think it’s gonna last for? [00:06:00] Don’t know. I

Tony Kynas­ton: It’s got­ta, well, it’s, it’s,

Cameron: as good as

Tony Kynas­ton: it’s got­ta last for 38 years to get your mon­ey back.

Cameron: 38 years, right? I mean, that’s based on today’s

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. There’ll be growth. Yeah.

Cameron: quadru­ple their rev­enue

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm

Cameron: for the next four years, that comes down. But the share price prob­a­bly goes up along­side of it, so maybe it does­n’t. I don’t know. Um, cou­ple of things. Um, BRI went up 41% yes­ter­day, Tony,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yee­haw

Cameron: I did a Pulled Pork on them while you were away in May.

Tony Kynas­ton: so I can’t claim it? Okay. You can claim it. Yeah. Good.

Cameron: it. Yeah. They, they are

Tony Kynas­ton: Shoul­ders of Giants Camp

Cameron: That’s right. They are under an acqui­si­tion offer, uh, which

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: every­one accepts. Um, it, the price had been down since I added it, though. So when I looked at it yes­ter­day, I think I was up 15%, not the full 41%. So, [00:07:00] um, there you go. But good luck to any­one who got in on that, and it’s still not a bad lit­tle run. I don’t

Tony Kynas­ton: That’s good.

Cameron: I haven’t looked

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. So that’s the tim­ber com­pa­ny, isn’t it? BRI?

Cameron: Yeah, it was an inter­est­ing, um, Pulled Pork actu­al­ly to drill down into all of the dif­fer­ent milling things

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: I think they’ve been around like 100 years or some­thing like that from mem­o­ry, and all, uh, very inter­est­ing. Looks like they’re not– They’ve had no, no share price move­ment today.

Looks like every­one’s tapped out Yeah, right. Cur­rent­ly at $1.58. It looks like it’s, uh, stalled there. But yeah, it had come down quite a since May. Uh, May it was trad­ing at around $1.33. It had come down to a $1.02 in Octo­ber, [00:08:00] and then is back up. So there you go. Uh, what else? We had some ques­tions.

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

Cameron: sent through some good ques­tions I’ll throw through to you.

We do actu­al­ly have a guest com­ing on in 15 min­utes, folks. Um, so we’re gonna try and jump into these a lit­tle bit quick­ly, and then we might need to pause. ques­tion from Doug, “How much weighting/thought/value are we still plac­ing on the qual­i­ty score? orig­i­nal episodes when the pod­cast start­ed the rule, if I recall cor­rect­ly, was only to buy if the qual­i­ty score was over 75%.

That seems to have stopped. Did any­one do back test­ing on it or if it had lost rel­e­vance as a stand­alone gate to buy?” What’s your rec­ol­lec­tion of the qual­i­ty score? Because mine’s dif­fer­ent

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, mine’s dif­fer­ent too. I think we said it was a nice to have. It was, um, some­thing we looked for, but we did com­pro­mise on that. It was­n’t a hard, a hard gate at 75%. [00:09:00] And, and my mem­o­ry of it is pre-QAV, um, I start­ed off hav­ing a hard gate of 75%, but I was find­ing that the buy list was too small, and some­times it would­n’t even have stocks on it at 75%, so I loos­ened that.

And, but I also found too that, um, by using the PROPCAF and the qual­i­ty score togeth­er, uh, to get the final QAV score, if some­thing would had low­er qual­i­ty but it was cheap­er, cheap­er to buy, the, the results or the per­for­mance was, was sim­i­lar to some­thing that was more expen­sive, so, but had bet­ter qual­i­ty.

So, um, I, I’ve actu­al­ly not used it as a hard gate for prob­a­bly 10 years

Cameron: Yeah. Um, what it says in the Bible, which I think, uh, I don’t think I’ve updat­ed this sec­tion of the Bible, um, since I first wrote it five years, [00:10:00] six years ago, when­ev­er it was, which is

Tony Kynas­ton: Do we need a c- do we need to put a coun­cil togeth­er to amend the Bible? Coun­cil of Nicaea?

Cameron: coun­cil? Yeah.

Tony Kynas­ton: Coun­cil.

Cameron: No, uh, I’m the Pope

Tony Kynas­ton: Just, uh, you’re the

Cameron: I just

Tony Kynas­ton: pope.

Cameron: yeah. Papal infal­li­bil­i­ty, Tony.

Tony Kynas­ton: Right.

Cameron: Um, they say, “A good score is high­er than 75%, how­ev­er, we will take low­er if the com­bined QAV score is equal to or above 0.10.” I think, I, I mean, my vague rec­ol­lec­tion is, um, think­ing it was a hard cut­off at 75 when we start­ed, but the, very ear­ly on you said to me, because we had a score that was low­er than, you said, “No, as long as the final QAV

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: we’ll still do it. It’s a nice to have.” That’s the way I’ve always treat­ed it in mem­o­ry any­way. Could be wrong on that, Doug. Maybe in the very, very ear­ly days. I know Doug’s been around a long time. it was for a lit­tle while, but it cer­tain­ly has­n’t been for the vast major­i­ty of the time we’ve been doing the show. Sec­ond [00:11:00] ques­tion, “Has Tony or any­one used adjust­ed price graphs to include total return for three PTLs? I’ve been start­ing to look at a way to rank ETFs and this issue came up. I know we score div­i­dend in the sys­tem, but that does­n’t direct­ly impact the over­all trend and buy or sell sig­nals. To me, com­par­ing over­all total return is the only fair com­par­i­son.

But I can also see that if you’re only just buy­ing into a stock, you don’t care about pre­vi­ous pay­outs if you haven’t had them, or maybe you should because they’re indica­tive of past per­for­mance.”

Tony Kynas­ton: So I’m not sure I under­stood that ques­tion. So we’re, we’re talk­ing about the stock price graph for three PTLs, and I think Doug’s say­ing we need to fig­ure div­i­dends into that graph, but I’m not sure how you would do that because it’s a share price graph. Um

Cameron: you would need to f- you know, write code [00:12:00] to

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, break it down some­how

Cameron: in some­how. I’m not sure how you do it either

Tony Kynas­ton: No. Um, div­i­dends are cer­tain­ly impor­tant, and we put them into the check­list for scor­ing, but I don’t. And I, I won­dered whether the div­i­dend yield was already baked into the stock price any­way, that peo­ple take it into account when they’re pric­ing the stock. So,

Cameron: Yeah, I think that makes sense.

Tony Kynas­ton: yes. So, maybe Doug can just give us some more infor­ma­tion, but I, I don’t see how you can blend those two togeth­er on a share price graph

Cameron: On the 3PTL and back­test­ing, though, I have start­ed the project that we’ve been talk­ing about. Um, I’m build­ing a mod­el for back­test­ing 3PTL stuff, um, look­ing at ques­tion for peo­ple who don’t know, I don’t know how much we’ve talked about it, but the ques­tion is whether or not we should just be. Oh, I, I talked about it in the newslet­ter this

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: actu­al­ly.

Yeah. Whether should we, we should just be tak­ing the two high­est and the two low­est and ignor­ing all of the fudg­ing that we’ve done. we fudge too far, [00:13:00] A Fudge Too Far, that was a great David Lean movie, I think, was­n’t it? Um, or if, you know, the fudg­ing is actu­al­ly improv­ing the return. So I’ve been try­ing to work out, it’s a ques­tion for you, w- I can prob­a­bly do offline, but, know, it, think­ing it through, the first stage of the back­test­ing will be var­i­ous ver­sions of the 3PTL mod­el­ing.

So what I’ve got is the cur­rent ver­sion of my log­ic, the, um, base lev­el ver­sion of the log­ic, just the two high­est and the two low­est,

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

Cameron: and then adding one of the addi­tion­al rules in at a time, dif­fer­ent vari­a­tions with, say, the, the flat line rule or the lat­est peak and the lat­est trough instead of the low­est

Tony Kynas­ton: Yep

Cameron: sec­ond trough for the sec­ond line. And then it’s [00:14:00] a ques­tion of using m- m- mod­el one, when does it get us in, when does it get us out, and what hap­pens to the share price after it gets us in and gets us out? And I’m look­ing at peri­ods, so I’m look­ing at, I think, 20 days, 60 days and 90 days or 30, 60, 90 or some­thing like that. Um, and I might need longer time­frames because the q- I guess the ques­tion I have, I wan­na check if this is the ques­tion you have is, which mod­el gets us in at the right time, the opti­mal time, and which mod­el gets us out at the opti­mal time? If the mod­el gets you in and then the share price goes to. It gets you in too ear­ly and the

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

Cameron: has­n’t sta­bi­lized and it goes down a week or a month lat­er, um, and then goes back up, it got us in too ear­ly. Uh, if it gets us out too ear­ly and the share price can- turns around and keeps going up, then that’s sub­op­ti­mal. it’s just a ques­tion of what the [00:15:00] time­frames for check­ing back are, you

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: long a win­dow do we want to take into account?

Tony Kynas­ton: Well, the way I, I would do it is I’m look­ing for, with your dif­fer­ent mod­el vari­a­tions, what the per­for­mance is for a set of stocks, QAV stocks. And I’d do it over a long peri­od of time because, you know, like all these edge cas­es hap­pen because of things like com­ing out of COVID or going into COVID or, um, some­thing else has hap­pened.

The Ukraine war start­ed or inter­est rates have risen. So you’re prob­a­bly on a five-year peri­od and then just.

Cameron: five years, yeah

Tony Kynas­ton: you know, a set of– maybe go back five years and look at what was on the buy list five years ago and, um, yeah, see how they per­form under dif­fer­ent mod­els.

Cameron: Okay. And just look at the whole five-year peri­od.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: Okay. Um, last­ly, Doug says he’s been exper­i­ment­ing a lot with AI to build and speed up his check­list, and he wants a Zoom [00:16:00] call. Um, he says Cam or Tony. I’m assum­ing it’s prob­a­bly a Cam job.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, that’d be good. Thank you.

Cameron: Yeah. yeah, and I said, I said Doug can email us any­time.

Love to, love to look

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh.

Cameron: AI work on

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh

Cameron: I got a lot to learn. Uh, we can share ideas. So yeah, good. Thank you for those ques­tions, Doug. Uh, well, how long have we got? Oh, eight min­utes. Um, Scott sent me an arti­cle,

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: the Aus­tralian Investor, that was in Morn­ingstar. Um, this came out on the 22nd of Octo­ber by Shani Jaya­mani. Um, exec­u­tive sum­ma­ry: the 2026 State of the Aus­tralian Investor report mar­ries qual­i­ta­tive sur­vey data from the large­ly self-direct and engaged retail investors with­in the Morn­ingstar com­mu­ni­ty with quan­ti­ta­tive port­fo­lio per­for­mance and trans­ac­tion data from an over­lap­ping and expand­ed group of retail investors using Share­sight for port­fo­lio track­ing and man­age­ment. The report key [00:17:00] find­ings, investors are cau­tious but remain prag­mat­ic and con­tin­ue to take advan­tage of per­ceived oppor­tu­ni­ties

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, that’s good sum­ma­ry.

Cameron: Yeah. Wow.

Tony Kynas­ton: La-last year they, they were wild and deeply opti­mistic and buy­ing Bit­coin, but this year they’re prag­mat­ic.

Cameron: By the way, I had a good laugh. I looked at Bit­coin yes­ter­day ’cause, uh, an old friend of mine was argu­ing about my, uh, analy­sis of Nvidia, I remem­ber him pump­ing, um, uh, Bit­coin for the last five years. Do you know the, the cur­rent Bit­coin price is the same price it was at five years

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, real­ly? Wow.

Cameron: maybe 5% up,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yep

Cameron: it’s, it’s come all the way back to its price from five years ago. But lim­it­ed sup­ply, Tony. It’s gonna go up for­ev­er. Lim­it­ed sup­ply. You

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Well,

Cameron: don- look, you don’t get it, Tony.

Tony Kynas­ton: I don’t get it. I know.

Cameron: a

Tony Kynas­ton: I’ve been say­ing I don’t get it for the last 10.

Cameron: about lim­it­ed [00:18:00] sup­ply? It’s, it’s, it’s a new kind of mon­ey, Tony. New c- it’s

Tony Kynas­ton: Well,

Cameron: Tony.

Tony Kynas­ton: well, good cus­tomer ser­vice is in lim­it­ed sup­ply as well, but that’s not worth well, it should be worth a lot, but

Cameron: is

Tony Kynas­ton: it’s not. Yeah. It’s

Cameron: my Wi-Fi provider, I’ve had some Wi-Fi issues and I’ve been con­tact­ing them. They call me to check up the next

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh, wow

Cameron: ” Hey, just check­ing up to see how it’s going with those fix­es we did yes­ter­day. Let me know. Get back to me.” I’m like, “Holy shit.” And then they sent me a cus­tomer sur­vey and I was like, “You guys are seri­ous­ly the gold stan­dard,” you

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, every­one sends me a cus­tomer sur­vey. Tel­stra came in and put my NBN in and sent me a cus­tomer sur­vey, and then when I just ignored it, they sent me anoth­er one. Then they rang me, and I’m

Cameron: I’m not say­ing that

Tony Kynas­ton: like

Cameron: they, they, they get gold stan­dard because they call me to check

Tony Kynas­ton: okay.

Cameron: it’s going a day lat­er.

Tony Kynas­ton: Uh-huh

Cameron: They reach out, “Hey, hey, how’s it going? How’s it going?” And they’re on it. They’re like all over it, dif­fer­ent peo­ple, they know the notes. You call them up, they go, “Yep, I’ve got, I’ve got the notes from Jacob here,” [00:19:00] uh, blah, blah.

They’re fan­tas­tic. I’m like, why can’t every­body

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: that lev­el? But you don’t get it, Tony. Decou­pled, Tony. Decou­pled, Tony. Lim­it­ed sup­ply,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: It’s gonna go to a mil­lion dol­lars. Go to the moon, Tony

Tony Kynas­ton: Well, aren’t they gonna halve it? That’s when you buy it, when they’re gonna– about to halve it or some­thing. Yeah. Num­ber of Bit­coins in cir­cu­la­tion halve.

Cameron: Hold on. If you thought it was going to a

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: ’cause it had lim­it­ed sup­ply,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: it at 100,000? That makes no sense

Tony Kynas­ton: Did­n’t we get giv­en $500,000 Zim­bab­we notes or some­thing from Thorsten to say, you know, “This is what Bit­coin is gonna be worth one day”?

Cameron: Yeah, yeah. I’ve

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: some­where. Yeah. Torsten, he emailed me, Dad. I think he wants to give us some mon­ey, you some mon­ey

Tony Kynas­ton: He wants to give us some mon­ey.

Cameron: Wants to give you some mon­ey, yeah, for the film.

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, excel­lent.

Cameron: Uh, any­hoo, [00:20:00] um, what else?

Tony Kynas­ton: Shh. Well, shh, it’s a tax write-off. Don’t, we don’t wan­na,

Cameron: find­ings.

Tony Kynas­ton: pol­lute it with the actu­al income. Yeah. Hmm

Cameron: shift in retail port­fo­lios con­tin­ues with exchange trad­ed funds becom­ing the core build­ing blocks of investor port­fo­lios while indi­vid­ual shares are tran­si­tion­ing to satel­lite hold­ings. Satel­lite of love.

Bum, bum, bum. Satel­lite of love.

Tony Kynas­ton: That’s a high, that’s a high reg­is­ter.

Cameron: of, uh, the film, remem­ber old David, my old friend that was in the, uh, reel of the film singing some old song about Jesus? I had to cut him in ’cause I had Jesus as a friend of mine, and they did­n’t like that, so I had to replace it with my old friend David.

They com­plained. I called him the oth­er day. He’s 101.

Tony Kynas­ton: Wow.

Cameron: in Octo­ber. Called him

Tony Kynas­ton: Good on him.

Cameron: lunch with him in a cou­ple of weeks. Sharp

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh,

Cameron: Yeah

Tony Kynas­ton: of weeks, you bet­ter bring that for­ward if he’s 101.

Cameron: Well, [00:21:00] actu­al­ly, I sent him an email on his birth­day and he did­n’t reply. It was on

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh

Cameron: 31st. Then I called him a week lat­er, could­n’t get through, did­n’t answer.

Called him a few days lat­er, still no answer. So I called recep­tion at the vil­lage where he lives in. I was like, “Oh, David.” They go, “Yeah, yeah, he’s still around. I’ll get him to give you a call.” He called me up 10 min­utes lat­er, and he was

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: Any­way.

Tony Kynas­ton: your ear­phones down.

Cameron: ETFs, are you sur­prised that every­one’s going into ETFs, Tony?

Tony Kynas­ton: I was– we were actu­al­ly talk­ing about this yes­ter­day when I was in Syd­ney with the, with some of the share­hold­ers in Climb,

Cameron: Myer

Tony Kynas­ton: and it’s cer­tain­ly the big thing. That’s, that was my take­away from what you sent me as well, that, that, this doc­u­ment. My two take­aways were peo­ple are buy­ing the dips, so as soon as the share mar­ket turns down for what­ev­er rea­son, they’re, they’re buy­ing it.

Um, which is kind of a ver­sion of the Fed put that they expect that if, if the share mar­ket drops, the inter­est rates will be cut to put things back into bal­ance. And the oth­er, the oth­er take­away was that, [00:22:00] um, peo­ple are now invest­ing heav­i­ly into ETFs, which kind of makes sense too, ’cause I mean, I’ve preached it for­ev­er as well, that index funds at low fees make a lot more s‑sense than, um, active man­age­ment if you, you know, unless you find a, find a good one.

Um, ’cause there’s fees involved. How­ev­er, there is. One of the peo­ple I was speak- talk­ing to yes­ter­day said that there are now more ETFs in Amer­i­ca than there are stocks. So, you know, it’s, it’s,

Cameron: Peo­ple

Tony Kynas­ton: it’s get­ting out of con­trol, and there’s o‑obviously ETFs that are low-cost index type ETFs, your Van­guards, for exam­ple.

But there’s a pro­lif­er­a­tion of ones now which do have high fees, which are gonna strug­gle in any sort of down­turn. So, you know, there’s a lot of syn­thet­ic ETFs, so they actu­al­ly don’t hold the com­mod­i­ty or the stock under­neath that they’re track­ing. So if the mar­ket drops quick­ly, you know, and they’ve got a bas­ket of puts [00:23:00] and calls and war­rants on these things, they may not be able to redeem you out if you try and sell, ’cause they can’t sell the under­ly­ing asset to, to get out.

Um, so there are lots of risks now, I think, in ETFs which weren’t there five years ago, ten years ago, so that’s. You’ve got to be care­ful about that, I think. But if you,

Cameron: a

Tony Kynas­ton: but if you are just buy­ing a vanil­la index fund with low fees, I think you’re okay

Cameron: I’ve got a guest com­ing on in a few weeks who I saw post on the ASX sub­red­dit that he’s a val­ue investor, and over the last 10 years his CAGR is 20%.

Tony Kynas­ton: Okay,

Cameron: And I said, I said, “Come on.” Um, but, uh, he– I know he’s got some ETFs in his port­fo­lio, so we can talk to him about that.

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh.

Cameron: And here is

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, hel­lo

jk: Hel­lo

Cameron: Live in front of your naked, steam­ing eyes, James Kir­by, wel­come to QAV

jk: Cameron. Hel­lo, Tony

Tony Kynas­ton: Hel­lo, James

Cameron: [00:24:00] How are you, James?

jk: Very good. Thank you very much.

Cameron: Oh, the plea­sure is all ours. Yes.

Tony Kynas­ton: yeah

jk: good,

Cameron: Very clear­ly.

jk: Uh, uh, James Kir­by from The Aus­tralian’s Mon­ey Puz­zle pod­cast.

Cameron: Oh, you’re intro­duc­ing your­self. Okay.

jk: if

Cameron: Wow. That’s, that’s very accom­mo­dat­ing of you.

jk: make it easy.

Cameron: Well, I’ve. Tony’s got some, uh, things he wants to talk to you about. Before we get into that, though, I’ve got a cou­ple of quick ones.

jk: Yes

Cameron: Um, you wrote a book, My Moth­er’s Dia­monds

jk: Gee, you’ve done a bit of home­work. That’s good. I’m

Cameron: That’s, that’s my job. And, and I, I was par­tic­u­lar­ly tak­en by that.

It’s, um, so it’s about Holo­caust sur­vivors and peo­ple try­ing to recov­er their assets. There was a sto­ry this week about a Van Gogh. Did you see that in the news?

jk: No, but the art repa­tri­a­tion is a sto­ry that nev­er ends. Yeah.

Cameron: Right. this is a, Sothe­by’s has, uh, got a Van Gogh called some­thing trees, Blos­som­ing [00:25:00] Chest­nut Trees. Um, it’s up for sale, val­ued at $180 mil­lion, and it was sold by a Jew­ish art col­lec­tor in June of 1936, and they’re claim­ing it was sold under duress, um, they want, know, ret­ri­bu­tion or

jk: goes. Yeah. I, I, I found this, this. There was a sto­ry be- in Dunedin, New Zealand of all places in the book, where some­one had just spot­ted some­thing and said, “Hang on a sec­ond,” you know.

Cameron: Hmm

jk: we had that, had that on the fam­i­ly wall, or we had that over the fire­place back in wher­ev­er. So that was an amaz­ing, was an amaz­ing sequence of events.

I start­ed, I wrote an arti­cle for The Aus­tralian, which, which was based on an advert I saw in a news­pa­per, that became a fea­ture and a series of fea­tures, which became a book, which became a doc­u­men­tary on SBS. Just a [00:26:00] sto­ry that went on for­ev­er. Uh, and it’s still going, real­ly.

Cameron: Yeah, still going. That’s fas­ci­nat­ing. Well, I want­ed to get your thoughts on that, and we’ve done that. You, uh, stopped using Twit­ter in ear­ly 2024. Why? See, the big ques­tions I’ve got here, the impor­tant ques­tions. Yeah.

jk: good. You’ve real­ly done your research. You know, I’ve always been skep­ti­cal about, uh, work­ing for free. Any­way, so I was quite hap­py to jump off Twit­ter along with every­body else when they got a bit tired of Elon Musk’s more, uh, unsa­vory, opin­ions and, his approach to things.

Uh, peo­ple were very dis­ap­point­ed with him, I think, in many ways. And, but more gen­er­al­ly, uh, I have always liked to be paid for the work I do, and, uh, push­ing– work­ing on social media, you don’t real­ly have a straight line to, uh, [00:27:00] you know, rewards. It’s, uh, in our world, my world, pro­fes­sion­al media, it’s become very dif­fi­cult to have a career where you are paid prop­er­ly for the work you do that you could have a full-time career.

And it, it’s been real­ly tough, and I’ve watched a lot of peo­ple, um, jump off, if you like, into oth­er areas to be paid bet­ter, but they’re not nec­es­sar­i­ly hap­pi­er, or they did­n’t nec­es­sar­i­ly want to do it. it’s quite a, it’s a skill in itself, career nav­i­ga­tion in, uh, in our game.

Cameron: Okay, inter­est­ing.

Tony Kynas­ton: So, so you got into pod­cast­ing?

Cameron: Yeah, pod­cast­ing, where all the big mon­ey is

jk: Well, pod­cast­ing has, you know, I think it’s got a future, and it’s, it’s– That’s for us to– In media, that can, that can be some­thing that’s often miss­ing. But also what I love about pod­cast­ing that you will get [00:28:00] some­body, and you will meet them, and then we’ll talk about what­ev­er sub­ject it might be, does­n’t mat­ter. they will talk to you, and you– a‑and they will be very inter­est­ing. And you s- might say, “Could you write an arti­cle about that?” They say, “Oh, yes, we’ll write an arti­cle. Sure.” They send it in, and you look at this. You look at what’s sent in, and you say, “Oh, this is so removed from what I had in mind.” bring that same per­son onto a pod­cast and lit­er­al­ly say to them, “Tell the lis­ten­ers what you’ve been telling me,” and it flows. So I think there’s that ter­rif­ic. That’s a ter­rif­ic aspect of pod­cast­ing in our area of finan­cial and eco­nom­ics, where that abil­i­ty to sort of artic­u­late com­plex ideas in an easy way. It’s, it’s a– it’s actu­al­ly– it’s a skill that’s some­times eas­i­er in the spo­ken word in pod­cast than it is, you know, to write

Cameron: Yeah.

jk: for most peo­ple,

Cameron: Yeah. I– Spot on. I

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, no, like great. [00:29:00] Yeah

Cameron: And do– And let’s do it before AI takes it all over, and I think that leads Tony into his first ques­tion for you

Tony Kynas­ton: Well, yeah, I mean, I– Cam and I were talk­ing about the lev­el of cus­tomer ser­vice in Aus­tralia, and I’ve had a lot of time sit­ting at air­ports recent­ly to lis­ten to The Mon­ey Puz­zle and, um, which is a good pod­cast, espe­cial­ly if as you unpack, I guess, the, the tips and tricks of nav­i­gat­ing the finan­cial land­scape at the moment.

And my first ques­tion is: Will, will AI replace finan­cial plan­ners? What, what are your thoughts on how AI’s go- get­ting into that a‑advice sort of, uh, you know, geog­ra­phy of the land­scape?

jk: I think they will adv- I think they will replace the low-hang­ing fruit in finan­cial advice. There’s a lot of rou­tine advice often giv­en by peo­ple who are bare­ly a few steps [00:30:00] ahead of the per­son across the table or the client, and I think that sort of lev­el of finan­cial advice will just dis­ap­pear. And I– and it’s not nec­es­sar­i­ly the wealth­i­er or, or, or less wealth­i­er peo­ple.

I think it’s got to do with how easy it is to offer that advice. And so I think that will be instant­ly replaced by AI, and finan­cial advi­sors at every lev­el will have to add val­ue, just like we all have to add val­ue in every­thing we do. So jour­nal­ism is the same. Um, the very obvi­ous stuff, the low-hang­ing fruit that would’ve been, you know, six, six secret hide­aways, uh, Greece that I haven’t been to.

Well, I just go onto AI and put that in, and I’ll get a pret­ty good list. So I don’t need to sub­scribe to some­thing to get that. I think finan­cial advice has some­thing very sim­i­lar. So you’ve got­ta add val­ue, and then you have to move up the chain. I think that would be the case, um, sub­stan­tial­ly. Yeah, I think [00:31:00] it’s a, it’s an area that is ripe. And the smartest advi­sors are already– They are, are, are– they are already h- or at least if they’re not hir­ing con­sul­tants, they are actu­al­ly hir­ing staff because you– the, the, the pro­duc­tiv­i­ty kick you could get in finan­cial advice from AI is pow­er­ful

Tony Kynas­ton: It is, yeah. And, um, there’s a, there’s a big under­served gen­er­al mar­ket, I think, at the moment for finan­cial advice, and maybe a v- finan­cial advice is too nar­row a term. But, uh, now that it costs sort of $3,000 to $5,000 for your first inter­view with a finan­cial plan­ner, a lot of peo­ple aren’t get­ting in the door for finan­cial advice, and I s- I see AI as a big, a big tool to help get them just start­ed on the basics of their finan­cial life

jk: I think so. Except, of course, you can’t, uh, com­plain if they’re wrong,

Tony Kynas­ton: You can com­plain.

jk: to

Tony Kynas­ton: You can [00:32:00] com­plain, you just can’t get rec­om­pense. Yeah.

jk: Yeah,

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

jk: we’ve got­ta put that on the table, um, that there is that as- I think the, the ide­al way obvi­ous­ly to use it is to stress test your ideas with the finan­cial advice, so, uh, with a finan­cial advi­sor.

So you, that, that you, that you go as far as you can on the, on the, on the com­mon denom­i­na­tor work. How much should I have in super? I pay off my mort­gage? These are like ele­men­tary ques­tions and, and they are not very com­plex, so that when you go to an advi­sor, the advi­sor can say some­thing real­ly spe­cif­ic that you would­n’t have found out on AI, what­ev­er that might be, that you can add or sub­tract make it bet­ter for you and your sit­u­a­tion.

But gener­ic advice, I think the AI will, will just wipe the floor with, with peo­ple who are giv­ing gener­ic advice and charg­ing three thou­sand

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

jk: [00:33:00] dol­lars a pop for it. That’s, that’s a busi­ness that’s over. So, so by the way, so is, uh, some of the oth­er busi­ness­es, I think the obvi­ous ones. You know, I think some of the busi­ness­es where peo­ple were mak­ing pret­ty good, uh, com­pen­sa­tion for, you know, mort­gage broking, I would real­ly wor­ry about.

Um, com­par­i­son ser­vices, that sort of thing. I think it’s, it’s, it’s ripe for the tak­ing, I imag­ine

Tony Kynas­ton: No, I agree. Uh, that, uh, real estate agents, I think, is a big one. We recent­ly bought a house, and AI gave us all the infor­ma­tion on val­u­a­tions for the prop­er­ty, so we, we went along pret­ty well armed for nego­ti­at­ing the, the pur­chase. And, um, yeah, you, you sort of. The, the tricks that real estate agents could use to try and get the price up are fair­ly lim­it­ed now, I think.

jk: Though you know the ques­tions to ask, Tony.

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm. Yeah, I guess so.

jk: knows the ques­tions to ask. You need to know the ques­tions

Tony Kynas­ton: The prompts. Yeah

jk: the prompts. Yes,

Tony Kynas­ton: Y- you just made a com­ment and said that the, the [00:34:00] basics are pret­ty well known about things like whether you pay down your mort­gage first. But I, I ques­tion that. I think that there are peo­ple still str- still quite strug­gle with, um, you know, I’m busy, I’m on the tools all day, and then, you know, I don’t have time to think about whether I’m pay­ing the mort­gage off or whether I’m invest­ing in a new prop­er­ty or whether I’m salary sac­ri­fic­ing more into super and, or hav­ing an off­set account.

So I think, I think that’s the kind of basics that, that a lot of peo­ple aren’t get­ting any thought or advice on that, that AI can prob­a­bly help with

jk: I sup­pose so. I was think­ing more of sort of home­spun when, you know, kind of home­spun folky type wis­dom that would come, you know, peo­ple would get from their par­ents or, or, um, you know, pay off your mort­gage as soon as you can, this sort of thing. There’s noth­ing wrong with those rules if you, if, if you’re lucky enough to be famil­iar with them. Uh, you know, spend less than you earn. if you could actu­al­ly hang on to three or four of those under­pin­ning rules, go a long way

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. [00:35:00] It’s, it’s inter­est­ing one, isn’t it? What, I mean, there are a lot of peo­ple that I’ve encoun­tered through doing our pod­cast or just gen­er­al­ly who don’t get exposed to those kinds of rules and, and, uh, e- ei- either, either ever or late in life. So there’s a real gap in terms of finan­cial lit­er­a­cy. I don’t know if it’s the school sys­tem or the par­ents don’t pass it down, or the kids are just nat­u­ral­ly cyn­i­cal or what, but yeah, the, I, I’m see­ing big gaps in peo­ple’s knowl­edge.

jk: Big gaps. A‑and, and that area of finan­cial lit­er­a­cy I’m, I’m very inter­est­ed in, and we did a, we had a, uh, con­ven­tion in Syd­ney, uh, just a few days ago, and, uh, it was a lit­er­a­cy Xtra, the Finan­cial Lit­er­a­cy, um, Foun­da­tion. And one of the things that, uh, came up was that younger have so lit­tle under­stand­ing.

They have dif­fer­ent per­cep­tions. I’m think­ing of some­thing like a bank. I mean, you, you or [00:36:00] I. What’s a bank? A bank is a big build­ing. it’s got wal­nut, you know, cor­ri­dor, lined cor­ri­dors and steps, and it has this sense of it’s fun­da­men­tal­ly strong, and you, you go into the bank, and your mon­ey’s in that bank, and they have huge build­ings, and they’re very, very con­vinc­ing. But a dig­i­tal native, if you like, just sees a brand name, and that brand name isn’t very dif­fer­ent from anoth­er brand name like Grand Theft Auto or some­thing. They’re just names on a screen, so they have no sense of secu­ri­ty from a bank, and they have no sense of cash because they nev­er use cash. So you’re talk­ing about this entire­ly dif­fer­ent gen­er­a­tion who will have very dif­fer­ent demands, and in some ways they’ll be very smart. Uh, but in oth­er ways, they will lack a, sort of a, um, a fun­da­men­tal under­stand­ing the rela­tion­ships [00:37:00] and that how a rela­tion­ship with a bank or what a bank is is dif­fer­ent than what some oth­er busi­ness might be

Tony Kynas­ton: And I think, I think, well, from my own expe­ri­ence, you know, when my daugh­ter got to an age where she was earn­ing a bit of mon­ey, like just from casu­al work, I said, “Righty‑o, you can’t just leave that at home in a jar. You’ve got­ta take it into a bank and earn some inter­est on it.” And we went into the bank, and we opened an account, and when she got her first state­ment, she said, “Dad, what does.001% inter­est add up to?”

So, so the, you know, the whole bank­ing rela­tion­ship has changed any­way, I think, and, and, you know, she got quite cyn­i­cal about

jk: it

Tony Kynas­ton: involved

jk: it’s a, it’s a, it’s a, it’s a fas­ci­nat­ing area, and, uh, it’s an area I would be con­cerned about, and I, I, I do try to talk to that age group because they do lis­ten to pod­casts, and they have this issue, they have this blurred line between gam­ing [00:38:00] and invest­ing.

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

jk: There’s anoth­er area of real con­cern in finan­cial lit­er­a­cy at the moment where, again, a, a, a, a dig­i­tal native or some­one who, whose life so far was large­ly their, the econ­o­my was online to them. they have per­haps bought their first stock and on a site where it cel­e­brates this, and it’s like you’ve won a prize because you’ve bought some­thing. But you haven’t won a prize yet. You’ve just bought. you, you may nev­er win the prize. Uh, so

Tony Kynas­ton: Cor­rect.

jk: dan­ger­ous, uh, you know, habits form­ing for peo­ple, and I, I think that’s

Tony Kynas­ton: Mhm

jk: we’ve got­ta real­ly, uh, explain to peo­ple very care­ful­ly what it real­ly means to invest or what it real­ly means to engage your mon­ey and who, who’s on the oth­er side of the trans­ac­tion.

What’s the rela­tion­ship? You know, what, is it fair? Is it a fair [00:39:00] rela­tion­ship between you and who you’re deal­ing with? So peo­ple get lost in this mire. They come out and they say, uh, like First Guardian, if you read the sto­ries, the one com­mon theme was peo­ple said, “I did­n’t think you could, uh, lose my super,”

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh

jk: was super.

Because, because there was a gov­ern­ment con­trol man­dat­ed that I had to save by law, thought that there was some sort of rec­i­p­ro­cal, uh, deal that you were pro­tect­ed in some fash­ion, that it was guar­an­teed. It’s not guar­an­teed. peo­ple don’t know that. You think they do, but they don’t. They don’t have, uh. M‑many, many peo­ple have no idea the terms in which we do our finan­cial rela­tion­ships, includ­ing super.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. And they don’t have the lit­er­a­cy or the expe­ri­ence that if a boil­er room rings you up and say, “Hey, com­pare what you’re get­ting now for your super with what we can get you.” You don’t ask the right ques­tions or you just, you know, [00:40:00] you’re, you’re, you’re worn down by the sales pitch, I guess. And, you know, there are steps you can take to say, “Hey, I’ll call you back and I’m gonna check this out first with my finan­cial plan­ner,” or what­ev­er.

They’re just not being tak­en.

jk: They’re not being tak­en, absolute­ly. Yeah

Cameron: So I, so my ques­tion to both of you i- is why is that basic lev­el of finan­cial lit­er­a­cy not there, in your opin­ion? Where are we fail­ing as a soci­ety?

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, from my, from my. Well,

jk: the, well,

Tony Kynas­ton: go ahead, James. Yeah.

jk: in the schools. It,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, I agree

jk: in the schools. uh, and I think the. You see, the schools will come back and say, “We do it in com­merce. We

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh.

jk: it in accoun­tan­cy.” Yeah, but the kids who are in accoun­tan­cy and com­merce are prob­a­bly bet­ter, they’re going to do bet­ter any­way. Uh, uh, so what I’d be con­cerned about is the kids that are look­ing out the win­dow when they’re doing com­merce and accoun­tan­cy,

Tony Kynas­ton: Well, it was in, it [00:41:00] was in busi­ness.

jk: in their

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Sor­ry to cut across you there, James.

jk: Yes,

Tony Kynas­ton: It was, it was called busi­ness prin­ci­ples when I went to school, so it may have changed. But, um, it was basi­cal­ly the, the choic­es were that you could do physics and chem­istry or you could do busi­ness prin­ci­ples. So like there was this stream­ing off of peo­ple who went into it.

A- and I have a friend who’s a school prin­ci­pal, he’s retired now, but I put it to him, you know, it should­n’t just be the com­merce kids who are learn­ing about finan­cial lit­er­a­cy, it should be all the, all the stu­dents. And he said, “Tony, you would­n’t believe how many peo­ple approach me every day and say all kids should learn X,” what­ev­er it is.

And he said, “We just can’t do that. We’ve got to

Cameron: you,

Tony Kynas­ton: refine it.”

Cameron: Tony

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, sor­ry. Okay. Yeah. So I’ll just repeat that.

Cameron: inter­net in your new house is, uh, not

Tony Kynas­ton: don’t, don’t get me start­ed about cus­tomer ser­vice again. Um, no, the point was that my school prin­ci­pal friend said that they were approached so often to have [00:42:00] some­thing includ­ed in the cur­ricu­lum for all stu­dents, whether it was, you know, phys­i­cal edu­ca­tion, sex edu­ca­tion, finan­cial edu­ca­tion or what­ev­er.

There was just so many lob­by groups that, that they just could­n’t do it

jk: Yes. No, they can’t. But, uh, Youth For The Xtra just solves the prob­lem to a degree in that the, the school just com­mits to leav­ing the, the time in the timetable, and they do every­thing else. They lit­er­al­ly design the pro­gram. The teacher comes in, it’s, they vis­it the school, they leave, and, and that gives them, um, the chance to get at a cer­tain amount of, of pupils through­out the coun­try.

But the, the issue in every coun­try is as I say, the stu­dents you want to get are not the ones who are doing com­merce and accoun­tan­cy.

Tony Kynas­ton: Cor­rect

jk: the stu­dents that aren’t doing it. Yeah

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. It’s the ones going, yeah, yeah, going into small busi­ness or going into trades or any­thing real­ly. But, um, yeah, look, maybe that’s a gap in the [00:43:00] mar­ket that we should try and fill some­how with a Math­let­ic style soft­ware pro­gram or some­thing. Yeah

Cameron: James has men­tioned the Xtra Foun­da­tion, which I know you’re a direc­tor of. Is that right, James?

jk: a direc­tor of it, yeah

Cameron: I’d nev­er heard of it until I did my research on you. So can you tell us a lit­tle bit more about how it works and what it actu­al­ly does, the role it plays?

jk: Yeah. Well, what it does is, uh, it, it w- its orig­i­nal, uh, chair founder was, um, Paul Clitheroe, who I’m sure

Cameron: Myer? Sure

jk: was a great oper­a­tor of course, and has just recent­ly, uh, resigned as chair. And the new chair is Delia Rickard, who was a deputy at ACCC. And when she was at, uh, sor­ry, at ASIC and, uh, uh, uh, and at, her main, uh, role pr- in the past, the rea­son I’m men­tion­ing her is because she was instru­men­tal in cre­at­ing ASIC’s Mon­eySmart

Cameron: Right

jk: so which is a ter­rif­ic, um, free, [00:44:00] um, you know, toolk­it for peo­ple who want to check out basics of mon­ey. Um, so that’s some­thing that, uh, is a key part of Xtra. basi­cal­ly, Xtra has two wings. One is that it funds orga­ni­za­tions that are, in the, in the sphere of finan­cial lit­er­a­cy. There’s a, there’s about 20 dif­fer­ent orga­ni­za­tions around the coun­try. They range from quite par­tic­u­lar orga­ni­za­tions that might focus on, uh, women, uh, in sup­port or indige­nous sup­port. the Super Con­sumers Aus­tralia, for instance, is, is, is, um, grant­ed by Xtra. sep­a­rate­ly it has the schools func­tion, which is, um, about 5,000 chil­dren at any giv­en time around the coun­try, any giv­en day would be attend­ing a class that’s, um, run by Xtra, and it’s in every state. And the trained, [00:45:00] uh, teach­ers go into the class­room with a set pro­gram, depend­ing on the age group, and they tell them the basics of finan­cial lit­er­a­cy.

So that’s how it works. uh, it’s been, it’s been, um, it’s been real­ly good to have because we know from the OECD that Aus­trali­a’s finan­cial lit­er­a­cy scores, once we were among the best, you know, have fall­en. And in absolute terms, they, they, they are, they’ve descend­ed the lad­der, you know, dra­mat­i­cal­ly. So this is some­thing of a, of an effort to get that back on track.

Cameron: Is there a way that we can get our schools. Like, I’ve got son who’s 12, he’s about to start high school next year. Is there a way that we can get schools to get involved with Xtra? Should we just point them at it?

jk: Lit­er­al­ly point them at it. Yeah, E‑C-S-T-R‑A, and, uh, they will make every effort [00:46:00] to get, uh, into the school cur­ricu­lum, uh, as fast as they can. In every state, as I say, uh, rur­al and region­al, and I’ve been out to some of the class­es, you know, and they’re great. They’re real­ly good. A- and, and, uh, these were quite young. my last one that I went to, they were about, uh, 11. You know, but they were very engaged, uh, by the tutors at some­thing quite dif­fer­ent, and you think, “Well, one else is gonna tell them this, and maybe no one at home is going to tell them this.” And I think, uh, we might have a blink­ered view our­selves. If you’re in finance or finan­cial media, you’re nat­u­ral­ly enough, a lot of, if you have kids your­self, by a pure osmo­sis, you know, they’re going to pick up a lot.

But in fam­i­lies where there isn’t, there’s two things actu­al­ly that comes up in finan­cial lit­er­a­cy. One is just a com­plete, um, that, that a fam­i­ly might have no idea what­so­ev­er. com­mon­ly, it’s actu­al­ly, [00:47:00] uh, social­ly, uh, not unac­cept­able, but peo­ple find it dif­fi­cult to talk about mon­ey. Don’t know why. We don’t find it dif­fi­cult, any of us, any of us three, but, uh, peo­ple do.

I’m,

Tony Kynas­ton: Absolute­ly

jk: real­ly why I can’t, uh, it, I can’t fath­om that per­son­al­ly, but it’s, it’s an issue. Yeah

Tony Kynas­ton: We’ve talked about it before and, and I know that, you know, bar­be­cue con­ver­sa­tions will include things like, you know, what’s my house worth or what’s the prop­er­ty mar­ket doing? But

jk: Mm.

Tony Kynas­ton: realm of what my own per­son­al finan­cial sit­u­a­tion is and what prob­lems am I fac­ing. And the, the case for, that brought that home to me was my father, who,

jk: Mm.

Tony Kynas­ton: he was a bit of a man’s man and he went to a finan­cial plan­ner who was a blokey bloke and he ran out of mon­ey, you know, when he was in retire­ment.

So he resist­ed all attempts from me to get involved until he was des­per­ate and [00:48:00] need­ed help and then I could unpick it all, but he just would­n’t talk about it.

jk: was the same. My

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

jk: He had his own busi­ness with his broth­er, and he was extreme­ly re-reluc­tant to tell me the basics until he was quite old, and I mean in, into his eight­ies real­ly. Uh, and thank­ful­ly I got involved in time for the GFC, just in time.

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

jk: Uh, it’s a dif­fer­ent sys­tem over there, but the same issues apply. I had prob­a­bly an ele­ment of pride there too.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah,

jk: You know, I

Tony Kynas­ton: I think so

jk: or I built a prac­tice or I built a

Cameron: Hmm.

jk: or I, I had a very

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

jk: what­ev­er.

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

jk: but that noth­ing, tells us noth­ing about whether the per­son is finan­cial­ly astute. We know lots of lawyers and den­tists and neu­ro­sur­geons who mon­ey eas­i­ly,

Cameron: Угу.

jk: eas­i­ly led

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh.

jk: on finan­cial mat­ters.

Yeah.

Cameron: film togeth­er, and Bill Had­er has this incred­i­ble riff on it on some chat show. So I need to find that film and watch that film now. So, uh, yeah. That’s my After Hours.

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, that’s great. I’ll have to look up Klaus Kin­s­ki stuff.

Cameron: Yeah, do it. Do it. And watch Fitz­car­ral­do, if you haven’t seen it.

Tony Kynas­ton: I haven’t seen it in a long time.

Cameron: Oh, it’s so good. It’s so good. Alright, well, that’s it for this week.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yep.

Cameron: Thanks every­one for lis­ten­ing. We’ll see you next week.

Tony Kynas­ton: Bye.

—

Cameron: James, we’ve near­ly used up our time with you, so I’m going to skip to the end. Um, we do a thing at the end of our show every week where [00:49:00] we do what we call After Hours, where we talk about books, film, TV, music, the most inter­est­ing new thing you’ve learned recent­ly. What have you got to share with us on your way out?

What, what– Out­side of mon­ey and finance, what are you into at the moment that’s cool that we should know about?

jk: Well, you’ve prob­a­bly– I know you’ve done your home­work and you can see behind me some of my, my pets

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, your books.

Cameron: I see a book on Troy which is leap­ing out at me. I’m going, “Oh, his­to­ry nerd. Hey, my kind of guy.” Yeah, yeah.

jk: Fry books on,

Cameron: Ah, yes.

jk: Greece. Yes. But

Cameron: Hmm

jk: uh, my– And, and this is not a finan­cial inter­est real­ly. It would­n’t want to be.

And I think most peo­ple who h- who, who col­lect are sim­i­lar. If you col­lect art or wine or watch­es or what­ev­er, I mean,

Tony Kynas­ton: Bit­coin

jk: you hope it comes right. But I’m not as clin­i­cal a col­lec­tor as I am an investor. You know, as a. My SMSF, I’m quite ruth­less, it’s all exquis­ite­ly [00:50:00] bal­anced and et cetera. My rare book col­lec­tion is, is very ran­dom. Uh, and it– a lot of it depends on what sort of appears in front of me. I, I’m not o- I’m not obses­sive enough to be a good rare book col­lec­tor. If I. If you were obses­sive, you would take a line of inquiry, and you would just fol­low it hard. Colo­nial doc­u­ments or some­thing or oth­er. I, my, my inter­ests are, are, are very I like, uh, Mel­bourne’s 1956 Olympics. That’s a big one.

that.

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

jk: very inter­est­ing one. Um,

Cameron: Very niche

jk: yeah. No, that’s not, that’s not niche.

Cameron: Real­ly?

jk: of, in the world of rare books, that’s not niche.

Cameron: Right.

jk: too

Cameron: Oh, okay

jk: Yeah. But, uh, it does teach you quite a bit. It’s– Look, in the end, it’s not unlike any oth­er form of invest­ing in that there’s three, three things that mat­ter with the rare books.

Uh, it– which is, uh, scarci­ty, [00:51:00] price, and con­di­tion. They’re the three things you have to get right. If you get those three, then you real­ly are on some­thing very spe­cial. Um, so it’s a curi­ous world. I do go to rare book­shops. I go to rare book auc­tions. Every­where I trav­el, I go to the rare book­shops and see what they’ve got and pick up odd. all sorts of things. I love it. My, my per­son­al inter­est is what they call asso­ci­a­tion copies. That’s where there’s a sto­ry behind the book, right? So s- there’s a sto­ry attached to the book. I’ve one here. I’ll sh- I’ll get it for you.

Cameron: Please

jk: So th- this looks like a fair­ly sim­ple book, but this is a book called Tal­leyrand. a French.

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh.

jk: Okay, a

Cameron: Okay. You don’t,

jk: who

Cameron: you don’t know who you’re talk­ing to right now, James,

Tony Kynas­ton: It’s the Na- Napoleon pod­cast­er here. Yeah

jk: Okay. Well, so Tal­leyrand, as you– Okay, well, I don’t have to explain who he was to you, but he was the, the

Cameron: [00:52:00] “Shit in a silk–

Tony Kynas­ton: talk­ing

Cameron: stock­ing,” as Napoleon referred to

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

jk: Yes, yes. And Tal­leyrands are still with us to this day. They just wear dif­fer­ent clothes.

Cameron: Yeah

jk: so this is a biog­ra­phy of Tal­leyrand by Duff Coop­er. Duff Coop­er was famous, uh, British, uh, oper­a­tor diplo­mat, mar­ried to Diana Coop­er, who was a famous British beau­ty way back in the day, 1920s, ’30s. So I found this book, and, uh, it turned out that it was owned by an Aus­tralian called Ernest Scott, who was a big name a- again, back at this time, and it’s his per­son­al copy.

And at the back, was a let­ter, and the, and it was a let­ter he had writ­ten to Duff Coop­er,

Cameron: Oh, wow

jk: uh, to say that he want­ed to get the name of Cape of the Bay of Port Phillip Bay changed to [00:53:00] Tal­leyrand Bay

Tony Kynas­ton: Ja

jk: because the French had, had arrived in. Did you know this, that the French had s- kin­da scout­ed the

Cameron: Uh-huh.

jk: a time?

Cameron: Yeah

jk: And this is a return let­ter from Duff Coop­er that says, “Dear sir, thank you very much for your let­ter,” da da dum, “and I com­plete­ly sup­port your efforts to call it Tal­leyrand Bay,” ’cause he knew Duff Coop­er had writ­ten this biog­ra­phy of Tal­leyrand. And, um, the thing was, it was 1939, and, uh, he was head of the admi­ral­ty in the UK, but, uh, guess what? had oth­er fish to fry pret­ty fast after that, so the whole thing was for­got­ten. That’s a kin­da clas­sic. That’s an asso­ci­a­tion copy. You got a lit­tle sto­ry attached to the book, and I have a, quite a few like that. I love, uh. That’s my pet thing.

Tony Kynas­ton: Can,

jk: Com­mer­cial­ly, hard to know.

Tony Kynas­ton: I was gonna say, can I, can I ask what would a book like that be worth?

jk: I don’t know. I mean, uh, it might be worth a few hun­dred dol­lars. It’s not worth a few thou­sand dol­lars. It’s not– This is not big game stuff, I’m afraid. [00:54:00] Um, yes, you’d have. A thou­sand dol­lars on a book is a lot. Um, so it’s not, you’re not deal­ing in big, big num­bers here. It’s, uh, because that’s a. The asso­ci­a­tion is of inter­est to me, but per­haps not to a wide. want a real asso­ci­a­tion copy. I saw a, a piece in the press about a year ago where they found, uh, Miller, writer, his copy, his per­son­al copy uh, of his, of the Torah, and he had writ­ten for Mar­i­lyn Mon­roe, who he was mar­ried to at the time, and he had his lit­tle notes, all his lit­tle notes on the side for Mar­i­lyn Mon­roe for her to learn how it all worked.

That’s what you call an asso­ci­a­tion copy.

Cameron: Wow

jk: like. That would be worth, pick a num­ber. The

Cameron: Wow. Wow.

jk: bet­ter.

Tony Kynas­ton: That’s, that’s incred­i­ble

Cameron: Yeah, so one of the, the first his­to­ry pod­casts, if not the first [00:55:00] his­to­ry pod­cast ever made, I made 20-odd years ago, which was a long series I did on Napoleon. met my wife, I met my wife at a Napoleon con­fer­ence in Cor­si­ca. Tony, before Tony and I ever knew each oth­er, he lis­tened to my Napoleon pod­cast.

jk: Is

Cameron: So yeah, yeah, Napoleon

Tony Kynas­ton: Where Cameron and I went back to Cor­si­ca a few years ago. Mm.

jk: so?

Cameron: yeah.

jk: Well, I

Cameron: So there you go.

jk: guy, so, so

Cameron: Good pick

jk: you, see, you

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

jk: Good pick. You nev­er

Cameron: Yeah, yeah.

jk: inter­est­ed in these books. Might be worth more than I thought

Cameron: Ah, yeah, if I had any mon­ey I would, uh, I’d make you an offer. I know peo­ple who are big, big col­lec­tors of Napoleon­ic, uh, stuff though, so

jk: I think Michael, uh, Kroger is. Was it Michael Kroger or

Cameron: I’ve,

jk: his.

Cameron: I inter­viewed, he did. I inter­viewed Michael Kroger about his Napoleon­ic col­lec­tion many years ago. Yeah.

jk: you go.

Cameron: He was a big Napoleon buff, sur­pris­ing­ly.

jk: you nev­er know who you’re talk­ing to

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh

Cameron: right. Well, we got­ta let you go ’cause I know you have com­mit­ments, James. It’s [00:56:00] been an absolute plea­sure. We’ve been a fan of your work for many years.

We’ve had your old, uh, part­ner in crime on our show a few times, Mr. Kohler,

jk: Alan,

Cameron: now off doing his thing with his, uh, son, Chris

jk: They’ve been want­i­ng to do that for a long time, so it’s great to see that, uh,

Cameron: Yeah

jk: that up and run­ning. And, and, and, and I am a fan of you guys’ work. I think it’s great. I think there’s a lot of city pod­casts out there. They’re doing not much good for most peo­ple real­ly. And, and what you’re doing is, is, is emi­nent­ly use­ful and sen­si­ble. So thanks for that

Cameron: Well, thank you very

Tony Kynas­ton: Thank you, James. Yeah.

Cameron: James.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, any­time.

Cameron: right,

Tony Kynas­ton: We could do a whole episode on your book col­lec­tion. That’d be great.

Cameron: Yeah, that would be great.

jk: on YouTube, huh?

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah. Yeah.

Cameron: Well, we are on YouTube. Yeah. Thank you, James.

Tony Kynas­ton: Thank you.

Cameron: your day. Thanks for com­ing on

Tony Kynas­ton: Plea­sure

Cameron: Well, that was fun

Tony Kynas­ton: It was very good. Draw­ing Napoleon back into things.

Cameron: Eh,

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: Not a f- not a [00:57:00] fan of Tal­leyrand,

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: emi­nent­ly, uh, good diplo­mat, clever guy, but, uh, betray- betray­er of Napoleon.

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh

Cameron: No, so he’s not a, he’s not, uh, not very pop­u­lar in Napoleon­ic cir­cles. Well, uh, any­thing else we need to talk about? Oh, are we doing our own after hours before we go, Tony?

I’ve had, I’ve had a bonkers cou­ple of weeks, man. Um, but I’ll let you start before

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, I’ve got noth­ing. I’ve just been so busy.

Cameron: So busy?

Tony Kynas­ton: yeah, uh, ha-haven’t had time to watch much. Bob Land is prob­a­bly just the high­light every week. Jen­ny and I tune into that. It’s get­ting bet­ter and bet­ter. Um, real­ly good.

Cameron: I’ve

Tony Kynas­ton: But that’s about it

Cameron: I. But I think, what, what’s it on? Is it Apple or Para­mount or

Tony Kynas­ton: Para­mount.

Cameron: I don’t have.

Tony Kynas­ton: it’s a sep­a­rate sub­scrip­tion, unfor­tu­nate­ly. So you prob­a­bly wan­na wait till Series 3’s fin­ished and then just sub­scribe for a month and clear it all.

It’s a good way to do it, yeah

Cameron: I start­ed on [00:58:00] Fitz­car­ral­do. I’m still

Tony Kynas­ton: Ah.

Cameron: through it. Oh my God, so great. And then I found a copy of My Best Fiend on YouTube.

Tony Kynas­ton: Best friend.

Cameron: no, it’s called

Tony Kynas­ton: It’s called Fiend, is it? Oh, okay.

Cameron: So

Tony Kynas­ton: Wind ven­dors and yeah.

Cameron: of weeks ago. No, no, uh, Wern­er

Tony Kynas­ton: Wern­er Her­zog, sor­ry.

Cameron: doc­u­men­tary about his rela­tion­ship with Klaus Kin­s­ki.

Tony Kynas­ton: You found it.

Cameron: I think. He’s cer­tain­ly up there. He’s up there with Paci­no and De Niro and

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm.

Cameron: I was like, “Nico­las Cage has got­ta be a fan of this guy.” And I saw that Nico­las Cage does refer to him­self as the Amer­i­can Klaus

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, real­ly?

Cameron: Yeah. And of course, he made a film with Wern­er Her­zog 20 years ago, Bad Lieu­tenant: Port of Call New Orleans, which I did see 20 years ago, in 2009, I think it was. rela­tion­ship to the orig­i­nal Abel Fer­rara Bad Lieu­tenant film with Har­vey Kei­t­el

Tony Kynas­ton: Which is [00:59:00] great. Mm-hmm

Cameron: is great and dis­gust­ing and filthy and appalling and debauched. But, um, yeah, I mean, My Best Fiend just f- I’m only halfway through it, but fan­tas­tic.

Tony Kynas­ton: So it’s on YouTube, is it?

Cameron: Yeah. Yes,

Tony Kynas­ton: Okay.

Cameron: find

Tony Kynas­ton: find it. Yeah

Cameron: It’s was­n’t on SBS or any­thing, which is where I’m watch­ing the films. I also, on YouTube, there’s all this Klaus Kin­s­ki stuff, includ­ing him, h- an appear­ance of him on Let­ter­man in 1983, which is com­plete­ly unhinged. Um, just fan­tas­tic.

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: Um, at, at one point in the mid­dle of the inter­view, he com­plains to Dave that nobody brought him the cof­fee that he asked for, and Dav­e’s scram­bling to get some­one to bring him a cof­fee ’cause he’s scared that he’s gonna pull out a gun and start shoot­ing peo­ple or some­thing. It’s, um. Yeah, absolute­ly. Like his per­for­mances are just. He does­n’t have to say any­thing. [01:00:00] Like this– And did you know he was in a Fist­ful of Dol­lars?

Tony Kynas­ton: No, real­ly?

Cameron: There’s

Tony Kynas­ton: did not

Cameron: No, I did not. I, I’d for­got­ten. I mean, I did­n’t rec­og­nize him prob­a­bly at the time. So there’s a clip on YouTube, look it up. It’s a, there’s a, it’s just a bar scene. Clint walks into this bar, and then Lee Van Cleef comes walk­ing down the stairs inside the bar, and he walks up to three guys stand­ing at the bar drink­ing. Two Mex­i­can-look­ing guys, and a guy with weird­ly blonde hair. And he strikes a match on the, um, gun strap of

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

Cameron: with the blonde hair to light his pipe, and that guy turns around, and it’s Klaus Kin­s­ki. And he does­n’t say any­thing, he just looks at him with this. And his, his mouth is quiv­er­ing, and he just looks at Lee Van Cleef like he wants to kill him. And Lee Van Cleef just [01:00:00] to light his pipe, and Klaus Kin­s­ki blows out the match. And Van Cleef is just calm as a cucum­ber, and then takes the cig­a­r­il­lo out of Kin­ski’s mouth and goes to light his pipe with the, with his cig­a­r­il­lo. And Kin­s­ki has no dia­logue, but just looks like he’s gonna absolute­ly explode. And Lee Van Cleef is just cool as a cucum­ber, and, and he, and Kin­ski’s hand goes to his gun, and one of his ban­di­do friends puts his hand on his gun, and he, they’re look­ing around, and he knows who Lee Van Cleef is, obvi­ous­ly, and you don’t wan­na mess with him.

And, and, and Clin­t’s just stand­ing in the cor­ner tak­ing this all in, and it’s just fan­tas­tic. But Kin­s­ki, man, he’s just so great. Like, absolute­ly bat­shit crazy, um, obvi­ous­ly. So, the, the, the, the My Best Fiend doc­u­men­tary opens with Kin­ski’s Jesus stage show. You ever heard about this?

Tony Kynas­ton: No

Cameron: In the ear­ly ’70s, I think it was ’71, did this thing in Ger­many.

I’m not sure if he [01:02:00] toured with it or if it was a one-off. But he got up on stage and just did this per­for­mance in front of this audi­ence where he was Jesus Unscript­ed, I think. Um, basi­cal­ly Jesus come back to tell every­body how they were going wrong, and he’s in just- he’s just dressed in jeans and a shirt, just in char­ac­ter as Jesus, and just rant­i­ng and rav­ing and, uh, like, should have.

He made, like, 180 films. I don’t think he ever played Hitler, but he should have played Hitler

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: had Hitler down to a T with his rant­i­ng and rav­ing. Um, and then peo­ple come up on stage and try and argue with him, and he just grabs the micro­phone and starts scream­ing abuse at them and telling them to shut up, and how dare they chal­lenge him. so he went straight from doing that, I think, to mak­ing Aguirre.

Tony Kynas­ton: Uh-huh

Cameron: And Kin­s­ki, in the doc­u­men­tary, just talks about, yeah, he basi­cal­ly was still in char­ac­ter, [01:03:00] think­ing he was the Mes­si­ah who could n- And there’s these record­ings that the sound engi­neer on Aguirre secret­ly took of Kin­s­ki argu­ing with Her­zog and telling him that he has to treat him with more respect and just let him do what­ev­er he wants.

And David Lean asked his advice, and, uh, Bertolt Brecht asked his advice, and Her­zog will ask his advice, too. And Her­zog’s like, “I’m not going to do that.” And he’s like, “Ah!” Oh, it’s just m-

Tony Kynas­ton: I’ll have to look it up. I mean, that’s the amaz­ing thing in this day and age. I mean, back in the ’70s or ’80s when we was watch­ing these movies, Fitz­car­ral­do and Aguirre, it’s like that’s all we had of Klaus Kin­s­ki. You know? There might be a mag­a­zine arti­cle or an inter­view or some­thing, but we’re like going, “Wow, this guy’s wild.

He’s great.” But you know, we did­n’t see David Let­ter­man clips or

Cameron: No.

Tony Kynas­ton: My Best Fiend or what­ev­er, or Jesus Christ videos. Yeah

Cameron: Well, like I, I, [01:04:00] I spend more time these days watch­ing, know, lis­ten­ing to Taran­ti­no talk about his films than I

Tony Kynas­ton: Ooh.

Cameron: his films, right?

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm.

Cameron: you- so much com­men­tary and analy­sis out there that Yeah, so any­way, such a, I’m in such a deep Klaus Kin­s­ki, um, rab­bit hole right now, and I wan­na watch all of his films that he ever yeah, made. I saw a clip. There’s a clip of Bill Had­er talk­ing about a film that he made, that Kin­s­ki made with, um, uh, oh, shit, who was the oth­er alco­holic guy in the ’70s? Um, in The Three Mus­ke­teers.

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, Oliv­er Reed?

Cameron: Oliv­er Reed.

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah.

Cameron: He and Oliv­er Reed made a

Tony Kynas­ton: Real­ly?

Cameron: like, a s- called Ven­om, about some snake. It’s like a h- a cheap, no-bud­get hor­ror film. And Bill Hader’s talk­ing about it going, “You’ve got Oliv­er Reed and Klaus Kin­s­ki in a low-bud­get hor­ror film about a killer snake. [01:05:00] Like, what’s not to love? Like, how can you go wrong

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh, that’d be great.

Cameron: Yeah. Which I got­ta try and track down. Appar­ent­ly, Kin­ski’s last film was some­thing he wrote, direct­ed, and starred in called Pagani­ni, where he plays Pagani­ni, and it’s basi­cal­ly just a hard­core porn film

Tony Kynas­ton: Ja

Cameron: Pagani­ni hav­ing sex with all of these women because they’re attract­ed to his Do you know who Pagani­ni was? Maybe I

Tony Kynas­ton: The oper­at­ing clown

Cameron: No. No, no, no. No, it was, um- Pagli­ac­ci. Um, no, Pagani­ni was a demon­ic vio­lin­ist. Um, very famous vio­lin­ist in like, um, I’m guess­ing the 18th cen­tu­ry. yeah. the, the sto­ry was that he sold his soul to the dev­il to be able to. Before Robert John­son, he

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah, cross­roads

Cameron: dev­il to be able to play vio­lin like that, and so yeah.

So Kin­s­ki made this film [01:06:00] about him, which I can’t find on stream­ing. I’m gonna have to track it down some­where. But it sounds com­plete­ly bonkers. Absolute­ly bonkers. I read, I read the Wikipedia page on it. Yeah, before he died trag­i­cal­ly quite young, 1991. when I say quite trag­i­cal­ly, both of his daugh­ters say that if he was still alive, they’d try and have him put in prison for life because he was sex­u­al- sex abuser, and

Tony Kynas­ton: mm.

Cameron: and all this sort of stuff, so. not a very nice guy to any­one. But, um, yeah, he was able to put all of that on screen. “Read­ing Dan­ger­ous Liaisons or Les Liaisons Dan­gereuses. You ever read that, the

Tony Kynas­ton: No,

Cameron: Oh, fan. I gave up on, um, gave up on, uh, the Mar­quis de Sade. It was just

Tony Kynas­ton: Yeah

Cameron: samey after a while. It was just, you know, sex­u­al, um, debauch­ery, um, page after page after page after page and, you know.

It’s shock­ing at first, then after 50 pages it’s like, [01:07:00] “Yeah, okay, I get it. just debauch­ery. I get it. Amoral debauch­ery, okay.” Dan­ger­ous Liaisons the nov­el is, uh, amaz­ing. It’s epis­to­lary, epis­to­lary nov­el. It’s just let­ters back­wards and for­wards from

Tony Kynas­ton: Mm-hmm

Cameron: main char­ac­ters, and it’s deli­cious­ly evil.

You’ve seen the film I’m sure, the Stephen Frears film.

Tony Kynas­ton: I have not.

Cameron: John

Tony Kynas­ton: Did­n’t, did­n’t have an inter­est in it. Just,

Cameron: Real­ly. Oh, I saw it when it came out, like in my ear­ly 20s I guess I saw it and, uh, yeah, absolute mas­ter­piece. Like, Jo- Malkovich, Glenn Close, Michelle Pfeif­fer, Uma Thur­man, and a very young Keanu Reeves. French nobil­i­ty just being deli­cious­ly evil.

Um, cor­rupt­ing the morals of good upstand­ing Catholics, uh, seduc­ing them. Yeah, real­ly, real­ly good. The book’s great. Lov­ing it. And I’m lis­ten­ing to Shostakovich’s 14th Sym­pho­ny-

Tony Kynas­ton: There’s a 14th? Wow.

Cameron: Ah,

Tony Kynas­ton: Scal- How-

Cameron: 15.

Tony Kynas­ton: There’s 15. [01:08:00] Okay. All

Cameron: 14th is 1969. He he was about to die, just come out of months in hos­pi­tal.

He’d had a heart attack, he had polio,

Tony Kynas­ton: Oh

Cameron: and it’s, it’s on the theme of death. It’s set to, like, sev­en poems about death, and it is absolute­ly bonkers. fre­net­i­cal­ly bo- it’s basi­cal­ly Klaus Kin­s­ki. If Klaus Kin­s­ki was a sym­pho­ny, it would be Shostakovich’s 14th Sym­pho­ny. lev­el of man­ic, fre­net­ic ener­gy and pas­sion and anger. Any­way, yeah, so I’ve had a great week. Okay.

Tony Kynas­ton: Okay. All right. Well, I can’t con­tribute much more than that. Can’t top that

Cameron: You’ve moved in. How did your hors­es go this week? Any horse news?

Tony Kynas­ton: No, I was– we were sup­posed to have, uh, Lake For­est run­ning last Sat­ur­day, but it got too wet, so he scratched and he’ll run this Sat­ur­day. So might be worth a bet. We’ll [01:09:00] see.

Cameron: Okay.

Tony Kynas­ton: Hmm.

Cameron: Thank you, TK. Let’s

Tony Kynas­ton: All right. Okay, bye

Cameron: Hap­py hunt­ing

QAV LIGHT

Same destination. You choose where you sit.

Click the pic­ture to learn more!

QAV Light — cockpit